The Recovery Will Stall in the Second Half of 2010

Home » Economy » Albert Edwards: Global economy to roll over in six to nine months’ time; bearish for shares

Digg it

Bookmark it

Stumble it

Reddit

SocGen’s Albert Edwards was out with a note today which is in line with my calls for a marked slowing of the economy toward the end of this year. He indicates that the rate of change in leading indicators in the real economy and in markets is rolling over right now. Edwards writes that this suggests softness in six-to-nine months (hat tip Scott).

I like his analysis because it depends on first derivatives or the rate of change rather than absolute levels which are misleading at turning points (see Has the increase in U.S. jobless claims peaked? from March 2009 for an example of first derivatives presaging the end of recession).  Remember, a recession begins from a cyclical peak in economic activity. So, the economy is rising until that point. Analysts looking at absolute levels only will miss the slowing in the rate of change.

Edwards writes:

I have had a few e-mails recently about some of the key leading indicators reaching new cyclical highs last week, and what this means for our view. To be sure, the latest weekly reading for the Economic Cycle Research Institute (ECRI) key lead indicator reached a 99 week high. That, at first sight, looks very bullish for the continuation of this cyclical upturn. However, as with all of these lead indicators, it is the rate of change that is important. The ECRI also report a smoothed annual change in their index. Last week that slipped to +12.5% yoy, which is a 37-week low (see chart below). Now one doesn’t want to be too armageddonish at this stage, but this is clear evidence that in 6-9 months time there will be a discernible slowdown in the economic recovery from its recent moderate pace.

The same dynamic is true for the OECD and Conference Board leading indicators as well "“ as it is for the change in analysts’ global EPS optimism, which is rolling over and leading the OECD indicator down.

 

 

The chart I found most compelling was the change in analyst optimism mapped against the 6-month change in the S&P. Note, we are measuring the first derivatives for analyst opinions here. So that means the rate of change is slowing even while the optimism is increasing.  Notice how well the datasets have coincided over the past decade.

Bottom line: This recovery is going to stall in the second half of 2010 unless… But, Obama probably doesn’t get that. As for investors, Edwards says:

[I]f the trend is your friend until it meets a bend, that trend is now the investor’s enemy.

Readers who viewed this page, also viewed:Marc Faber: I advise every American to hold his gold outside of the United StatesThe bearish argument for the global economyHas the increase in U.S. jobless claims peaked?Barack Obama: "if we keep on adding to the debt"¦ that could actually lead to a double-dip"Letterman’s Top 10 George Bush moments [Translate]

Related postsPayroll data mixed despite the bullish headline job loss figureThe bearish argument for the global economyKasriel: ‘greater risk for the global economy…is inflation’Are jobless claims peaking?ISM manufacturing index at highest since April 2006

If you enjoyed our post, feel free to subscribes to our rss feed

 Print This Post sr_adspace_id = 5672807; sr_adspace_width = 468; sr_adspace_height = 60; sr_ad_new_window = true; sr_adspace_type = "graphic"; Category: Economy     Tags: double dip, Economy, psychology, recovery, stocks« Prepared Testimony of Lloyd C. Blankfein for Tomorrow’s Senate Hearing «» Risk of a Haircut Weighs On Euro » rootless_cosmopolitanEdward,The expectation of a close to Zero growth or a renewed economic contraction, at least for the United States, is corroborated by the data provided by the Consumer Metrics Institute.http://www.consumerindexes.com/These data are supposed to represent the current demand for discretionary consumer goods through Internet orders and to be an early indicator of the GDP change one or two quarters downstream. The time lagged correlation between the provided Daily Growth Index and the GDP change seems to be quite high, although one could formulate the caveat that the data series, going back to 2005 only, is still quite short.According to these data, demand in US has been contracting again since mid of January 2010, after the strong upswing in 2009. If this Daily Growth Index has a good predictive value indeed, it shows a stalling of the "recovery" or even another recession starting in the second or third quarter of 2010, which is totally at odds with all the optimism currently boosted in the commercial media, by analysts, and shown in investor sentiment indicators.blog comments powered by Disqus var disqus_url = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/04/albert-edwards-global-economy-to-roll-over-in-six-to-nine-months-time-bearish-for-shares.html '; var disqus_container_id = 'disqus_thread'; var facebookXdReceiverPath = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/wp-content/plugins/disqus-comment-system/xd_receiver.htm'; /**/ /**/ Subscribe

SearchLijit Search sr_adspace_id = 3985607; sr_adspace_width = 300; sr_adspace_height = 250; sr_ad_new_window = true; sr_adspace_type = "graphic"; About the author

Author: Edward Harrison

Edward is the founder of Credit Writedowns, a former strategy and finance executive who started out long ago as a diplomat. Edward speaks six languages, so expect to see a translated text or two in his writings. From an ideological perspective, Edward calls himself a libertarian realist: a firm believer in the primacy of markets over a statist approach. but not in an ideological way. Often government intervention and oversight is not just wanted but warranted. Edward holds an MBA from Columbia University and a BA in Economics from Dartmouth College. Contact him at feedback at creditwritedowns dot com.

Read all of Edward Harrison's Posts

Random Quote“Charlie and I believe Berkshire should be a fortress of financial strength "“ for the sake of our owners, creditors, policyholders and employees. We try to be alert to any sort of megacatastrophe risk, and that posture may make us unduly apprehensive about the burgeoning quantities of long-term derivatives contracts and the massive amount of uncollateralized receivables that are growing alongside. In our view, however, derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction, carrying dangers that, while now latent, are potentially lethal.”-- Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway 2002 Annual Report Berkshire Hathaway (pdf)Polls

Obama's 'War on Wall Street' is

a political stunt after the stunning defeat in Massachusetts. (55%, 168 Votes)only a start. But, it's the best we've seen so far. (34%, 106 Votes)the real deal. He just needs to stick to his guns. (6%, 17 Votes)counter-productive. We've seen enough big government. Leave Wall Street alone. (5%, 17 Votes)

Total Voters: 308

 Loading ...Polls ArchiveRecent PostsLinks: 2010-04-27 The horrendous Keynesian/monetarist nightmareGuest Post: Possible Misunderstandings about Municipalities and their BondsGuest Post: Some Proposals to the Greek GovernmentMerkel may force banks to take haircut on Greek debtRisk of a Haircut Weighs On EuroAlbert Edwards: Global economy to roll over in six to nine months' time; bearish for sharesPrepared Testimony of Lloyd C. Blankfein for Tomorrow's Senate HearingRandom 1970s Inspiration for GreeceAre the housing bailouts for banks or borrowers?Greek bond yields at 12-year high, contagion increasing Research

Casey Research: Why Are Silver Sales Soaring?

Casey Research: Sooner or Later, You'll Invest Abroad

Casey Research: Will Obama Destroy Any Hope of U.S. Energy Independence?

Casey Research: An Insider's View of the Real Estate Train Wreck

Casey Research: Vintage Wine Turns Sour for Financiers

INO: A Quick Peek at Crude Oil

INO: Make Some Sense of Today's Gold Market

INO: How to Spot the Big Trends

INO: Dow in 2010 = Dow of 1929. Video Analysis

Popular PostsAlbert Edwards: Global economy to roll over in six to nine months' time; bearish for sharesThinking about Creditanstalt todayThe Florida Nightmare: ForeclosureBubblicious mortgage deals, Canadian versionMarc Faber: "Symptoms of a bubble building in China"Andy Xie: I'll Tell You When Chinese Bubble Is About to BurstRosenberg: Stocks 35% overvaluedJeremy Grantham on BubblesBill Black: Lehman's demise is "a story of fraud"Starbucks' closure listMost ViewedCredit Crisis TimelineSwitzerland threatened with bankruptcyLetterman’s Top 10 George Bush momentsIs the State of California bankrupt?The Dummy’s Guide to the US Banking CrisisMarc Faber: I advise every American to hold his gold outside of the United StatesTop ten predictions for the 2009 global economyChart of the day: Dow 1928-1932Byron Wien: Ten Surprises for 2009The recession is over but the depression has just begunThe Swedish banking crisis response – a model for the future?The top 25 European banks by assetsAboutQuantitative easing: printing money like mad to ward off deflationLehman Brothers: a primer on Credit Default SwapsMarc Faber: China’s numbers are fakeCalifornia will go bankruptChart of the day: Total US DebtCurrency crisis is gathering stormThe TED SpreadTip Jar

Donation Amount: (Currency: USD)

Repeat Donation: Do not repeatDailyWeeklyMonthlyYearly x

Tag cloud accounting Asia Austrian Economics bailout banking Bank of America bankruptcy blog bonds Britain budget capital Caroline Baum cars central banks Charlie Rose China Citigroup commodities compensation corruption credit credit and credit cards credit cards credit crisis credit ratings crisis solutions debt deflation Democrats derivatives distraction double dip Eastern Europe Economy election Europe Fannie Mae FDIC finance charts financial bubbles financial history financial news financial statements foreclosure forex Freddie Mac Germany gold Goldman Sachs government Greece Housing inflation interest rates international investing investment Ireland Japan jobs law Lehman leverage local manufacturing market wizards media mergers money mortgages nationalization Obama oil outlook Politics populism property protectionism psychology quantitative easing RBS recession recovery regionals regulation retail saving silver small business Society Spain stimulus stocks taxes trade United States video Volcker Willem Buiter

Our SiteIf you want to find out what's going on in the credit crisis, you've come to the right place.

See the Credit Crisis Timeline, which includes a timeline of major crisis events and links to a list of crisis events organized by financial institution. This is the most comprehensive data set of credit crisis-related events on the Internet.

To contact us, click here.

See more information about us.

Posts AuthorsEdward Harrison 3413Marshall Auerback 71Marc Chandler 57Edward Hugh 33Niels Jensen 11Claus Vistesen 10Guest Author 7John Lounsbury 3Rob Parenteau 2Charlie Bull 1CategoriesSelect CategoryBlogs  (35)Business  (91)Economics  (185)Economy  (668)Financial Institutions  (635)Forecasts  (39)Housing  (203)Markets  (359)More  (52)News  (608)Political Economy  (440)Politics  (233)Retrospective  (25)Society  (33) /* */ var dropdown = document.getElementById("cat"); function onCatChange() { if ( dropdown.options[dropdown.selectedIndex].value > 0 ) { location.href = "http://www.creditwritedowns.com/?cat="+dropdown.options[dropdown.selectedIndex].value; } } dropdown.onchange = onCatChange; /* */ Archives Select Month April 2010  (142) March 2010  (165) February 2010  (144) January 2010  (144) December 2009  (169) November 2009  (146) October 2009  (160) September 2009  (106) August 2009  (93) July 2009  (172) June 2009  (113) May 2009  (135) April 2009  (130) March 2009  (179) February 2009  (141) January 2009  (128) December 2008  (117) November 2008  (99) October 2008  (198) September 2008  (162) August 2008  (147) July 2008  (214) June 2008  (218) May 2008  (106) April 2008  (62) March 2008  (18) Search Read Full Article »