Hard on the heels of the emergence of any new technology come hoards of politicians, like so many moths to the flame of Prometheus, eager to regulate the new innovation. The resulting policies in some instances are sensible, even necessary; and yet, in many others, the hurry to regulate smothers young technologies, depriving ordinary people of many, if not all, of the advantages that new product or service might have brought about.
Wearable devices, such as smartglasses, have arrived on the market, and the heavy tread of regulators close behind already is audible. California’s S.B. 1130, an early effort to regulate wearables, would impose strictures on the devices that do not bind technologies with similar capacities, such as smartphones.
The bill, having been approved by both houses of the state legislature, now lingers on Gavin Newsom’s desk. “Early policy approaches that target wearables treat them either as generalized ‘surveillance devices’ because they include sensors or cameras, or as ‘consumer toys’ that obscure their significant economic, healthcare, and accessibility value,” write Taylor Barkley and Neil Chilson of the Abundance Institute. The presumptions of such an approach cannot survive scrutiny.
Economics teaches that the fundamental event in a dynamic market is discovery: the entrepreneurs dreaming up or stumbling upon novel insights, business models, strategies, or technologies. He does not anticipate the exact contours of such advances prior to the instant of discovery, and the merits of his new ideas are tested and tempered by competition, success being heralded by the approbation of consumers, demonstrated by profit. To put it differently, prosperity progresses as entrepreneurs generate new knowledge, an act of creativity and imagination.
Digital technologies, particularly wearables, have rendered this process of knowledge creation more collaborative. After a device is developed and brought to market, others — e.g., software developers, business users, individuals — begin their work, discovering new and potential uses for the device. Manufacturers have, at the most, profoundly imperfect knowledge of the eventual uses to which their products will be put. What wearables are to be — that is, what tasks they can perform and what new capabilities third-party-developed companion software can create — will depend greatly upon the experimentation and ingenuity of actors other than device manufacturers. The process of discovery — of knowledge generation — has been rendered collaborative, a joint venture between device manufacturers, third-parties, and users.
For instance, Meta, as it developed its Ray-Ban smartglasses, could not have foreseen the device’s use to provide “real-time, step-by-step instruction and safety training” to new construction workers. Nor could the company have foreseen its use to assist roadside emergency-response mechanics’ diagnostic efforts — or to analyze crop conditions to aid farmers, or to provide safety instructions to workers deploying rural broadband infrastructure at great heights, heights at which handheld devices cannot safely be used. Americans enduring the early stages of dementia and the cognitively impaired may soon expect access to a digital assistant, called OurLife, which will utilize the Meta glasses. Projects are also underway to develop new tools to provide assistance to the blind and the deaf.
These ideas did not originate in the minds of Meta employees. The company, understanding the model of collaborative knowledge generation, has issued grants to fund these innovations. As other companies bring their own products to market and into competition with the Meta Ray-Bans — Google’s offering, for one, will appear this fall — new creative energies are likely to be unleashed and the benefits enjoyed by American businesses and consumers to multiply.
Cliches have it that “tomorrow is a mystery,” “the future is uncertain,” and “the only things that are certain are death and taxes.” All are true. But when observing the restless creative dynamism of the entrepreneurial mind, another cliche is more apt: “expect the unexpected.” No one can say precisely what innovations will appear in the decades to come, but they are sure to improve the lives of the American people, helping businesses to be more profitable and productive, and the sick and disabled to find comfort and fulfillment.
This process can be halted if lawmakers cannot assuage the anxieties that often attach, bramble-like, to the uncertainty that often pervades periods of intense innovation. If ill-conceived regulation asphyxiates the forces of innovation, America will be left poorer, sicker, blander, greyer. As Calvin Coolidge said famously, “the chief business of the American people is business.” Have at it, I say.