Yes Virginia, There's a Difference b/w Greece & U.S.

Marshall Auerback Credit Writedowns May 6, 2010

Home » Economics » MMT: Yes Virginia, There is a Difference Between Greece and the US

Digg it

Bookmark it

Stumble it

Marshall Auerback here with a post which I originally published at New Deal 2.0. This post on deficits in fiat currency regimes is the second in a series of posts on Modern Monetary Theory.

Many market analysts, commentators and economists claim to be having a hard time finding a metric in which the US is in better financial shape than Greece. Ken Rogoff, for example, recently warned that a Greek default would usher in a series of sovereign defaults, and suggested recently on NPR that the crisis also had implications for the US. The historian Niall Ferguson made a similar claim a few months ago in the Financial Times. The cries of the deficit hawks grow louder: Repent all ye fiscal profligates, before the "day of reckoning" comes.

Let's dial down the Biblical hysteria a wee bit while there's still time for rational debate. The market's recent response to the intensifying pressures in the euro zone suggests that investors are beginning to differentiate between countries that are sovereign issuers of currency, such as the US or Japan, and non-sovereign issuers, such as Greece or any other nations in the euro zone. The US dollar is rising in value, notwithstanding the federal deficit, while debt distress in the so-called "PIIGS" countries, especially Greece, are intensifying, thereby driving down the euro to fresh 12 month lows against the dollar.

The relative performance of various currencies against the US dollar is highly instructive in this regard. Over the past 3 months, the Australian, New Zealand and Canadian dollars have all registered gains of some 4% against the greenback. The worst performer? Not surprisingly, the euro, down 6.3% over that period. Whether consciously or not, the markets are demonstrating that they understand the distinctions between users of currencies (who face an external funding constraint), and those nations that face no constraint in their deficit spending activities because they are creators of currency.

That the US has the reserve currency is an irrelevant consideration here. The key distinction remains user vs. creator. The euro zone nations are part of the former; Canada, Australia, the UK, Japan and the US are representatives of the latter.

Using "PIIGS" countries as analogues to the US or the UK, as Rogoff, Ferguson and countless other commentators do, is wrong. Their faulty analysis comes as a result of the deficit critics' failure to distinguish between the monetary arrangements of sovereign and non-sovereign nations. Any sovereign government (none within the EMU enjoy that status any longer) can deal with a collapse in revenue and an increase in outlays from a financial perspective without invoking the sort of deadlocks that are now crippling the EMU zone. That is why, for example, the Japanese yen is not in freefall against the dollar, despite having a public debt to GDP ratio in excess of 200%, almost 2.5 times that of the US. In fact, over the past few days the yen has actually appreciated against the dollar. Now why would that be, if the lesson we were supposed to learn was the evils of "unsustainable" government deficit spending?

Fiscal sustainability has no relevance in a system where there are no operational constraints on the ability of a government to spend. US Social Security checks will not bounce. Nor will the Canadian or Japanese equivalents. Similarly, their bonds will always be able to pay out interest.

Note that this doesn't mean that there are no real resource constraints on government spending. Let's be clear: anyone who advances the use of fiscal policy as an effective counter-stabilization tool is always careful to point out that these interventions can come at a cost. That cost could well be inflation if, as a result of the fiscal expansion, we reach full employment, resource constraints begin to appear, but the government continues to spend. But if the economy recovers, tax revenues will increase and safety net spending will fall. In the US, that means we will likely be back to "normal," with deficits around 2-4% depending on the state of the economy, which is where we've been for the past 30 years aside from 1998-2001.

Why won't these deficits be inflationary? As Professor Scott Fullwiler noted in a recent email correspondence with me, once the recovery is underway and the economy gets to a significantly higher capacity utilization where price pressures could emerge, the deficit will be declining substantially. It will also be at least a partially offset by a fall in discretionary spending on social welfare. It's axiomatic that the faster the economy grows, the smaller the deficit becomes, unless the government continues to spend recklessly"“which we certainly do not advocate.

And by the time we get to a point where we might have inflation, the deficit is back to 2-3%, which again is where we've been for the past 30 years, while average inflation has been about 2%. Note: inflation does not equal default. You and I could well buy credit default swaps on any country in the world, but we are unable to collect if any of the relevant countries register a positive rate of inflation "” even a double digit rate of inflation "” because inflation is not tantamount to default. Nor do the ratings agencies recognize default in this manner. Default is defined as a failure to perform a task or fulfill an obligation, especially failure to meet a financial obligation. Inflation is not incorporated into the definition when it comes to questions of national insolvency.

By contrast, the talk of Greek default is prevalent across the markets, and that is a reasonable concern in the context of the euro zone. The default option is considered a foregone conclusion, even allowing for the massive 110 billion euro bailout, which was designed to inspire "shock and awe" among investors but instead has simply engendered shock. If Greece costs 110 billion euros to bail out, how much next time for Spain, Italy, or even France?

If the markets have concerns about national solvency, they won't extend credit. And that is the problem facing all of the euro zone countries. Greece, Portugal, Italy, France, and Germany are all users of the euro-not issuers. In that respect, they are more like any American state or municipality, all of which are users of the US federal government's dollar.

And deficits per se will not create the conditions for default in the US. If the US continues to run net export deficits (all the more likely given the ongoing fall in the value of the euro), and the private domestic sector is to net save, the US government has to net spend"“that is, run deficits. That is a basic accounting identity, nothing more, nothing less. If the US government tries under these circumstances to run surpluses, it will first of all force the private domestic sector into deficits (and increasing debt) and ultimately fail because the latter will eventually seek to increase their saving ratio again.

And the same logic applies for Greece. The call is for the IMF/EU package to reduce its budget deficit as a percentage of GDP from the current 13.6% to 8.1% in 2011. How will they achieve that? Trying to engineer a reduction in the deficit via austerity programs (or freezes or whatever else one might like to call them) at a time when private spending is still insufficient to maintain adequate real GDP growth is a recipe for disaster. It will increase the deficit.

Consider Ireland as Exhibit A in this regard. Ireland began cutting back deficit spending in 2008, when its banking crisis began to spread and its budget deficit as a percentage of GDP was 7.3%. The economy promptly contracted by 10% and, surprise, surprise, the deficit exploded to 14.3% of GDP. We would wager heavy odds that a similar fate lies in store for Greece, given the EU's inability to understand or recognize basic financial balances and the interrelationships among the various sectors of the economy. Neither a government, nor the IMF, can predict with any certainty what the outcome will be"“ultimately private saving desires will drive the outcome, as Bill Mitchell has noted repeatedly.

Why do we have huge budget deficits across the globe? It's not because our officials have all suddenly become Soviet-style apparatchiks. It is largely because the slower global economy has led to lower revenues (less income=less taxes paid, since most tax revenue is based on income, and lower tax brackets) and higher spending on the social safety net. Gutting this social safety net because we extrapolate the wrong lessons from the euro zone's particular (and self-imposed) predicament constitutes the height of economic ignorance. It also reflects a transparently political agenda, which the US would be ill advised to embrace. The rescue packages, the IMF intervention and all the talk about orderly defaults cannot overcome the EMU's fundamental design flaw. Let neo-liberalism die with the euro.

Readers who viewed this page, also viewed:MMT: Hyperinflation in the USA [Translate]

Related postsPoll: Will Greece default?Greece: Something will give, austerity or growth or bothGreece sees credit rating cut by S&PPortugal UpdateTroubles in the EuroZone: Will the Contagion affect the U.S.?

If you enjoyed our post, feel free to subscribes to our rss feed

Print This Post sr_adspace_id = 5672807; sr_adspace_width = 468; sr_adspace_height = 60; sr_ad_new_window = true; sr_adspace_type = "graphic"; Category: Economics Tags: budget, Europe, inflation, taxes« Links: 2010-05-06 Heading toward a Greek default « Michael JungExhibit B is Japan - 1997/98?IMF urged Japan to cut spending, withdraw stimulus and increase taxes. Subsequently the economy tanked again = shortfall in tax higher than expected, deficit increased.Exhibit C is Germany - 2010/11!Current predictions for tax shortfall exceed predictions;1,2bn Euros less for 20102011 11,7bn Euros less,2012 12,8bn less2013 13,7bn lesshttp://www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/0,151...I have yet to look up details and explanations. Either (1) a tax increase is implemented for the higher income brackets or (2) subsidies and smart welfare cuts have to be implemented, because (3) new expanded borrowing has to be ruled out as it is the most costly exercise and most lethargic plan.blog comments powered by Disqus var disqus_url = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/05/mmt-yes-virginia-there-is-a-difference-between-greece-and-the-us.html '; var disqus_container_id = 'disqus_thread'; var facebookXdReceiverPath = 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/wp-content/plugins/disqus-comment-system/xd_receiver.htm'; var DsqLocal = { 'trackbacks': [ ], 'trackback_url': 'http://www.creditwritedowns.com/2010/05/mmt-yes-virginia-there-is-a-difference-between-greece-and-the-us.html/trackback' }; /**/ Subscribe

SearchLijit Search sr_adspace_id = 3985607; sr_adspace_width = 300; sr_adspace_height = 250; sr_ad_new_window = true; sr_adspace_type = "graphic"; About the author

Author: Marshall Auerback

Marshall Auerback has 27 years of experience in the investment management business, serving as a global portfolio strategist for RAB Capital Plc, a UK-based fund management group with $2 billion under management, since 2003. He is also co-manager of the RAB Gold Fund. He serves as an economic consultant to PIMCO, the world's largest bond fund management group, and as a fellow of the Economists for Peace and Security.

Read all of Marshall Auerback's Posts

Random Quote“I am 100% sure that the U.S. will go into hyperinflation.”-- Marc Faber, May 2009 Polls

Will Greece default?

Yes, but they will stay in the euro-zone after a managed restructuring (39%, 246 Votes)Yes and it will be a messy involuntary default (26%, 164 Votes)Yes and they will leave the euro-zone (19%, 123 Votes)No, they will take the necessary austerity measures plus receive enough support from the EU and IMF. (16%, 101 Votes)

Total Voters: 634

Loading ...Polls ArchiveRecent PostsMMT: Yes Virginia, There is a Difference Between Greece and the USLinks: 2010-05-06 Heading toward a Greek defaultHugh Hendry talking Greek and euro banker bailout on CrossTalkStat of the Day: Table of euro-zone debt and deficitsBBH CurrencyView: US Dollar Firm Ahead of ECB MeetingVideo: Greek austerity protests turn deadlyHow Belgian debt, Italian anarchy and Greek profligacy lead to economic chaos in EuropeChanos, Roach Discuss Outlook for China's EconomyMeredith Whitney: First quarter bank earnings are due to marking up assets, not fundamentalsCareer options: Government or private sector Research

Casey Research: Why Are Silver Sales Soaring?

Casey Research: Sooner or Later, You'll Invest Abroad

Casey Research: Will Obama Destroy Any Hope of U.S. Energy Independence?

Casey Research: An Insider's View of the Real Estate Train Wreck

Casey Research: Vintage Wine Turns Sour for Financiers

INO: A Quick Peek at Crude Oil

INO: Make Some Sense of Today's Gold Market

INO: How to Spot the Big Trends

INO: Dow in 2010 = Dow of 1929. Video Analysis

Popular PostsUS GDP growth rate is unsustainable; recovery will fadeMMT: Hyperinflation in the USAThe Age of The TraderAlbert Edwards: Global economy to roll over in six to nine months' time; bearish for sharesOut of control US deficit spendingStarbucks' closure listGoldman's public purpose and where I have problems with the Abacus dealSlovakia first euro-zone nation to reject Greek aid packageLocal Government Fiscal Emergency: Fresno, CALinks: 2010-04-30 On contagion, Ireland looks best, Portugal looks good, Spain looks worstMost ViewedCredit Crisis TimelineSwitzerland threatened with bankruptcyLetterman’s Top 10 George Bush momentsIs the State of California bankrupt?The Dummy’s Guide to the US Banking CrisisMarc Faber: I advise every American to hold his gold outside of the United StatesTop ten predictions for the 2009 global economyChart of the day: Dow 1928-1932Byron Wien: Ten Surprises for 2009The recession is over but the depression has just begunThe Swedish banking crisis response – a model for the future?AboutThe top 25 European banks by assetsQuantitative easing: printing money like mad to ward off deflationAlbert Edwards: Global economy to roll over in six to nine months’ time; bearish for sharesLehman Brothers: a primer on Credit Default SwapsMarc Faber: China’s numbers are fakeCalifornia will go bankruptChart of the day: Total US DebtCurrency crisis is gathering stormTip Jar

Donation Amount: (Currency: USD)

Repeat Donation: Do not repeatDailyWeeklyMonthlyYearly x

Tag cloud accounting Asia Austrian Economics bailout banking Bank of America bankruptcy blog bonds Britain budget capital Caroline Baum cars central banks Charlie Rose China Citigroup commodities compensation corruption credit credit and credit cards credit cards credit crisis credit ratings crisis solutions debt deflation Democrats derivatives distraction double dip Eastern Europe Economy election Europe Fannie Mae FDIC finance charts financial bubbles financial history financial news financial statements foreclosure forex Freddie Mac Germany gold Goldman Sachs government Greece Housing inflation interest rates international investing investment Ireland Japan jobs law Lehman leverage local manufacturing market wizards media mergers money mortgages nationalization Obama oil outlook Politics populism property protectionism psychology quantitative easing RBS recession recovery regionals regulation retail saving silver small business Society Spain stimulus stocks taxes trade United States video Volcker Willem Buiter

Our SiteIf you want to find out what's going on in the credit crisis, you've come to the right place.

See the Credit Crisis Timeline, which includes a timeline of major crisis events and links to a list of crisis events organized by financial institution. This is the most comprehensive data set of credit crisis-related events on the Internet.

To contact us, click here.

See more information about us.

Posts AuthorsEdward Harrison 3457Marshall Auerback 71Marc Chandler 62Edward Hugh 36Claus Vistesen 13Niels Jensen 12Guest Author 7John Lounsbury 3Rob Parenteau 2Charlie Bull 1CategoriesSelect CategoryBlogs (35)Business (93)Economics (187)Economy (684)Financial Institutions (641)Forecasts (39)Housing (203)Markets (364)More (52)News (621)Political Economy (451)Politics (233)Retrospective (26)Society (33) /* */ var dropdown = document.getElementById("cat"); function onCatChange() { if ( dropdown.options[dropdown.selectedIndex].value > 0 ) { location.href = "http://www.creditwritedowns.com/?cat="+dropdown.options[dropdown.selectedIndex].value; } } dropdown.onchange = onCatChange; /* */ Archives Select Month May 2010 (37) April 2010 (161) March 2010 (165) February 2010 (144) January 2010 (144) December 2009 (169) November 2009 (146) October 2009 (160) September 2009 (106) August 2009 (93) July 2009 (172) June 2009 (113) May 2009 (135) April 2009 (130) March 2009 (179) February 2009 (141) January 2009 (128) December 2008 (117) November 2008 (99) October 2008 (198) September 2008 (162) August 2008 (147) July 2008 (214) June 2008 (218) May 2008 (106) April 2008 (62) March 2008 (18) Search

Disclaimer: All data and information provided on this site is for informational purposes only.

Get free updates via RSS - Twitter - Daily E-mail - Weekly E-mail

English dansk Deutsch ???????? español eesti français italiano æ—¥æ?¬èª? í???ì–´ lietuvi? latvie?u Nederlands norsk polski português Ñ?Ñ?????? svenska ?æ–? (ç®?ä½“) ?æ–? (?é«”) powered by /* */ var pollsL10n = { ajax_url: "http://www.creditwritedowns.com/wp-content/plugins/wp-polls/wp-polls.php", text_wait: "Your last request is still being processed. Please wait a while ...", text_valid: "Please choose a valid poll answer.", text_multiple: "Maximum number of choices allowed: ", show_loading: "1", show_fading: "1" }; /* */ /*'); })();/*]]>*/ where_go_count = new sack("http://www.creditwritedowns.com/index.php"); where_go_count.setVar( "wherego_id", 15781 ); where_go_count.setVar( "wherego_sitevar", document.referrer ); where_go_count.method = 'GET'; where_go_count.onError = function() { alert('Ajax error' )}; where_go_count.runAJAX(); where_go_count = null; FB_RequireFeatures(["XFBML"], function() { FB.init("82121eed751aa250fe490395c481d5d7", "http://www.creditwritedowns.com/?xd_receiver=1", {"permsToRequestOnConnect":"email"}); }); FB.init(Body for a section of developers.facebook.com content.); FB.Event.subscribe('auth.sessionChange', function(response) { if (response.session) }{ // A user has logged in, and a new cookie has been saved } else { // The user has logged out, and the cookie has been cleared } });