This blog post originally appeared on RealMoney Silver on Oct. 27 at 7:27 a.m. EDT.
Underpromising and overdelivering is the oldest game in the investor relations handbook, as earnings expectations are often cagily crafted by corporate managements. In turn, many Wall Street analysts, emulating Ralph Wanger's zebras, follow that company guidance in adopting a herd mentality that morphs into a Wall Street consensus. To be sure, I am being somewhat hyperbolic. Not all Wall Street analysts are lemmings or are simply providing maintenance research. There are still (and always will be) research stars. But, in the main, a variant view from the sell-side consensus is relatively rare, as the middle of the Wanger's herd of zebras seems to provide a security blanket to most analysts. This helps to explain why on average over the past decade, over 60% of reporting companies beat consensus, with a range through thick (economic expansion) and thin (economic contraction) of between 45% and 80% beats. So amazingly, even through the very thin (recession), there has never been a single quarter in 40 quarterly periods in which under 45% of reporting companies didn't beat consensus! Admittedly, the improving trend in recent earnings beats (from the low in fourth quarter 2008 of 54% to the current beat rate of over 75%) is important, but it could be argued that the most recent quarter's historically large earnings beat rate might have been favorably impacted by the lowered guidance and reduced expectations made during and immediately after the credit crisis. Even though the percentage beat rate is now at the highest level since third quarter 2006, which had a beat rate of 72%, the fact that over 75% of reporting companies in third quarter 2009 exceeded consensus expectations may be less impressive than has been evinced in this month's endless media celebrations.Leave a comment
SHARE:
Featured Photo Galleries Go to Slideshow ArchiveConnect with TheStreet
Dow Jones S&P 500 NASDAQ 10-Year Note 9,899.63 1,065.69 2,119.67 34.75 Oil * 77.73 UP 31.67 DOWN 1.25 DOWN 22.18 DOWN 0.79 10 Yr 3.48% SPDR Gold 101.76 +0.32% -0.12% -1.04% -2.22% Data delayed 20 minutes More From TheStreet Latest Headlines Top-rated Mutual Funds from TheStreet Ratings Jim Cramer Book Tour Top-rated ETFs from TheStreet Ratings Find returns with the Dividend Calendar Top Rated Stocks from TheStreet Ratings Twitter RSS Facebook YouTube adsonar_placementId=1341369;adsonar_pid=879768;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=320;adsonar_zh=280;adsonar_jv='ads.adsonar.com'; Brokerage Partners YAHOO.util.Event.on(window,"load",function(){ setTimeout(function(){ TSCM.util.attachScript('scr_intellitxt','http://thestreet.us.intellitxt.com/intellitxt/front.asp?ipid=10685'); },1200); }); Sponsored Links Get your credit score in 2 easy steps for free. By Experian Consumer Direct var ads = [ { link:"http://FisherInvestments.click-url.com/INV/go/131834384/direct/01/", text:"How to plan for a secure retirement.", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;218383547;40631616;h", text:"Trade in your printer and get up to $50 from HP.", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;186067846;4639705;x?http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;185806793;24432847;u?http://www.hp.com/sbso/special/instantsavings.html?jumpid=ex_R295_link/kimipgsmb/2Q08LJ/OJ-BDM/printingimaging/instantsavings/TheStreet", text:"Save up to $500 off top-selling HP printers. Click here to save", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.wsod.com/click/8bec9b10877d5d7fd7c0fb6e6a631357/83.45.img.TEXT/", text:"Free stock symbol lookup: Scottrade stock research", trk:'http://ad.wsod.com/embed/8bec9b10877d5d7fd7c0fb6e6a631357/83.45.tk.TEXT/' }, { link:"http://ad.wsod.com/click/8bec9b10877d5d7fd7c0fb6e6a631357/83.45.img.TEXT/", text:"Free stock symbol lookup: Scottrade stock research", trk:'http://ad.wsod.com/embed/8bec9b10877d5d7fd7c0fb6e6a631357/83.45.tk.TEXT/' }, { link:"http://clk.atdmt.com/DEN/go/171694938/direct/01/", text:"Get a guaranteed return. Lock in a great rate on a Citibank CD.", trk:'http://view.atdmt.com/DEN/view/171694938/direct/01/' }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;218390104;41227940;w", text:"Plan with Merrill Lynch", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;219173989;41227940;r", text:"Pursue your goals with help from a Merrill Lynch Advisor", trk:null }, { link:"http://www.goldline.com/d/index.html?id=557&utm_source=thestreet.com&utm_medium=banner&utm_campaign=street-gold-delivered", text:"Goldline.com – A leader in gold investing since 1960.", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;218753205;41757528;l? http://www.optionsxpress.com/?cmpid=tlstreetros", text:"Trade Options, Stocks and Futures in One Account at optionsXpress", trk:null }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;219059876;42243733;o?https://www.blackcard.com/app/japply/lp/26879.jsp?campaignid=0001130&obcreative=0000000&obadloc=006&obchannel=005&ibchannel=03&partnerid=1394&referrerid=STRBWN0004&sid=text", text:"The Visa Black Card. Enjoy 1% Cash Back or Travel. Apply Now!", trk:'http://ad.doubleclick.net/ad/N5928.1199.8344890806521/B3868511.4;sz=1x1' }, { link:"http://clk.atdmt.com/ANY/go/173953744/direct/01/", text:"Take advantage of new opportunities at ups.com/whiteboard", trk:'http://view.atdmt.com/ANY/view/173953744/direct/01/' }, { link:"http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;217859701;36852981;v", text:"Invest with U.S. Trust", trk:null } ]; function __trackingpixel(url){ var ord = Math.floor(Math.random() * 100000000000); if(typeof url != "undefined") { if(url.indexOf('[timestamp]')!= -1) { url = url.replace("[timestamp]", ord); } return ""; } } var counter=-1; var limit = 3; function __write_textlink() { counter++; if(counter >= limit)return; var index = Math.floor(Math.random() * ads.length * 10 % ads.length); var it = ads.splice(index,1); var o = it[0]; document.write(''); document.write( o.text ); document.write( '' ); if(o.trk != null){ document.write(__trackingpixel(o.trk)); } if(ads.length > 0) { __write_textlink(); } else { } }; __write_textlink(); TheStreet Premium Services All Services Action Alerts PLUS Get free access to Cramer's portfolio picks at Action Alerts PLUS - Try it now Free RealMoney Jim Cramer's RealMoney team of 70+ Wall Street pros will give you wealth-building strategies - Get started Free RealMoney Silver Doug Kass + our 5 Premium Services - all in one place - Get a free 14-day trial today Stocks Under $10 David Peltier is ready to help you find affordable Stocks Under $10 which could lead to a big-money payoff - Get access to his portfolio FREE Coming Soon - ETF Action Don Dion's brand new service can help investors at all levels build profitable ETF portfolios - Learn more View Directory Jim Cramer Doug Kass Ron Insana Breakout Stocks Options Alerts Stock Under $10 RealMoney Don Dion's ETF Action Hot Topics: Gold - Fast Money - Apple Tablet - Chevy Volt - Cramer's Picks - Windows 7 - Health Care - Mad Money - Earnings Resources About Us Advertise Corrections Customer Service Employment Investor Relations Make a Suggestion Privacy Policy Readers' Feedback Sitemap Video Sitemap Subscribe Terms of Use Financial News Archive Topic Archive TheStreet Premium Services Compare All Services Jim Cramer's Action Alerts PLUS: Now any level of investor can trade right alongside a Wall Street pro — and enjoy 24/7 access to his portfolio! Learn More Login Ron Insana's Market Movers: Now you can benefit from Ron's highly sophisticated portfolio management strategy — and buy and sell alongside him whenever you wish! Learn More Login RealMoney: Jim Cramer's team of 70+ investment pros offer a daily wealth of fast-breaking market news... analyses... red-hot opportunities...and wealth-building strategies. Learn More Login RealMoney Silver: The genius of Doug Kass + 5 Premium Services = an unrivaled group of expert fundamental analysts, technical analysts, and Wall Street observers. Learn More Login Breakout Stocks: Bryan Ashenberg combines sophisticated screening software with eagle-eye analysis to find small and mid-caps ready to break out! Learn More Login Chairman's Club Deep in the Money Calls Stocks Under $10 Top Gun Trader TheStreet Ratings Daily Swing Trade Top Stocks ETF Shark Alerts Options Alerts try { function DM_onSegsAvailable(segs, cust_id) { for(var i=0;i /** * appends an ad using an existing container as an 'anchor'... works as follows: * 1) DART ads render in containers off screen (ie. #boxAd) * 2) the actual ad (#boxAd) is removed from the DOM and appended to the placeholder (#boxAdContainer) * 3) we kill the absolute positioning on the actual ad (#boxAd) to make it visible * * NOTE: to add something to the lazy loader, add it in TSCM.ads.placeLazyLoadingAds below * * @param adId string the id of the actual ad container (where the DART tag lives) * @param placeholderId string the id of the placeholder element */ TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder = function(adId, placeholderId) { //bail out for invalid args or missing elements if( !YAHOO.lang.isString(adId) || !YAHOO.lang.isString(placeholderId) || !YAHOO.util.Dom.get(adId) || !YAHOO.util.Dom.get(placeholderId) ) { return; //die quietly and make room for more calls to this function }; var ad = YAHOO.util.Dom.get(adId); //store the actual ad DOM element ad.parentNode.removeChild(ad); //remove ad from the DOM YAHOO.util.Dom.get(placeholderId).appendChild(ad); //append the ad to the placeholder ad.style.position = "static"; //show the ad! }; /** * function wrapper that places all DART ads using TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder * if appendToPlaceholder can't find the elements specified, it just returns and is ready for the next call */ TSCM.ads.placeLazyLoadingAds = function() { // DART 1 (banner) TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder('ad728x90', 'bannerContainer'); // DART 1 (expander) TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder('expanderad', 'expanderbar'); //DART 2 TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder('customUnit', 'cauContainer'); //DART 3 TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder('boxAd', 'boxAdContainer'); //DART 4 TSCM.ads.appendToPlaceholder('secondBoxAd', 'secondBoxAdContainer'); }; YAHOO.util.Event.onDOMReady(TSCM.ads.placeLazyLoadingAds);After the Bell
Before the Bell
Booyah! Newsletter
ETF Weekly
Midday Bell
TSC Top Ten Stories Newsletter
University Newsletter
Winners & Losers
TheStreet Mobile Edition
Take Our Tour
Connect with TheStreet
Read Full Article »