The US Department of Commerce is out today with monthly numbers on personal earnings, spending and saving. The good news is that spending, up 5%, rose much faster than income, up 1%. The bad news is the same: Spending grew much faster than income.
Increases in spending, especially when they are rising much faster than income, show optimism on behalf of the consumer. And in an economy in the US that is 70% driven by consumer expenditures, we need a good deal of optimism to pull us out of a recession and keep the economy chugging along. But the rise in spending and sluggish growth in income also sent the savings rate down to 3.3%, its lowest level since October 2008 (chart ht Calculated Risk). And that is bad news. Here's why:
The problem is something called the paradox of thrift. A former Curious Capitalist Justin Fox summarized the issue nicely in a column last year.
Don't spend more than you make. Don't buy things you don't need. Save for a rainy day. If Americans had followed these simple rules over the past decade, there would be no financial crisis, no worst-since-the-1930s recession, no acrimonious Washington debate over what to do about it. Now we seem to be starting to rediscover thrift. Debt levels are falling. Consumer spending is down. The savings rate is on the rise. Great, right? Not exactly. The sudden sobering up of the American consumer happens to be the No. 1 force driving the U.S. and global economies downward. We're saving more, yet we're all getting poorer.
The great recession was supposed to teach all of us one lesson. Debt is bad. If we were going to pull out of this, we were all going to have to lock up our wallets and focus on paying off our bills. And indeed the savings rate did initially turn up. It is still well above its low of 1%. But the upward trajectory that many predicted has stalled. Perhaps because of what Justin said. Saving more didn't make us feel any better.
The questions of whether this is a bump in the road or a return to 1% is up for debate. Calculated Risk still says it expects savings rates to rise to 8% during the next few years. Other economists say the idea that the savings rate would rise dramatically was probably a pipe dream.While we might cheer a drop in savings in the short-term, in the long-term, savings has no real downside. In fact, it is a catalyst for long-term grown. That's why a generation of spend-thrifts coming out of the Great Depression led to prosperity in the 50s, 60s, 80s and 90s.
I think anyone who has lived in America for some time knows that we love to spend. So without some kind of government intervention--more incentives to save, some real financial reform that cuts back aggressive lending practices--it is unlikely that we will dramatically shift to a nation of savers. And this unfortunately is a bad thing. And that could be the best argument for some government action either in the form of more stimulus and job creation spending. Americas can only stop spending for so long. Savings seems to be a virtue again. But if incomes continue to stagnate or drop, Americas will again get used to spending more than they make. And if that happens, we can wave good-bye to another one of those Great Recession opportunities. Oh well.
Incentives to save? We have incentives to spend. Tax breaks to buy a new car, tax breaks to buy a new appliance, tax breaks to buy a house, tax credits (big ones!) to buy any number of things vaguely energy-efficient.
So the government has been trying hard to get consumers to open their wallets. Maybe that's what these numbers reflect?
Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.
The Curious Capitalist Favorite Links Adam Lashinsky Barry Ritholtz Brad DeLong Calculated Risk Econbrowser Econlog Epicurean Dealmaker Ezra Klein Felix Salmon Floyd Norris Greg Mankiw Growthology James Pethokoukis John Gapper Justin Fox Marginal Revolution Mark Thoma Matt McAlister Megan McArdle Michael Mandel Mike Moffatt Nicholas Carr Paul Kedrosky Paul Krugman Philip Coggan Planet Money Roger Parloff Ryan Avent The Stash adFactory.getCmAd(300, 250, "global", "tout").write(); adFactory.getCmAd(300, 100, "article", "tout").write(); ArchiveMarch 2010SMTWTFS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 More News from Our Partners CNN Online game seeks to empower Africa Survey: More Americans getting news via Facebook, e-mail Pentagon OKs use of social media Huffington Post Jim Moret: This Recession Is Depressing Jon Younger: When Engagement Means Employees Like Each Other More Than Customers Lehman Brothers Wives Were Wild Spenders, Says New Book 'The Devil's Casino' DailyFinance.com Pharma Today: Deals, Drug News, and a 'Going Concern' Warning Legal Briefing: Want to Pollute? Just Dump in a Stream, Not a River Japan's Astellas Goes Hostile on OSI Pharma With a $3.5 billion Bid Rotten Tomato Exclusive: Oscar Nominee Jeff Bridges on Crazy Heart - The RT Interview Weekly Ketchup: Ian McShane sails to Stanger Tides Critics Consensus: Your Badge and Gun, Cop Out Life Spencer Tunick: Naked Ambition Trippy Closing Ceremonies Earthquake in Chile: First Photos More on TIME.com » Consumer Spending Is Back: Good News or Bad? Military Suicides: Why Are They Going Up? How Governors Could Be Key to GOP Resurgence Quotes of the Day » "It's like renting a car in England â?? you know how to drive, but you're driving on the other side of the road." STEVE ABRAHAM, an air-traffic controller at JFK in New York City, on having to redirect planes after the airport shut down its main runway for repairs; the concrete on the runway will be repaved over a four-month period More Quotes » var ad = adFactory.getAd(88, 31); ad.setPosition(13) ad.write(); Today in Pictures » Drag Race Stay Connected with TIME.com Learn More » Subscribe to RSS Feeds Sign Up for Newsletters Add TIME Widgets Read TIME Mobile on Your Phone Become a Fan of TIME Get TIME Twitter Updates adFactory.getCmAd(115, 42, "homepage", "tout").write(); © 2010 Time Inc. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | RSS | Newsletter | TIME For Kids | LIFE.com Subscribe | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Reprints & Permissions | Opinion Leaders Panel | Help | Site Map TiiAdTrackRevSci(); function tiQuantcast() { } _qoptions={ qacct:"p-5dyPa639IrgIw", labels:tiQuantcast() } BF_BB_DATA = null; (function( ){ document.write(''); var sid="740V07"; var c=""; var b=""; BF_BB_SCRIPT=document.createElement('script'); BF_BB_SCRIPT.type="text/javascript"; BF_BB_SRC="http://buzzbox.buzzfeed.com/wd/BuzzBox?sid=" + sid + c + b + '&it=1&cb=' + (new Date()).getTime(); setTimeout(function() { document.getElementById('BF_BUZZBOX').appendChild(BF_BB_SCRIPT); BF_BB_SCRIPT.src=BF_BB_SRC; },1); })(); Powered by WordPress.com VIP var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); try { var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-10268691-1"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {} _qoptions = { labels:"adt.0,language.en,vip.timecuriouscapitalist" };_qacct="p-18-mFEk4J448M";quantserve(); st_go({'blog':'5320466','v':'wpcom','user_id':'0','post':'8873','subd':'timecuriouscapitalist'}); ex_go({'crypt':'RDZ8LFkxbXF2TVluJVFmT0xoZkVaUCVrM3R3cCU2Wi10dWQ0JktGcGFFRkZuR0ZNW0dDN1J4NTFWaiU2Y1FZUHVSPytUVTJEWjhBQ2RTVEIleDJqNHZaP2FSaWcyY29XX2ZzRjNiZCt3VXVMUTBZWz9Bals3eTFhMXIwW1dTRHxtZi42YnktJTEvNUdySllIdTV3dW5oeFhCMFNmd3RMSTZlR2o3c0g0YVIwLzBnP1czSXFEX35jdGpzZUxZemJ6b01vLWw2OXgtQndWVU81TlVKKyZTa2lFOS9SUERLY3pQblNZfGF0'}); addLoadEvent(function(){linktracker_init('5320466',8873);}); Read Full Article »