A Worrisome Market Sign Is 'Volatile Volatility'

Dow Jones Reprints: This copy is for your personal, non-commerical use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers, use the Order Reprints tool on any article or visit www.djreprints.com

ON WALL STREET, EVENTS THAT CREATE WEALTH are commemorated with souvenirs. My favorite is a Dow 10,000 baseball cap celebrating the first time the index registered five digits. I like this just slightly more than the "It's Back" T-shirt issued when the Dow first recrossed 10,000 -- after it had been practically cleaved in half during the credit crisis.

With the DJIA slouching, yet again, toward 10,000, and the financial system shuddering with uncertainty, some item -- aside from guns and gold -- is needed to express the moment. But selecting an appropriate one is difficult. Volatility is the zeitgeist of this market and this generation. As of deadline, it still was impossible to capture lightning in a bottle.

All that can be said with some modicum of certainty is that the markets are much more nuanced than they were three weeks ago, or even last May. Options traders probably have more opportunities than hazards, but straight stock investors face a near-term future of tumultuous prices.

Pros know this, prima facie, but everyone else should pay close attention to volatility levels in equity and index options. Some of the stock swings are so dramatic that volatility itself is once more volatile. This means you can be right on a stock's direction, and still get clobbered.

Over the years, I've learned to recognize traders' tone of voice as a sentiment indicator. Lately, I hear tense voices -- just as I did during the thick of the credit crisis. And on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, one denizen says he increasingly hears people scream, often in real anger, when stock prices break lower.

This isn't to suggest that dark days similar to those of the financial panic are coming, but rather that a transition seems to be under way, in response to Europe's economic crisis and the mysterious May 6 flash crash.

Volatile volatility itself is another indicator and one that produces surprises. Consider this: Many investors expected the stock market to correct from its extraordinary run since March 2009, but for technical reasons, not because of fundamental problems in Europe.

In a May 14 note to clients the Vicar of Volatility, Buzz Gregory, a derivatives strategist at Goldman Sachs, pointed out that the Chicago Board Options Exchange's CBOE Volatility Index (ticker: VIX) had made an historic swing. Its flash-crash spike to 40, and decline to 27 over the following four days, capped the VIX's most volatile two weeks ever. Volatile volatility makes it difficult to use options to express directional views of stocks, because puts and calls can be too expensive to buy, and too cheap to sell.

How would we know the worst is over? Easy: when the CBOE creates VIX totems with catchphrases like "Make a Friend of Fear."

FOR A CINEMATIC PORTRAYAL of what happens to those who dance with volatility and sometimes win, sometimes lose, let us reintroduce you to filmmaker James Allen Smith.

Last summer, Smith was struggling to bring Floored to the big screen. The movie since has played on big screens in big cities, where film fans have viewed its story about how people struggle with money and change, as the world marches onward. The film is a real-life, grainier version of Oliver Stone's Wall Street. (Wall Street Money Never Sleeps, the sequel to the original, arrives Sept. 24 from 20th Century Fox, which like Barron's is a News Corp. (NWSA) unit.)

If you missed Floored in the theater, it's available on DVD at www.flooredmovie.com.

E-mail: steven.sears@barrons.com

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com

Twitter

Yahoo! Buzz

facebook

MySpace

Digg

LinkedIn

del.icio.us

NewsVine

StumbleUpon

Mixx

A recent surge in the tech giant's shares may have triggered selling. Video: CEOs Sell at Delta, Henry Schein

First-quarter margins disappointed, however fundamentals are improving and the stock looks outright cheap.

Goldman Sachs and Salesforce rose. Brocade and Dell fell.

Sandler O'Neill says Long Island banks generally say the worst is behind.

FBR Capital upgraded the retailer to Outperform.

Dundee Capital is cautious on smaller producers in the near term.

Credit Suisse downgraded the drugstore chain to Neutral.

Growing demand for services that rein in medical costs makes this stock a good health-care pick. Video: Medco Health's Bright Prospects

Fund pro John Buckingham likes oil-services stocks. But he's also a fan of Disney and American Eagle Outfitters.

CA Technologies' outgoing chief operating officer executed the biggest insider sale at the company since August 2007.

Shares of the discount retailer, which Thursday announced a tepid forecast, are now on sale.

Caris & Co. upgraded the energy firm to Above Average.

Collins Stewart likes First Solar the most in the sector.

Needham upgraded the retailer to Buy from Hold and raised estimates.

Shares of Sprint Nextel can benefit from the wireless carrier's early adoption of 4G data transmission technology.

After a dismal week, major indexes end with a strong showing. (At SmartMoney.com.)

It may not have been another "flash crash." But Terrible Thursday proved no slouch at bettering the market. So where do we go from here?

AN INTERVIEW WITH ARTHUR MORETTI: This Neuberger Berman fund manager sees opportunity in the convergence between growth and value.

A revolutionary approach can ease family conflicts and make distributions more predictable.

Data-storage giant EMC is ready to cash in on the next digital explosion.

The popularity of DSL is keeping telecom giant CenturyLink relevant.

As cities and states struggle, investors must be nimble. What to look for in tax-exempt bonds. Our picks.

Europe's biggest banks have been punished more than they deserve.

As it heads toward $1 trillion under management, JPMorgan Private Bank is working to keep service levels high.

Alongside the nuclear controversy, an art scene flourishes. Collectors are taking notice: Prices of Iranian contemporary art have jumped -- and they're likely to keep going up for another five or 10 years. How Westerners are getting in on the action.

Read Full Article »


Comment
Show comments Hide Comments


Related Articles

Market Overview
Search Stock Quotes