I'm not the only person out there trying to reconcile how gold could be both an inflation hedge and a deflation hedge.
How a thing could be something while at the same time being the opposite of that something is a logic puzzle worthy of Raymond Smullyan or perhaps the Tootsie Pop Owl.
Apparently, there is a line of reasoning out there that may be of help to those troubled by the inflation/deflation hedging potential of gold ownership.
From WhiskeyAndGunpowder.com (I know, awesome):
Knowing how governments will respond to deflation, the case for inflation-proof gold looks increasingly clear to cautious wealth"¦
Useless for pretty much everything except storing wealth (its economic value is social, not industrial), gold acts as inflation-proof money when investors need it most "” right in the middle of an asset-price deflation.
Given central banks' default response to any level of financial stress, it's a unique and appealing attribute. Because rather than leaving cash hoarders alone, sub-zero real rates of interest "” plus the ever-present threat of massive devaluation "” force sleepless nights on cautious savers. (The risk of banking collapse is an extra, but non-government-inspired threat.)
In simpler terms, the case for gold-as-deflation-hedge can be made based on the obviousness of what policy response will likely be toward deflation - deliberate inflating.
Think of it this way - if you are a cartoon character and your house is infested by mice, you should buy a whip and a chair, because eventually someone will be bringing in a lion to deal with those meeces mice.
It is this chess-like premonition of cause-and-effect that allows you to look at gold as both a deflation and an inflation hedge - you're simply predicting that the powers that be will swing their pendulum too far in each direction.
If you've hit upon this answer before I have, one gold star for you. I'm not always the quickest, but eventually I get there.
Riddle solved, next!
Source:
Gold Is an Inflation-Proof Deflation Hedge (Whiskey and Gunpowder)
Tags: $GLD
Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.
The Reformed Broker is a blog about Wall Street, the economy, politics and anything else. Joshua Brown has been managing money for high net worth clients, charitable foundations, corporations and retirement plans. (More »)
Follow me on: Twitter and StockTwits
Sign up for your FREE Daily Goodness e-mail delivered each morning with the latest investment news.
Which update would you like to receive?
Overheard on StockTwits
Chartly Technical Knockout
AR Energy
Macro Weekly
AR Options
The official StockTwits™ newsletter
Copyright © 2010 StockTwits Inc. All rights reserved. Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms and Conditions. Blog Design by Genevate
Read Full Article »