Welcome
Home This week's print edition Daily news analysis Opinion All opinion Leaders Letters to the Editor Columns KAL's cartoons Correspondent's diary Economist debates World All world Politics this week United States The Americas Asia Africa Middle East Europe Britain Special reports Business and finance All business and finance Business this week Economics focus Management Economics A-Z Business education All business education Which MBA? Markets and data All markets and data Daily chart Weekly indicators World markets Currencies Rankings Big Mac index Science and technology All science and technology Technology Quarterly Technology Monitor Culture All culture Style guide People People Obituaries Diversions Audio and video Audio and video library Audio edition The World In The World in 2009 The World in 2008 The World in 2007 The World in 2006 The World in 2005 The World in 2004 Research tools All research tools Articles by subject Economics A-Z Special reports Style guide Country briefings All country briefings China India Brazil United States Russia My account home Newsletters and alerts Manage my newsletters Manage my e-mail alerts Manage my RSS feeds Manage special-offer alerts More » Print subscriptions Subscribe to The Economist Renew my subscription Change my print subscription delivery, billing or e-mail address Pay my bill Activate premium online access Report a missing copy Suspend my subscription More » Digital subscriptions Subscribe to Economist.com Manage my subscription Mobile edition Audio edition Download screensaver More » Classifieds and jobs The Economist Group About the Economist Group Economist Intelligence Unit Economist Conferences Intelligent Life CFO Roll Call European Voice EuroFinance Reprints and permissions EIU online store Economist shop
Advertisement
document.write(''); document.write(''); Finance and Economics function toggle(embed){ if(document.getElementById(embed).style.display == 'none'){ document.getElementById(embed).style.display = 'block'; }else{ document.getElementById(embed).style.display = 'none'; } }Reserve currencies
Cross my palm with euros?Nov 11th 2009From Economist.com
The dollarâ??s days as the worldâ??s reserve currency are far from over ShutterstockWORRIES about the dollarâ??s dominance of the global monetary system are not new. But debate about replacing the beleaguered dollar, whose trade-weighted value has dropped by 11.5% since its peak in March 2009, has resurfaced in the wake of a global financial and economic crisis that began in America. China and Russia, which have huge reserves that are mainly dollar denominated, have talked about shifting away from the greenback. India changed the composition of its reserves by buying 200 tonnes of gold from the IMF.
None of this threatens the dominance of the dollar yet, particularly as a dramatic shift out of the currency would be damaging to the countries (such as China) that hold a huge amount of dollar-denominated assets. But a new paper by economists at the IMF, released on Wednesday November 11th, acknowledges that the global crisis has reignited the debate about anchoring the worldâ??s monetary system on one countryâ??s currency.
document.write('');Some say that Americaâ??s role as the principal issuer of the global reserve currency gives it an unfair advantage. America has a unique ability to borrow from foreigners in its own currency, and wins when the dollar depreciates, since its assets are mainly in foreign currency and its liabilities in dollars. By one estimate America enjoyed a net capital gain of around $1 trillion from the gradual depreciation of the dollar in the years before the crisis.
In a sense the world is hostage to Americaâ??s ability to maintain the value of the dollar. But as the IMF points out, the currency&rsqu
Advertisement
Reserve currencies
Nov 11th 2009From Economist.com
WORRIES about the dollarâ??s dominance of the global monetary system are not new. But debate about replacing the beleaguered dollar, whose trade-weighted value has dropped by 11.5% since its peak in March 2009, has resurfaced in the wake of a global financial and economic crisis that began in America. China and Russia, which have huge reserves that are mainly dollar denominated, have talked about shifting away from the greenback. India changed the composition of its reserves by buying 200 tonnes of gold from the IMF.
None of this threatens the dominance of the dollar yet, particularly as a dramatic shift out of the currency would be damaging to the countries (such as China) that hold a huge amount of dollar-denominated assets. But a new paper by economists at the IMF, released on Wednesday November 11th, acknowledges that the global crisis has reignited the debate about anchoring the worldâ??s monetary system on one countryâ??s currency.
Some say that Americaâ??s role as the principal issuer of the global reserve currency gives it an unfair advantage. America has a unique ability to borrow from foreigners in its own currency, and wins when the dollar depreciates, since its assets are mainly in foreign currency and its liabilities in dollars. By one estimate America enjoyed a net capital gain of around $1 trillion from the gradual depreciation of the dollar in the years before the crisis.
In a sense the world is hostage to Americaâ??s ability to maintain the value of the dollar. But as the IMF points out, the currencyâ??s primacy arises at least partly because China and other emerging countries have chosen to accumulate dollar reserves. The depth of Americaâ??s financial markets and the countryâ??s open capital account have made the dollar attractive. So some of the advantage has been earned.
But large and persistent surpluses in countries like China mean continued demand for American assets, reducing the need for fiscal adjustment by either country. This, in turn, has contributed to the build-up of the macroeconomic imbalances that many blame for the financial crisis.
Dealing with these imbalances could begin by finding ways to reduce reserve accumulation in emerging countries. The IMF reckons that about two-thirds of current reserves (about $4 trillion-$4.5 trillion) are held by countries as insurance against shocks, including sudden reversals of capital flows, banking crises and so on. In theory, groups of countries could pool reserves, so that a smaller amount would suffice than if countries each maintain their own buffers. Other alternatives include precautionary lines of credit, such as the American Federal Reserveâ??s with the central banks of Brazil and Mexico, or the IMFâ??s flexible credit line.
But what are the alternatives to relying on the dollar? One possibility is a system with several competing reserve currencies. Over time, the euro and Chinaâ??s yuan (if it became convertible) could emerge as competitors. This would require a great deal of policy co-ordination among issuing countries. But by having several reserve currencies the â??privilegeâ? that America now enjoys would be available more widely, providing an incentive to compete to attract users to different currencies.
Another alternative is a greater reliance on SDRs, the IMFâ??s quasi-currency, which operates as a claim on a basket of currencies: the dollar, euro, sterling and yen. Because the SDRâ??s value depends on several currencies, it shares many of the benefits of a multiple-currency system. But even the IMF says that using SDRs seems â??doubtful unless the systemâ?¦fails in a major wayâ?.
The most radical solution of all is a new global currency that could be used in international transactions and would float alongside domestic currencies. The fund argues that this would have to be issued by a new international monetary institution â??disconnected from the economic problems of any individual countryâ?. This currency could serve as a risk-free global asset.
Radical as this may sound, it is not a new idea. John Maynard Keynes had something similar in mind when he proposed an International Clearing Union. This global bank would issue its own currency, called the bancor, in which all trade accounts would be settled. In the absence of such a bank the world will have to make do with the current system. So worries about the dollarâ??s value aside, its global dominance is secure for now.
Back to top ^^
The Economist welcomes your views.
Advertisement
Advertisement
NUS Asia-Pacific EMBA Top 11 EMBA Worldwide (FT 2009) Admission Requirements: Bachelor degree 10 yrs working exp Join us for info session
Call for Research Fellows from around the world to work at the IN3 (Internet Interdisciplinary Institute) of the Open University of Catalonia (UOC) in Barcelona.
Università Bocconi: Economics and Management Education since 1902. - Bachelor - Master of Sciences - PhD Download your Welcome Kit!
CALL FOR PAPERS Journal of CENTRUM Cathedra CENTRUM Business School
Amidst a dramatic tropical landscape, a vibrant Caribbean port of call is emerging. Be amongst the first to discover Christophe Harbour, St. Kitts.
Glasgow Caledonian UniversityYunus Chair in Social Business and Health For full details, please visit our dedicated website
Copyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2009. All rights reserved.
Read Full Article »