5 Surprises in the November Jobs Report

By Liz Wolgemuth

Posted: December 4, 2009

In a sign that employers are beginning to dip their toes into the hiring waters, a rising number of temp jobs helped shrink November's total job losses to 11,000, a figure small enough for officials to consider employment numbers essentially unchanged for the month. The unemployment rate fell by 0.2 percentage point to 10 percent. The data were far better than economists' forecasts of 125,000 jobs lost and an unchanged unemployment rate.

[See the best places to find a job.]

Still, there are plenty of data below the surface headline numbers that flesh out a fuller picture of the job market's progress. Here are five things to know about the jobs report:

The job market was better than you thought: While November's unexpectedly improved data make for welcome news to a layoff-weary public, the Labor Department dramatically revised the job losses for September and October to show a rosier job picture for those earlier months, as well. Employers cut just 111,000 jobs in October, rather than the 190,000 originally reported, and 139,000 jobs in September, rather than the 219,000 first reported.

There were many bright spots in November: The average number of hours worked each week has fallen throughout much of the recession, as employers slashed their workers' time on the job to cut costs. But last month, the average workweek increased by 0.2 hour to 33.2 hours, while the manufacturing workweek increased 0.3 hour to hit 40.4 hours, and factory overtime also rose 0.1 hour.

[See what job seekers can expect in 2010.]

Professional and business services sector employers added 86,000 jobs last month, most of them in temporary help services. Temp jobs are a leading indicator of the labor market, as employers often ease their way into hiring by bringing in temp workers, before building the confidence to add permanent employees.

Even construction industry job losses narrowed significantly in November, to 27,000, after averaging 117,000 a month in the six months ending in April, and 63,000 a month during the six-month period ending in October.

Long-term unemployment continues to spread: The ranks of the long-term unemployed grew again last month, as 293,000 unemployed workers saw their unemployment spells push past the six-month mark. Now, nearly 6 million workers have been unemployed for 27 weeks or more. As job losses narrow but employers hesitate to hire, average unemployment durations lengthen. Nearly 4 in 10 unemployed workers are among the long-term unemployed.

[See how the long-term unemployed can find work.]

The report doesn't match up with other jobs data: Today's report will no doubt be a head scratcher for economists as they try to understand how other labor market data could be so divergent. Earlier in the week, ADP reported private payroll losses of 169,000 for November. The Monster Employment Index, which measures online job demand, actually dipped slightly from October's number. "This was a shocking report because the reported payroll data bear little resemblance to any other evidence concerning the labor market, including the ADP survey, which is based on hard data from a much wider sample of payrolls than is the government's survey," says Joshua Shapiro, chief U.S. economist at research firm MFR.

The turnaround is coming: In an effort to gain new insights into how to stem the tide of job losses—or at least appear to be interested in gaining new insights—the White House held a jobs summit yesterday afternoon at which 130 business leaders exchanged ideas about what could put Americans back to work. Although the White House is loath to call any new efforts "stimulus," the administration may consider hiring tax credits, eased access to credit for small businesses, and weatherization incentives.

Today's report, however, gives stimulus supporters a kind of premium fuel for their defense of the $780 billion package. Labor Secretary Hilda Solis was quick to note the legislation's hand in the improved data. "While there has been a lot of rhetoric about the Recovery Act, when you look at today's report and other recent favorable economic trends, it is hard to argue that the Recovery Act is not working," Solis says.

No matter the precise cause for improvement, some economists find solid, rather than specious, good news in the November data. "Sorting through the volatility of recent months, there is pretty clear evidence of underlying progress toward labor market recovery," David Greenlaw and Ted Wieseman of Morgan Stanley Research said in a morning note. "The same sort of trend is evident in the weekly jobless claims data. We continue to look for payroll changes to turn positive in early 2010. "

Why is the media continuously flaunting unsubstantiated facts over and over? I dare they substantiate these "attention" grabbing heartwarming(I say in jest)stories about reduced layoffs and slowing joblessness. Where are the facts about the millions that have dropped off the rolls of the unemployed because they can no longer receive unemployment...thus "reducing" the numbers of unemployed simply because they're no longer counted??? Even counting last months decline, the unemployment rate has more than DOUBLED since the recession began in 2007...what's to be so excited about that? Job creation wil remain extremely weak for the forseable future...there are 15,400,000 seeking full time work and 11,500,000 who are underemployed. As more people begin to seek work the jobless rate is likely to resume it's INCREASE. Please report with honesty or don't report at all..the old saying appears to be accurate here...if you're not part of the solution then you're most assuredly part of the problem!

Al of WI @ Dec 04, 2009 16:06:31 PM

Just ask any of the millions of unemployed how they feel about the improving job market. There are currently 6 unemployed people available to apply for any job that opens up. And the unemployed are supposed to feel good because their unemployment benefits were extended, and the the unemployment counters got their numbers wrong? THERE HAS BEEN NO IMPROVEMENT. It continues to get worse. What about the number of those who are no longer counted, because they DID exhaust their unemployment benefits? They're only counted now as "No longer looking for work". Try telling them that.

Barry W. Shook of IN @ Dec 04, 2009 14:15:44 PM

I can't believe this article! Are you guys out of your minds? The real title for this article should be "The report doesn't match up with other jobs data" and then you should have explored why! These numbers are false! I believe ADP any day over this administration. Look how they revised the growth numbers down a whole point last month! They will have to do it with these numbers as well. We're at 10.4% according to ADP. Do you all really think we are this stupid?

John of GA @ Dec 04, 2009 13:08:11 PM

advertisement

Search for the perfect place for you and your family.

Careers that offer strong outlooks and high job satisfaction.

Make an informed choice when shopping for your next car.

advertisement

IT service jobs"”in engineering and in software services"”have fared well in this economy.

advertisement

A weekly insider's guide to politics and policy — in a multimedia, digital format. 52 issues for $19.95!

6 months of U.S. News & World Report's print edition for only $15. Save up to 67% off the cover price!

Presidents don't run the country alone. Get to know the people who make up Barack Obama's inner circle.

Loopholes allow states to provide college savers with less-than-solid guarantees.

Cars that make the most economic sense — not just when you sign on the dotted line, but for years after.

Copyright © 2009 U.S.News & World Report LP All rights reserved.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Read Full Article »


Comment
Show comments Hide Comments


Related Articles

Market Overview
Search Stock Quotes