It started as a dull throb in the economy, with the pain growing sharper. Now there's finally a diagnosis: Runaway healthcare costs are directly harming businesses and their employees.
As just about everybody knows, the cost of healthcare is rising much faster than wages, profits, and most other things in the economy. Healthcare spending accounted for about 11 percent of GDP in 1987; today it's more than 16 percent, and by 2017 it's very likely to be almost 20 percent. We spend more than $2 trillion a year on healthcare—roughly the same amount we spend on housing—and the cost is rising about five times faster than wages or overall inflation. Exorbitant cost is the main reason 47 million Americans have no health insurance—and why President Obama's ambitious plan to expand coverage and overhaul the entire system is in jeopardy.
[Read about the trouble with healthcare reform, in numbers.]
Somebody has to absorb those painful price hikes every year, and since companies provide the insurance for about 60 percent of Americans, they're the first to get the bill. Some economists believe that businesses simply shift the cost of health insurance to workers, by offering lower wages to compensate for the costly benefit, and to their customers, by charging higher prices to cover the costs of healthcare.
A new study, however, shows that some industries have become chronically hamstrung by rising healthcare costs, with lower growth and employment than they'd have if costs were lower—or somebody else paid them. Researchers Neeraj Sood, Arkadipta Ghosh, and José J. Escarce of the Rand Corp. analyzed the performance of 38 industries from 1987 to 2005 and found that sectors where a high proportion of workers have company-provided health insurance—such as manufacturing, utilities, communications, education, and finance—showed the lowest growth over the 19-year period. Industries where fewer workers get company-paid health insurance—such as agriculture, hotels, entertainment, retail, and construction—grew more.
Since some industries naturally grow faster than others, the researchers isolated other factors that could explain the discrepancy. They also compared U.S. industries with their counterparts in Canada—where the government, not business, pays for healthcare—to see if the entire industry was suppressed because of global trends or just the American slice. Their conclusion: Rising healthcare costs in the United States have directly curtailed growth and employment. And the industries with the most generous benefits tend to be penalized for it. "Industries which provide healthcare to a large fraction of workers didn't grow as fast as industries offering health insurance to a small fraction of workers," says Sood.
[See 8 industries that will sit out an economic recovery.]
The Rand study may be the first to document the impact of rising healthcare costs on business performance, but it reinforces lots of anecdotal evidence. Starbucks CEO Howard Schultz has complained that his company spends more on worker benefits than on coffee. General Motors has claimed that healthcare expenses add $1,500 to the cost of making a car. Only 59 percent of small firms offer health insurance to their employees, down from 68 percent in 2000. Many business owners say they limit hiring or try to get by with part-timers because the costs of full-time benefits are too high. The prospect that Obama's reforms could actually raise costs on many businesses, to help cover the uninsured, has undermined support for his plan.
Rand quantifies the effect this way: At 2005 GDP levels, every 10 percent increase in "excess" healthcare costs—the amount by which growth in healthcare costs exceeds GDP growth—would cost the economy 120,800 jobs and $28 billion in lost revenues. The researchers caution against extrapolating their data to estimate total jobs lost throughout the whole economy to excessive healthcare costs. But they did some other nifty calculations, showing how employment and output would change in 15 industries if healthcare costs do indeed rise to 20 percent of GDP by 2017, as many economists expect unless there's dramatic reform. (These figures aren't part of the study; Neeraj Sood of Rand provided them to me upon request. Data is from 2004 and 2005, the latest available.)
[See 11 places with a worse economy than ours.]
One startling outcome of the Rand projections is that every one of the 15 industries they analyzed stands to suffer lost jobs and output if healthcare expenses keep rising. Agriculture and forestry, where just 19 percent of workers have company-paid insurance, would shrink the least. Utilities, which cover 83 percent of their workers, would shrink the most. Here's how 15 major industries would fare if healthcare costs swell to 20 percent of GDP by 2017:
One industry, of course, stands to gain plenty of jobs: healthcare. And benefit costs shouldn't be too much of a constraint, since the healthcare industry has one of the lowest rates of insurance coverage. Before long, it seems, everybody in America will either be a caregiver or a patient.
Tags: healthcare
Tools: Share | | Comments (3) | Print
Close Social Web E-mail del.icio.us Digg Facebook Netscape Yahoo! My Web Technorati Google Bookmarks Newsvine BlinkList reddit Blogmarks ma.gnolia Windows Live Tailrank E-mail It To Address: Your Name: Your Address: « Why 'Cash for Clunkers' Will Keep on Rolling Reader Comments Read all 3 comments about this article Here Here!!!I just do not understand why people aren't rallying with the President to reform this broken system. I have health insurance, but it is basically useless! It is what is known as "catastophic" coverage - I have a sky high deductible, no prescription benefits, and I feel like a complete fool every month for paying for it!! Oh, and the rates go up ALL THE TIME!! If anybody opposes heath care reform, you know they are in the pocket of lobbyists and the insurance vultures!!
Lisa of LA Aug 05, 2009 10:55:52 AM [permalink] [report comment] Health ReformWe need Single Payer--yesterday!!! Wake up America!
Dorene Robinson of WA Aug 05, 2009 10:46:12 AM [permalink] [report comment] I have been saying for yearsthat there is nothing better we could do FOR BUSINESS than adopt single-payer national health care financed by taxes and premiums charged to individuals.
This study seems to support that notion and frankly, it's hard to understand why this is not ridiculously obvious to everyone.
Muser of NM Aug 04, 2009 20:27:08 PM [permalink] [report comment] Read all 3 comments about this article Add your thoughts Subject: Type your comments here: (3000 characters left) Your name: Your E-mail address: State: Choose State AL - Alabama AK - Alaska AZ - Arizona AR - Arkansas CA - California CO - Colorado CT - Connecticut DE - Delaware DC - District of Columbia FL - Florida GA - Georgia HI - Hawaii ID - Idaho IL - Illinois IN - Indiana IA - Iowa KS - Kansas KY - Kentucky LA - Louisiana ME - Maine MD - Maryland MA - Massachusetts MI - Michigan MN - Minnesota MS - Mississippi MO - Missouri MT - Montana NE - Nebraska NV - Nevada NH - New Hampshire NJ - New Jersey NM - New Mexico NY - New York NC - North Carolina ND - North Dakota OH - Ohio OK - Oklahoma OR - Oregon PA - Pennsylvania RI - Rhode Island SC - South Carolina SD - South Dakota TN - Tennessee TX - Texas UT - Utah VT - Vermont VA - Virginia WA - Washington WV - West Virginia WI - Wisconsin WY - Wyoming International Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.advertisement
dblclick('leaderboardB'); About this blog Send an E-mail to flowchart@usnews.com. The global economy is mysterious, even scary. Chief Business Correspondent Rick Newman connects the dots. In addition to his writing for U.S. News, Rick is the co-author of two books: Firefight: Inside the Battle to Save the Pentagon on 9/11, and Bury Us Upside Down: The Misty Pilots and the Secret Battle for the Ho Chi Minh Trail. Tell him what concerns you: flowchart@usnews.com.advertisement
dblclick('rectangleA'); OTHER ARTICLES FROM THE RICK NEWMAN BLOG Recent Posts Archive Why 'Cash for Clunkers' Will Keep on Rolling Where Bailout Money Goes to Die The Trouble With Healthcare Reform, In Numbers 6 Small Steps Toward a More Normal Economy 8 Industries That Will Sit Out a Recovery August 2009 (2) July 2009 (10) June 2009 (21) May 2009 (23) April 2009 (20) March 2009 (26) February 2009 (22) January 2009 (23) December 2008 (20) November 2008 (14) October 2008 (17) September 2008 (17) August 2008 (9) July 2008 (9) June 2008 (10) May 2008 (7) April 2008 (7) March 2008 (7) February 2008 (4) January 2008 (5) December 2007 (3) November 2007 (3) October 2007 (4) September 2007 (3) USN.load('Widget'); Event.observe(window, 'load', function(){ USN.Widget.tab(USN.Widget, $('tab_interface')); }); NEWSLETTERSign up today for the latest headlines from U.S. News & World Report delivered to you free.
Learn More RSS FEEDSPersonalize your U.S. News with our feeds of blogs and breaking news headlines.
Subscribe U.S. NEWS MOBILEU.S. News daily briefings are also available on your mobile device.
Subscribe People who read this also read ...Solutions for Business
USN.load('RandomOrderList'); Business Intelligence: Thriving in Economic Uncertainty In an uncertain economy, many companies feel the pinch of reduced business activity. READ how Business Intelligence can help make smarter operational decisions. Navigating a Turbulent Economy Times of economic turbulence may bring renewal to organizations. READ what Microsoft Corporation suggests as several starting points. Unified Messaging: A Better Solution For today's decision makers, UM is the preferred solution for telephone call answering and voice messages in most enterprises. READ how this evolution occurred. Creating Business Value Through Better Collaboration Information workers use multiple tools to collaborate today, e-mail, phone, web conferencing, portals, and specialized point collaboration applications. READ more about Microsoft's virtual workspace software solutions Twelve Ways to Reduce Costs with SQL Server. Many Organizations are dealing with challenges in the tough economic climate. READ twelve ways organizations can use Microsoft SQL Server 2008 to save time and money. Mobilizing Microsoft Dynamics CRM In today's competitive world, organizations that implement Mobile CRM have a strong business advantage. READ how Mobilizing Microsoft Dynamics CRM benefits businesses, users, administrators, and developers.
Job Search Find your dream job today! Browse thousands of job postings.Popular: Government Jobs, Sales Jobs, Accounting Jobs, Healthcare Jobs, Consulting Jobs Jobs by SimplyHired Event.observe(window,'load',SHformfill);
advertisement
dblclick('rectangleB'); Best of Flowchart How to Tell if You're Rich Greenspan vs. Buffett 4 Myths About Free Markets"”and Their Demise The Need for Greed 5 Upsides of $4 Gas Economic Recession, Consumer Depression Why More Saudi Oil Could Harm American Consumers Economic Upswing? Ask Again in a Year What Springsteen Can Teach CEOs 6 Myths About Oil Speculatorsvar simplyhired_widget = {}; //simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Green OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; try { var blogFromURL = document.location.href.split('/blogs/')[1].split('/')[0]; } catch (error) { if (error instanceof TypeError) { //'/blog/' is not in url var blogFromURL = ''; } } switch (blogFromURL) { case 'fresh-greens': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Environmental'; break; case 'the-ticker': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'new-money': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'alpha-consumer': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-best-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'capital-commerce': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'daves-download': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Tech OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'flowchart': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-home-front': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Real estate OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'luxe-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'on-careers': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'outside-voices-small-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'planning-to-retire': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'risky-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-inside-job': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; default: simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Consulting'; } simplyhired_widget.partner = 'usnews'; simplyhired_widget.location = ''; simplyhired_widget.num_jobs = '7'; simplyhired_widget.stylesheet = 'http://static.usnews.com/css/simplyhired.css'; simplyhired_widget.height = '400px'; simplyhired_widget.header = 'Related Jobs Near You'; keywordslocation Job search powered by Simply Hired
Amazon.com Widgets
Nation & World | Health | Money & Business | Education | Opinion | Science | Photo | Video | RankingsCopyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Subscriber Services | Site Map | About Us | Contact Us | Newsletters | Marketplace | Find your dream job today! Browse thousands of job postings.Popular: Government Jobs, Sales Jobs, Accounting Jobs, Healthcare Jobs, Consulting Jobs Jobs by SimplyHired Event.observe(window,'load',SHformfill);
advertisement
dblclick('rectangleB'); Best of Flowchart How to Tell if You're Rich Greenspan vs. Buffett 4 Myths About Free Markets"”and Their Demise The Need for Greed 5 Upsides of $4 Gas Economic Recession, Consumer Depression Why More Saudi Oil Could Harm American Consumers Economic Upswing? Ask Again in a Year What Springsteen Can Teach CEOs 6 Myths About Oil Speculatorsvar simplyhired_widget = {}; //simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Green OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; try { var blogFromURL = document.location.href.split('/blogs/')[1].split('/')[0]; } catch (error) { if (error instanceof TypeError) { //'/blog/' is not in url var blogFromURL = ''; } } switch (blogFromURL) { case 'fresh-greens': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Environmental'; break; case 'the-ticker': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'new-money': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'alpha-consumer': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-best-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'capital-commerce': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'daves-download': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Tech OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'flowchart': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-home-front': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Real estate OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'luxe-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'on-careers': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'outside-voices-small-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'planning-to-retire': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'risky-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-inside-job': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; default: simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Consulting'; } simplyhired_widget.partner = 'usnews'; simplyhired_widget.location = ''; simplyhired_widget.num_jobs = '7'; simplyhired_widget.stylesheet = 'http://static.usnews.com/css/simplyhired.css'; simplyhired_widget.height = '400px'; simplyhired_widget.header = 'Related Jobs Near You'; keywordslocation Job search powered by Simply Hired
Amazon.com Widgets
Nation & World | Health | Money & Business | Education | Opinion | Science | Photo | Video | RankingsCopyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Subscriber Services | Site Map | About Us | Contact Us | Newsletters | Marketplace | Store | Advertise With Us | Press Room | Masthead | Widgets | RSS |Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy. Make USNews.com your home page.
var dc_AdLinkColor = '#005497' ; var dc_PublisherID = 74751 ; var dc_isBoldActive = 'no' ; USN.load('Analytics'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('nav-search'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('newsletters'); DM_tag();Popular: Government Jobs, Sales Jobs, Accounting Jobs, Healthcare Jobs, Consulting Jobs Jobs by SimplyHired Event.observe(window,'load',SHformfill);
advertisement
dblclick('rectangleB'); Best of Flowchart How to Tell if You're Rich Greenspan vs. Buffett 4 Myths About Free Markets"”and Their Demise The Need for Greed 5 Upsides of $4 Gas Economic Recession, Consumer Depression Why More Saudi Oil Could Harm American Consumers Economic Upswing? Ask Again in a Year What Springsteen Can Teach CEOs 6 Myths About Oil Speculatorsvar simplyhired_widget = {}; //simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Green OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; try { var blogFromURL = document.location.href.split('/blogs/')[1].split('/')[0]; } catch (error) { if (error instanceof TypeError) { //'/blog/' is not in url var blogFromURL = ''; } } switch (blogFromURL) { case 'fresh-greens': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Environmental'; break; case 'the-ticker': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'new-money': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Finance OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'alpha-consumer': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-best-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'capital-commerce': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'daves-download': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Tech OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'flowchart': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Government OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-home-front': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Real estate OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'luxe-life': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'on-careers': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'outside-voices-small-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'planning-to-retire': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Retirement OR Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'risky-business': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; case 'the-inside-job': simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Sales OR Accounting OR Healthcare OR Consulting'; break; default: simplyhired_widget.keywords = 'Consulting'; } simplyhired_widget.partner = 'usnews'; simplyhired_widget.location = ''; simplyhired_widget.num_jobs = '7'; simplyhired_widget.stylesheet = 'http://static.usnews.com/css/simplyhired.css'; simplyhired_widget.height = '400px'; simplyhired_widget.header = 'Related Jobs Near You'; keywordslocation Job search powered by Simply Hired
Amazon.com Widgets
Nation & World | Health | Money & Business | Education | Opinion | Science | Photo | Video | RankingsCopyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Subscriber Services | Site Map | About Us | Contact Us | Newsletters | Marketplace | Store | Advertise With Us | Press Room | Masthead | Widgets | RSS |Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy. Make USNews.com your home page.
var dc_AdLinkColor = '#005497' ; var dc_PublisherID = 74751 ; var dc_isBoldActive = 'no' ; USN.load('Analytics'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('nav-search'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('newsletters'); DM_tag();advertisement
keywordslocation Job search powered by Simply Hired
Amazon.com Widgets
Nation & World | Health | Money & Business | Education | Opinion | Science | Photo | Video | RankingsCopyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Subscriber Services | Site Map | About Us | Contact Us | Newsletters | Marketplace | Store | Advertise With Us | Press Room | Masthead | Widgets | RSS |Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy. Make USNews.com your home page.
var dc_AdLinkColor = '#005497' ; var dc_PublisherID = 74751 ; var dc_isBoldActive = 'no' ; USN.load('Analytics'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('nav-search'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('newsletters'); DM_tag();Amazon.com Widgets
Nation & World | Health | Money & Business | Education | Opinion | Science | Photo | Video | RankingsCopyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Subscriber Services | Site Map | About Us | Contact Us | Newsletters | Marketplace | Store | Advertise With Us | Press Room | Masthead | Widgets | RSS |Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy. Make USNews.com your home page.
var dc_AdLinkColor = '#005497' ; var dc_PublisherID = 74751 ; var dc_isBoldActive = 'no' ; USN.load('Analytics'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('nav-search'); USN.Form.zeroInputField('newsletters'); DM_tag();Copyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.
Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy. Make USNews.com your home page.
Read Full Article »