Apple: Can It Stop the Android Menace?

Edward Harrison Credit Writedowns November 19, 2009

You are here: Home » Archives » Business » Apple: Can it stop the Android menace?

Digg it

Bookmark it

Stumble it

I want to take a break from banking and macro stuff and talk a little bit about technology. I wrote an article about Android a few weeks back. That was a more personal account on why I was switching from a Windows Mobile phone to Android, the latest whiz-bang operating system running mobile phones. (Don't ask me why I stuck with Windows Mobile for so long "“ even I don't know any more). This article is looking at the Android phenomenon more from a strategic perspective.

You may have seen the Verizon commercials on TV. They're everywhere: Droid has arrived. And this happens to be a big problem for Apple Computer.

(In case you haven't seen the commercials, here is one embedded below)

As you probably know, I am a bit of a technophile. I'm that guy you remember from high school who was taking AP Computer Science and programming in Pascal, the guy you remember who always had the latest gadget. And I've done my stint in technology companies too. But, at heart, I am a finance guy and when I look at technology, I do so from a finance guy's point of view. That's why I see the emergence of Android phones as significant. The recent flurry of announcements about hardware manufacturers adopting the Android platform has me thinking about Apple Computer and the 1990s again "“ and that's not good for Apple.

The Macintosh

From the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s, I was a Macintosh user and an avid fan of Apple Computer and its products. I started using PCs only because incompatibility with my colleagues' work product forced me to do so. The Macintosh was miles ahead of the PC in user-friendliness and platform robustness. And Apple is a company that cares about customer service too.

But, forced to do so or not, I did switch to the PC, as did millions of others. The reason: one company cannot compete against 100s. Apple refused to open its system and that limited production to Apple alone. Meanwhile, in PC world, you saw Compaq, Gateway 2000, HP, Dell, IBM, Toshiba, NEC, Packard Bell and a host of other vendors jumping onto the PC platform. Eventually, the PC was ubiquitous "“ and often incompatible with the Macintosh. How could Apple compete? It couldn't. Eventually, the Macintosh lost market share and became a niche product for die-hards, education and design.

Digital Music

But, Apple maintained its core competencies of user-friendliness, platform robustness and customer service. While PC makers were technology companies run by engineers, Apple was a consumer product company run by design and marketing. So, when Apple hit upon the digital music scene with iTunes and the iPod, it instantly became a success.

I am a big music fan. Because I tend to be an early adopter, I went all-in for digital music and CDs, buying my first CD player in 1988 "“ a top-rated Kyocera DA-610cx. When digital music hit the portable device market, I was there as well with my portable supposedly skip-free CD player plus car adapter. But, eventually I switched to Mini Disc and then on to Digital Audio Players. Remember the Diamond Rio 500?

The iPod

Then came the iPod. This was a ground-breaking product which was to digital music players what the Macintosh was to computers. It revolutionized the industry, bringing Apple Computer back to prominence as a technology company. The iPod became the dominant digital audio player (the hardware) "“ and with it, iTunes became the dominant digital music player (the software). It was almost like Intel and Microsoft rolled into one. Again, it was the user-friendliness, the product design and robustness of the iPod and the user-friendliness of Apple which made the difference.

Since then, Apple has successfully branched out into all manner of related spheres: video, podcasts, and most crucially digital music purchases and mobile telephones. They have also been very successful at integrating all of the platforms.

The iPhone "“ Android wars

But, everyone knows the digital music player is passé. And iTunes, the digital music player is a loss leader. The real money is going to come from digital music purchases and Apple's mobile telephone, the iPhone. So, strategically speaking, this is why I see the flurry of announcements about Android phones as a problem for Apple.

Android is the Linux-based operating system developed by Google. it is now being implemented on a number of different platforms from internet tablets to low-end personal computers to mobile telephones.

What I question is how Apple is going to compete in mobile telephones. Don't let the hype around the Verizon Droid fool you. The phone, manufactured by Motorola, is a very good phone. But, it is only one of many that are now coming to market. There are also phones in the works from Sony Ericcson, Samsung, HTC, Dell, Garmin, LG, and a host of other manufacturers. Even Google is supposed to be coming forth with the much anticipated Google Phone "“ the phone designed to prevent the splintering of Android which doomed Unix as a consumer-based operating system.

To my eyes, this is looking like a repeat of the Macintosh-PC Wars of the 1990s which Apple lost. On the one side, you have Apple, competing at the high end and very concerned about platform integrity and control, and preventing other manufacturers from building its hardware. On the other side, you have another operating system designed for the lower end and installed on a host of manufacturer systems "“ which may or may not cause serious platform integrity problems down the line. Who wins that battle?

In the 1990s it was Intel and Microsoft. And they went on to reap massive rewards as Apple foundered. Today, Apple risks a repeat of this if it does not come out with a credible solution to deal with its burgeoning Android problem.

Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe via the RSS feed, E-mail or Twitter for updates on finance and economics.

Related posts:Android gaining momentum on Apple’s iPhoneWalt Mossberg says Apple’s new browser Safari is fastMeredith Whitney says nationalization is wrong and banks will lose moneyJeremy Grantham: In-depth television interview with Consuelo MackeBay to cut 10% of its workforce

Category: Business Tags: business media, Technology160 views« Steve Keen: Debt and the economy – how do we pay for all of this? « » The slow but inexorable decline of jobless claims » Name I wasn't around in the '80s to see how Macintosh declined, but I suppose Apple didn't have the same level of market share as it does now in the smartphone segment with the iPhone. Suffice saying, all the people I know that are thinking about getting a better phone are first thinking about the iPhone (or the JesusPhone as The Reg named it). I think eventually the Android will be their biggest competitor in the consumer area (the corporate one is way too dominated by RIM), but this time Apple has a well-consolidated first mover advantage with the Apple Store nearing 90 000 applications. Probably that would be enough for most iPhone users to not make the switch. And if the iPhone moves to Verizon and other carriers it might get an extra push too...Which surely doesn't exclude the possibility that Apple shares aren't overvalued! Joel Lost in all of this, except in your opening and closing paragraphs is Microsoft. They have completely missed this transition from home computers to pocket computers and it will cost them big time. I had heard how Google was set to become the new Microsoft, but failed to truly see how until Android OS. Microsoft seems set to become a history lesson. Edward Harrison I also didn't touch on RIMM, Nokia, the handset makers, developers or the telcos! I tried to keep a narrow focus on the Apple-Google thing but, like you, I suspect Google is gunning for Microsoft as much if not more than Apple. I see Android as a Trojan Horse into the desktop space.I ran this at Naked Capitalism as well and there are a lot of good comments. blog comments powered by Disqus var disqus_url = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2009/11/apple-can-it-stop-the-android-menace.html '; var disqus_container_id = 'disqus_thread'; var facebookXdReceiverPath = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/wp-content/plugins/disqus-comment-system/xd_receiver.htm'; var DsqLocal = { 'trackbacks': [ ], 'trackback_url': 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2009/11/apple-can-it-stop-the-android-menace.html/trackback' }; Subscribe

Readers who viewed this page, also viewedReaders who viewed this page, also viewed:Android gaining momentum on Apple’s iPhoneChina’s empty city: the emperor really has no clothesBill Gross: Fed on hold through 2010Meredith Whitney says nationalization is wrong and banks will lose moneyTop ten predictions for the 2009 global economySearchLijit SearchAdvertisments sr_adspace_id = 3985607; sr_adspace_width = 300; sr_adspace_height = 250; sr_ad_new_window = true; sr_adspace_type = "graphic"; Archives Select Month November 2009 (105) October 2009 (160) September 2009 (106) August 2009 (93) July 2009 (172) June 2009 (113) May 2009 (135) April 2009 (129) March 2009 (179) February 2009 (141) January 2009 (128) December 2008 (117) November 2008 (99) October 2008 (198) September 2008 (162) August 2008 (147) July 2008 (214) June 2008 (220) May 2008 (119) April 2008 (78) March 2008 (40) Recent Posts If the U.S. stopped issuing treasuries, would it go broke? News from around the web: 2009-11-19 The slow but inexorable decline of jobless claims Apple: Can it stop the Android menace? Steve Keen: Debt and the economy – how do we pay for all of this? The small bank – big bank dichotomy Barack Obama: “if we keep on adding to the debt… that could actually lead to a double-dip” News from around the web: 2009-11-18 Credit Suisse cautious on Citigroup due to regulatory hurdles News from 17 November 1930: “we face a winter of hunger and distress” Recently PopularChina’s empty city: the emperor really has no clothesMeredith Whitney: “I haven't been this bearish in a year”Roubini: For unemployment "the worst is yet to come"China slams U.S. for inflating global asset prices via carry tradeHong Kong: “America is doing exactly what Japan did last time”I am now moving from multi-year recovery to a double dip baselineIf this is recovery"¦The recession is over but the depression has just begunBill Gross: Fed on hold through 2010Rosenberg: U.S. GDP is overstated Most Viewed Credit Crisis TimelineSwitzerland threatened with bankruptcyLetterman’s Top 10 George Bush momentsIs the State of California bankrupt?The Dummy’s Guide to the US Banking CrisisTop ten predictions for the 2009 global economyMarc Faber: I advise every American to hold his gold outside of the United StatesChart of the day: Dow 1928-1932The Swedish banking crisis response – a model for the future?Quantitative easing: printing money like mad to ward off deflationThe recession is over but the depression has just begunAboutByron Wien: Ten Surprises for 2009Lehman Brothers: a primer on Credit Default SwapsThe top 25 European banks by assetsThe TED SpreadMarc Faber: China’s numbers are fakeCurrency crisis is gathering stormChart of the day: Total US DebtCitibank has cut all lending in Denmark Resources TranslateTranslate to:ArabicBulgarianCatalanChinese (Simplified)Chinese (Traditional)CroatianCzechDanishDutchEnglishFilipinoFinnishFrenchGermanGreekHebrewHindiIndonesianItalianJapaneseKoreanLatvianLithuanianNorwegianPolishPortugueseRomanianRussianSerbianSlovakSlovenianSpanishSwedishUkrainianVietnamese var thestr = window.location.href; var mystrlen = 31; var sresult = thestr.indexOf( "www.creditwritedowns.com" ); if( sresult == -1 || sresult >= mystrlen) { document.write( ' ' ); document.write( 'return to original' ); }else{ document.write( '' ); } Powered by Google Translate. PollsSorry, there are no polls available at the moment.Polls Archive Social Media

Tagsbailout banking bankruptcy and foreclosure Barack Obama bond investing Britain business media capital markets China consumerism credit and credit cards deflation Democrats distraction economic depression economic indicators economic recovery election Europe FDIC federal reserve finance financial bubbles financial crisis financial history financial leverage financial statements foreign exchange trading inflation economics interest rates investing jobs law and justice loans and lending market wizards monetary policy mortgages oil Politics presidential elections regulatory capitalism residential property stocks unemployment United States

Recommended Links Compare Personal Loans Compare Credit Cards Our Site If you want to find out what's going on in the credit crisis, you've come to the right place.

See the Credit Crisis Timeline, which includes a timeline of major crisis events and links to a list of crisis events organized by financial institution. This is the most comprehensive data set of credit crisis-related events on the Internet.

To contact us, click here.

See more information about us.

Post Calendar November 2009 S M T W T F S « Oct «-» 1234