Ok. So here's what we do know. It is very unlikely that a "fat finger"--Wall Street lingo for a trader keying in the wrong trade, say selling billions of shares instead of millions--caused the market crash. But what did? Mary Shapiro, the head of the Securities and Exchange Commission, told a Congressional panel today that the SEC still can't determine why the market dropped 1,000 points in 16 minutes. Here's what Shapiro has to say via CNNMoney.com:
Mary Schapiro, chairwoman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, said that the SEC cannot point a single cause behind the events of May 6. The Dow Jones industrial average plummeted 1,000 points, representing about $1 trillion in market value, between 2:40 p.m. and 3:00 p.m. ET last Thursday.
The SEC has historically been one of the slowest moving agencies. They never brought charges against Madoff, until he basically turned himself in, and even the Goldman case is about something that happened a little over two years ago, which in SEC time is kind of quick. But those are investigations where the SEC has to make a judgment call about what is legal and what is fraud. That's not what we are asking for here. Just a basic accounting of who traded what. And even that the SEC can't produce. Aren't these guys supposed to be monitoring the market in real time?
Schapiro said her agency's preliminary investigation has looked at a sharp drop in the value of a particular stock future called the E-mini S&P 500, which investors use to bet on the future performance of stocks in the broad stock index.
The E-mini S&P 500 futures price fell by more than 5% in a few minutes and then quickly recovered, according to Schapiro.
"It should be no surprise that the broader stock market indexes showed similarly fast and similarly large declines and recoveries," Schapiro said, since stock prices follow futures prices. But the correlation doesn't fully explain what happed on Thursday, she added, saying "It could have as readily been events or anomalous activities in individual stocks that caused someone to trade first in the futures markets."
The SEC is also looking into "massive intraday price swings" in shares of many Exchange Traded Funds as a possible factor in the crash, Schapiro said. The shares of more than a quarter of all ETFs experienced brief declines of more than 50% in Thursday's tumult.
"Ultimately, we may learn that the extraordinary disruption in trading, however it may have been triggered, was the result of a confluence of events which, taken together, exacerbated what already had been a down day and led to an extraordinarily steep price drop and recovery," said Schapiro.
I think the interesting thing here is that the 1,000 point drop is highlighting problems not just about the market, but the SEC's ability to monitor the market. The problem is what caused the market to drop does not only have to do with electronic trading, but that a lot of that electronic trading goes on in "Dark Pools." Market watchers have warned about these dark pools for some time, but it hasn't been clear just how much the SEC knows about them. Generally, the exchanges, which make a lot of money off the dark pools, have promoted the practice and have said they have a handle on who is trading what, and have the ability to police what goes on in the dark pools. It's clear now that that is not the case.
To her credit Shapiro has been looking into dark pools. But the fact that the SEC can't determine who bought or sold what during a mere 16 minutes of trading proves that there is a lot more that needs to be done to shed light on the shady corners of the market.
First thing SEC (and everyone else) need to change is the view of 'Free' market. Just because it is 'free' so everything that happens is naturally and supposed to be? I suggest to view it as a wild herd. Of course, it is free because it is Wild. And because it is wild, every human needs to pay close attention. Or it will feed upon you.
(Maybe a better solution: domesticate it!)
I think this highlights the need for regulations. A free market without rules and regulations will give us nothing but more of this sort of chaos. Just like a free society without laws will give us anarchy.
Now that's scary. Up until now I've been assuming that the source of the glitch could be traced like an overloaded circuit in a power outage. With the SEC admitting that's not the case, I can't help but wonder what's being covered up (and who's doing it). Hopefully, the correctional measures being pursued still have some validity.
As a professional trader I feel obligated to shed a little light on this. And I can see from the comments that people seriously have no idea what is going on.
I suppose to the casual observer the market looks like as if it's essentially rallied over the last many months in lockstep with 'better', or more 'promising' news. This is incorrect. What's really happened is the high frequency trading and program trading supercomputers employed by the Primary Dealers - Goldman Sachs, etc. - have falsely pushed the market higher to give the appearance of a healthy market and economy. All of this being based on the 'greater fool theory' that eventually the larger public will be baited into buying stocks thinking that a burgeoning bull market is unfolding and then take those assets off the bank's hands at inflated prices.
But unfortunately for the big banks, people haven't rushed back into the stock market (wisely so), so all of the big investment houses now hold a tremendous amount of inflated assets on their books. At the first sign of trouble their algo-based supercomputers are going to unload them as fast as possible.... essentially overwhelming any so-called 'markets' whether it be NYSE, dark pools, whatever.
The market cratered because there were no buyers. There never were. The primary buyer of stocks over the last year has been computers trading back and forth with each other, nothing more.
SEC is misleading public. "ruled out the possibility that cyber-terrorism" They have no idea, they don't have access to "Dark Pools" where 70% of NYSE trades, no access to data, nets or logs. HEAD OF SEC DIDN'T FIND ANY HACKING ACTIVITY. AND CIA DIDN'T FIND ANY ILLEGAL TRADES???
SPEAKS TO A CONGRESS OF EUNUCHS, NO BALLS, OR REGULATION.
Gerald Internet Anthropologist http://warintel.blogspot.com/2010/05/schapiro-misleads-public-1000-pt-drop.html
Get e-mail updates from TIME's The Curious Capitalist in your inbox and never miss a day.
The Curious Capitalist Favorite Links Barry Ritholtz Brad DeLong Calculated Risk Econbrowser Econlog Epicurean Dealmaker Ezra Klein Felix Salmon Floyd Norris Greg Mankiw Growthology James Pethokoukis John Gapper Justin Fox Marginal Revolution Mark Thoma Matt McAlister Megan McArdle Mike Moffatt Nicholas Carr Paul Kedrosky Paul Krugman Philip Coggan Planet Money Roger Parloff Ryan Avent The Stash adFactory.getCmAd(300, 250, "global", "tout").write(); adFactory.getCmAd(300, 100, "article", "tout").write(); ArchiveMay 2010SMTWTFS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 More News from Our Partners CNN Happy 50th birthday to the laser Google giving up on Nexus One's online store Facebook launches new security feature Huffington Post Stocks Fall On Europe Fears Argentina: Greek Financial Rescue Is Doomed To Fail Lloyd Blankfein Dropped $26 Million In CASH On New Apartment DailyFinance.com Prada Japan Accused of Forcing Staff to Buy its Merchandise Adobe Declares Its Love for Apple, but Apple Loves Chips More Dow Tumbles 162 Points on European Debt Anxiety Rotten Tomato Friday Harvest: Inception, Super 8 trailer, pics, and more! Five Favorite Films with Michael Caine Total Recall: Russell Crowe's Best Movies Life Terror in Thailand The Week's Best Photos: 5.7.10 Canadians Behaving Badly: 05.12.10 More on TIME.com » Congress Takes on the Credit-Rating Agencies Sarah Palin on Her Favorite Subject: Abortion The Mozart Effect: Not Much Effect Quotes of the Day » "The Gulf of Mexico is a very big ocean. The amount of volume of oil and dispersant we are putting into it is tiny in relation." TONY HAYWARD, BP CEO, on the crude oil spilling in Louisiana after an April 20 explosion sank one of the company's oil rigs More Quotes » var ad = adFactory.getAd(88, 31); ad.setPosition(13) ad.write(); Today in Pictures » Suspect Stay Connected with TIME.com Learn More » Subscribe to RSS Feeds Sign Up for Newsletters Add TIME Widgets Read TIME Mobile on Your Phone Become a Fan of TIME Get TIME Twitter Updates adFactory.getCmAd(115, 42, "homepage", "tout").write(); © 2010 Time Inc. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | RSS | Newsletter | TIME For Kids | LIFE.com Subscribe | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Media Kit | Reprints & Permissions | Opinion Leaders Panel | Help | Site Map TiiAdTrackRevSci(); function tiQuantcast() { } _qoptions={ qacct:"p-5dyPa639IrgIw", labels:tiQuantcast() } Powered by WordPress.com VIP var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); try { var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-10268691-1"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {} _qacct='p-18-mFEk4J448M';_qoptions={labels:'adt.0,language.en,vip.timecuriouscapitalist'}; st_go({'blog':'5320466','v':'wpcom','user_id':'0','post':'10163','subd':'timecuriouscapitalist'}); ex_go({'crypt':'RDZ8LFkxbXF2TVluJVFmT0xoZkVaUCVrM3R3cCU2Wi10dTZtNy10XTZYNmhTfmltUFt4QkVba04taWo3UFpjZTA9S1ZaNT9XZ0VnUHZtZyZ6Tm0vZWRsbW93cmtTdyVhMkwrclNyeVY0NSwzbHU0Tk0wV1lhTWNEPXpBd3puNl9NSCY3YW1nLmM3VFsvLVsyVCtHZ2QmR35iVU1LYzZNMSVYPS4vazN3aUdleW9fLnU0dXYxWnUrL3xDa1N+di1ESHd5My5zZEhPdFI0MnBxOVhGc2F+b0dNU0QxUjhlLlM/Y08uSVAveTlf'}); addLoadEvent(function(){linktracker_init('5320466',10163);}); Read Full Article »