As the Queen’s Speech yesterday was overshadowed by yet another meltdown in global financial markets, I was reminded of Her Majesty’s faux-naif remark to the learned professors of the London School of Economics shortly after the failure of Lehman Brothers in the autumn of 2008: why did no one see this crisis coming?
The economists’ official answer, conveyed after another six months of deep cogitation in a three-page letter to Buckingham Palace, was that the economics profession did, of course, see it coming and had warned all along about global imbalances, excessive borrowing and so on. The problem was that politicians, bankers and overpaid financiers did not pay enough attention to the professional economists’ warnings.
The reason I have disinterred this episode is that the learned professors were wrong in their diagnosis of the disaster. The Queen’s question, taken in the context, was not about long-term issues such as mortgage debts and risk-management models. It was about the failure of politicians and economists to foresee the catastrophic consequences of allowing the failure of this one middle-sized bank.
The question of how the failure of Lehman turned a more-or-less normal boom-bust cycle into the greatest financial crisis of all has still not been satisfactorily answered by politicians, establishment economists and central bankers. And now, almost unbelievably, there is a serious risk that the world’s failure to understand the true lessons of Lehman will precipitate another financial disaster.
The key lesson from the failure of Lehman was that, in the midst of a systemic financial crisis, no significant bank should ever be allowed to fail. When an entire financial system is in peril, the cost of offering unlimited government guarantees and taxpayer bailouts will always be much smaller than the losses from allowing any significant bank to collapse. Such bailouts and guarantees may, in the long run, encourage excessive lending and other irresponsible behaviour, but that is an issue to be addressed by regulation after the crisis is over. In dealing with systemic financial crises, the risks of increasing moral hazard are irrelevant in comparison with the certainty of disaster triggered by the failure of any significant bank.
Today exactly the same analysis has to be applied to the risk of Greece or any other European government defaulting on its debts or dropping out of the eurozone. If any such default were to occur, it could trigger a global financial catastrophe even larger than Lehman. Yet the possibility of a Greek debt default or restructuring is being positively promoted by many of the world’s most respected economic and financial commentators. The German Finance Minister has repeatedly suggested temporary suspension from the eurozone as a punishment for the Greek Government’s transgressions. The German representative on the European Central Bank has stated publicly that he voted against the bank buying Greek government bonds. And the leader column of the Financial Times demanded yesterday that Greece must be made “safe to fail”, by preparing the ground for orderly restructuring. Such a restructuring, the FT went on to argue, would punish the German and French banks that were imprudent enough to lend Greece too much money and “whose governments inexcusably prefer to bail them out on the sly via Greece”.
These were exactly the sort of veiled threats, in some cases from the same authorities, heard before Lehman was allowed to collapse. It is hardly surprising that investors are starting to question the solidity of the guarantees against any kind of default that were supposedly provided two weeks ago by eurozone governments and the European Central Bank.
What is truly alarming about the present situation is that the world has so recently seen the catastrophic consequences of using debt defaults in the midst of a financial crisis to punish imprudent lenders. Yet some of the key policymakers and opinion formers seem, like the Bourbons, to have learnt nothing from the Lehman experience and to have forgotten none of their prejudices.
The fact is that if Greece were allowed to renege on its debts, the foreign banks that held €338 billion of Greek debt at the end of 2009 would immediately move to dump their additional €333 billion of Portuguese debt and probably their €1,500 billion of Spanish debt. And who knows how well over two trillion euros of Italian debt would be treated? The plunging value of Greek and Iberian bonds would immediately threaten several of the main French and German banks with insolvency, requiring government guarantees that would run into trillions of euros.
If Greece or any other member of the eurozone were temporarily suspended, as suggested by the German Finance Minister, the consequences would probably be even more catastrophic. The euro would immediately be revealed not as a genuine single currency but merely as a foreign exchange arrangement of the kind that has frequently collapsed under market pressures, for example in Argentina, Thailand and, not least, in the British experience of the ERM.
The citizens of Southern European countries would quickly understand this and would transfer their savings to banks in Germany and the Netherlands, leading to a collapse of the euro project within weeks and the probable failure of every Southern European bank.
Any such upheavals would dash hopes of global recovery from the 2008 crisis and would cause irreparable damage to public finances already on the brink of catastrophe. It is obvious that such calamities must be avoided, almost regardless of cost or whether it sets a bad example to improvident governments or bankers.
Astonishingly, however, the Greek tragedy in Europe is looking more and more like a revival of the Lehman drama. The €750 billion bailout package announced two weeks ago by EU governments is being hedged about with so many conditions and qualifications that it resembles the original $700 billion Bush bailout plan. The 16 bickering leaders of the eurozone seem to be emulating the confusion of the US political establishment and multiplying it by 16. And the starring role of the ideologically blinkered and incompetent President Bush, out of his depth and flailing helplessly in matters of high finance, is played by Angela Merkel.
Even as a long-time sceptic about the euro project, I find it almost impossible to believe that, just two years after Lehman, Europe would make the same blunders as the Bush Administration. But, as we have learnt again and again in this long period of turmoil, the impossible can become inevitable without even passing through improbable.
Order By:
Would you like to post a comment? Please register or log in
function blogURL(bUrls) { window.location=bUrls; } fieldset { float:left; width:165px; border:0px; margin:0px; padding:0px; } OUR COLUMNISTS
Columnists
Select David Aaronovitch Simon Barnes Camilla Cavendish Jeremy Clarkson Giles Coren Robert Crampton Bill Emmott Daniel Finkelstein Michael Gove Anatole Kaletsky India Knight Dominic Lawson Leo Lewis Rod Liddle Magnus Linklater Ben MacIntyre Bronwen Maddox Minette Marrin Carol Midgley Caitlin Moran Richard Morrison Matthew Parris Michael Portillo Libby Purves William Rees-Mogg Melanie Reid Peter Riddell Hugo Rifkind Sathnam Sanghera Frank Skinner Graham Stewart Andrew Sullivan Rachel Sylvester Janice Turner Guest contributorsBlogs
Select Alpha Mummy Archive Blog David Aaronovitch Asia Exile Baby Barista Blockbuster Buzz Charles Bremner Big Brother Mary Beard Comment Central Cricket Blog Faith Central Formula One Ruth Gledhill Inside Iraq Ariel Leve India Knight Money Rafael Nadal News Blog William Rees-Mogg Rugby Sinofile Mick Smith Sports Commentary Irwin Stelzer Peter Stothard Technology Travel Urban dirt Wimbledon Anatole KaletskyAnatole Kaletsky writes for The Times Comment pages on Thursdays. One of the country's leading commentators on economics, he was formerly Economics Editor and is now Editor-at-large of The Times. He has won many awards for his financial and political journalism. Before joining The Times, he worked for 12 years on the Financial Times
Read more from Anatole Kaletsky Peter StothardThe Editor of the TLS writes on books, people and politics
A Don's LifeMary Beard of Cambridge and the TLS on culture ancient and modern
Live Q&A How to make politics work for youDaniel Blythe answers your voting questions. With a free e-book download.
Every country leads the world in one field. Guess the UK's? Comment Central MOST READ MOST COMMENTED MOST CURIOUS Most Read Skip Most Read Today No-holds barred Cameron ditches... Duchess of York urged to ‘come... On constant alert for a war in Korea that... Jamaica gun battles claim 60 lives MOST COMMENTED Skip Editor's Pick Today if(isArticle == "true" && articleHeadlines.length!=0){ for(var j=0; j=45){ headline = articleHeadlines[j].substring(0,44)+"..."; } document.write(""+headline +""); } }else{ fSubmitMostCommented('http://community.timesonline.co.uk/ver1.0/Direct/Process'); } MOST CURIOUS Skip Most Curious Today Three new BBC executives to be paid more... After six years, finale of the TV drama Lost... Wherefore art thou Romeo, begging audiences... HMS Victory sails into bottle at Trafalgar... Focus Zone Need to Know:Up-to-date industry sectors news at a glance: interactive heatmap, daily video and podcast
Mapping Business:This week: Healthcare. Painful medicine for the economy is cause for concern for all
Discover Normandy :Win the chance to visit one of France's most beautiful regions. Plus: find out about its delicious food and impressive art history
Cool Camping:Long gone are the days of damp tents and flimsy caravans: our guide shows you everything you need to know to 'glamp' in style
More reports:Enjoy further reading from where to find the best tradesmen to the new trend for 'bleisure' travel
Need to Know Mapping Business Discover Normandy Cool Camping More reports Births, deaths, marriagesPlace your announcement
Encounters DatingWe'd love to find you someone special
Crossword ClubSign up today or try one of our free demo crosswords
Free CV ReviewSell yourself! Have your CV reviewed by experts
AnnouncementsSearch The Times Births, Marriages & Deaths
Online Sudoku with daily prizes Find a LawyerCut your legal costs
Classifieds Cars Jobs Property Travel Cars Skip Cars of the Week Stratstone, the No.1 Choice for Luxury Cars.Europe’s largest independent Jaguar Dealer group with 23 locations across the UK. To view our latest New Car Offers and Jaguar Approved Vehicles visit Stratstone.com.
Mercedes Benz E-ClassCabriolet 2010 £43,850 Bedford
Bleisure Travel: The Best of Both WorldsLand Rover Range Rover 4.2 V8
2006 £27,950 West Yorkshire
Search for more cars and bikes Jobs Skip Jobs of the Week Negotiation ConsultantSix Figure Package The Gap Partnership UK - International travel
Head of Business Management Unit£68,672 + travel allowance BMJ Group Harrogate
Head of Business Management Unit£68,672 + travel allowance AQA Harrogate
Consultancy careers£80,000+ Kpmg London
Search more Jobs Properties New Canaan, Connecticut, United StatesBreathtaking interiors, indoor golf range, manicured grounds, enclosed courtyard, stunning pool, charming carriage house & additional 3 bedroom guest house. £6,491,752 GBP
Only 20 minutes from the City Beautifully designed townhouses of 3,800sqft,woodland views in Chislehurst.5 beds, 4 baths, 3 receptions, kitchen/breakfast, landscaped garden & private parking.
Clapham NorthDouble Room with own Bathroom to Rent £150pw
It’s in your hands!30% off key ready properties in Cyprus, guaranteed fast and easy finance. Prices from 89,000 Euros!
Search for more properties Holidays Skip Travel of the Week Volcano Special!Visit Iceland with Discover the World for a once in a lifetime opportunity to witness this powerful force of nature. 3-night break from £312. Longer self-drive options available.
Royal Caribbean: Independence of the Seas Deals!Sail from Southampton throughout 2010 & 2011 from just £279 pp. Book now for FREE parking or regional coach transfers!
Save over £500 - Cote d’Azur luxury villa special offersHand picked villas with pools with Quality Villas Ltd. Provence, St Tropez & more
Celebrity Cruises Luxury 2011 CruisesFor the best savings book your 2011 Celebrity Cruise with Iglucruise.com now plus enjoy FREE parking or regional coach transfers.
Search for more holidays Place your advert nowSearch Ad Reference:
Read Full Article »