Sign in
Become a MarketWatch member today
David Weidner's Writing on the Wall
Feb. 16, 2010, 2:55 a.m. EST · Recommend (13) · Post:
View all David Weidner's Writing on the Wall "º
"¹ Previous Column
Wall Street's latest contagion goes global
First Take "º
Breaking through a nuclear impasse
By David Weidner, MarketWatch
NEW YORK (MarketWatch) -- Questions of the day: Would you buy a round-trip ticket on an airplane prone to crashes? How about a car with a history of serious brake problems? Interested in a TV that works great, except for the picture?
If you answered yes to any of those, do I have an investment opportunity for you.
Citigroup Inc. /quotes/comstock/13*!c/quotes/nls/c (C 3.31, +0.13, +4.09%) , our taxpayer-funded national bank, is readying a new credit derivative, the CLX. Basically, the CLX is systemic risk insurance that will pay out in the event of a financial crisis. The basic premise is to allow investors to hedge against a spike in funding costs.
Reuters Citi's Vikram Pandit
According to Risk Magazine "the CLX is constructed as a sum of the Sharpe ratio -- deviations from the mean divided by volatility -- of various market factors, such as equity volatilities, Treasury rates, swap spreads, corporate bond swaption-implied volatilities, and structured credit spreads. Citi will make the CLX tradable by using fixed historical values for the mean and volatility parameters, eliminating the need for costly recomputation from lengthy time series." Read Risk Magazine story on the CLX.
If you understood the last paragraph, please take two bailouts, a bonus and call your Treasury Secretary in the morning.
Citigroup says CLX is based on six indexes. It's still in the planning stages, but it won't put the firm at risk. Citi's considering building it at the request of customers it considers sophisticated enough to use CLX wisely. Citi just wants to make a market in CLX. It will buy when there are no buyers, sell when there are no sellers. Citi says its role will be neutral. They may even bring other brokerages in to spread the risk.
Sorry, but the CLX sounds a lot like what got Wall Street into trouble in the first place. Complicated derivatives, including collateralized debt obligations, synthetic CDOs and credit default swaps, ripped apart balance sheets and drove financial institutions such as Citigroup into the arms of taxpayers.
Investors, swayed by Wall Street sales pitches touting the safety of these securities, had little understanding of the risks these securities held. And who can blame them? When you look at the CLX, it's not exactly clear on what it's based and who's really carrying the risk.
But the complexity is only part of the problem.
Barry Ritholtz, the well known blogger and investor, points out on his Big Picture blog that "Any insurance product, CDS, any contract is only as a good as the financial condition of the contraparties. Any insurance product designed to pay off in the event of a financial crisis becomes increasingly unlikely to do just that...We already have systemic risk insurance. Only, it's not from Citi, it's from Uncle Sam." See blog post by Ritholtz.
The point is, when push comes to shove, will there be a market for the CLX? Won't most of the institutions buying them be in trouble if they need to cash out? And who cashes them out, Citi? How much is Citi going to set aside to cover potential losses?
Citigroup, denies that it's putting taxpayers at risk. Rather, it might have the opposite effect: for example strengthening an insurer when borrowing costs soar.
But a lot of finance pros have looked at this and they say the way CLX is laid out, there doesn't seem to be any specific party responsible for paying on the contracts. If it's Citi, what happens if Citi can't pay? Under proposed reforms, Citi would be too big to fail and get a bailout if it ran into CLX trouble.
- rooneyg | 8:00 a.m. Feb. 16, 2010
SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) -- The Obama Administration, bogged down on so many fronts, has tossed $8.3 billion of federally backed loans to the nation's nuclear power industry.
6:15 p.m. Feb. 16, 2010 | Comments: 13
This Week in Japan
Will Bank of Japan target prices?
Media Web
Dear Katie Couric: Just hang tough
On the Markets
Corporate insiders' buying picks up
Vital Signs
Where to get health care if you face obstacles
Writing on the Wall
Citigroup's plan: profit from the next crisis
Tech Tales
Google Buzz may be a lesson in viral backlash
The Economist's Corner
Can we wean ourselves off pork?
Behavioral Economics
Read Full Article »