One Page Destroys the Gov't "Economic Savior" Myth

Go to PDF Version | Go to Recent Issues

To save time in the future, you may select one of the preferences below. You may update your eIBD preferences at any time by going into My IBD and selecting Update Your eIBD Preferences.

Set Web-Based Version as Default Set PDF Version as Default Set Recent Issues as Default

Get QuoteSearch Site

Daily Graphs Online

 View Enlarged Image

Sometimes you can read a book that will change your mind on some fundamental issue.

Rarely, however, is there just one page that can undermine or destroy a widely held belief. But there is such a page — Page 77 of the book "Out of Work" by Richard Vedder and Lowell Gallaway.

The widespread belief is that government intervention is the key to getting the country out of a serious economic downturn.

The example often cited is President Franklin D. Roosevelt's intervention, after the stock market crash of 1929 was followed by the Great Depression of the 1930s, with its massive and long-lasting unemployment.

This is more than just a question about history.

Right here and right now there is a widespread belief that the unregulated market is what got us into our present economic predicament, and that the government must "do something" to get the economy moving again. FDR's intervention in the 1930s has often been cited by those who think this way.

What is on that one page in "Out of Work" that could change people's minds? Just a simple table, giving unemployment rates for every month during the entire decade of the 1930s.

Those who think that the stock market crash in October 1929 is what caused the huge unemployment rates of the 1930s will have a hard time reconciling that belief with the data in that table.

Although the big stock market crash occurred in October 1929, unemployment never reached double digits in any of the next 12 months after that crash.

Unemployment peaked at 9%, two months after the stock market crashed — and then began drifting generally downward over the next six months, falling to 6.3% by June 1930. This was what happened in the market, before the federal government decided to "do something."

What the government decided to do in June 1930 — against the advice of literally a thousand economists, who took out newspaper ads warning against it — was impose higher tariffs, in order to save American jobs by reducing imported goods.

This was the first massive federal intervention to rescue the economy, under President Herbert Hoover, who took pride in being the first president of the United States to intervene to try to get the economy out of an economic downturn.

Within six months after this government intervention, unemployment shot up into double digits — and stayed in double digits in every month throughout the entire remainder of the decade of the 1930s, as the Roosevelt administration expanded federal intervention far beyond what Hoover had started.

In 1992, the feminists in the media rejoiced at what they called "The Year of the Woman," when 10 Democratic women (and one Republican) ran for the Senate in the aftermath of Anita Hill's unproven sexual-harassment allegations against Clarence Thomas. Just two years before, seven Republican women ...

'Sometimes," George Orwell admonished, "the first duty of intelligent men is the restatement of the obvious." That's what I want to do — talk about the obvious. Suppose that a person is faced with the choice of spending $50,000 on a brand-new car or paying two years' worth of college tuition ...

The big oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is bad enough in itself. But politics can make anything worse. Let's stop and think. Either the government knows how to stop the oil spill or they don't. If they know how to stop it, then why have they let thousands of barrels of oil per day keep gushing out, ...

A political candidate can take on the public-employee unions in a nasty street rumble and emerge bloodied but victorious. That's the message from Tuesday's election to fill a board of supervisors seat in Orange County, Calif. It was a race that could have statewide and even national implications ...

In announcing the passage of a U.N. Security Council resolution imposing sanctions on Iran, President Obama stressed not once but twice Iran's increasing "isolation" from the world. This claim is not surprising considering that after 16 months of an "extended hand" policy, in response to which Iran ...

Posted By: thebassman(855) on 6/17/2010 | 9:20 PM ET

O isn't about equal opportunity - he & rest of dems are only for opportunity of their preferred (as in contributors, unions etc) constituents. The point of the article is O & Dems are replicating, and then some, the POLICY DECISIONS the CREATED the DEPRESSION. They have added MORE DEBT to date than the entire history of US. My kids & grandkids will have a MUCH TOUGHER ROAD than any of us - all thanks to pols in general, O & dems currently in power in particular. O about control - always has been

Posted By: moonhawk(5) on 6/17/2010 | 9:19 PM ET

More like "affirmative action" than "equal opportunity"... and living proof that it's a bad idea.

Posted By: Hanuman(180) on 6/17/2010 | 8:52 PM ET

Creating strawmen to know down may be fun, but it doesn't reflect reality. BHO has been the beneficiary of an effective meritocracy an opportunity that he took full advantage of to earn his way to becoming the first African American president. Our Constitution talks about equal opportunity and if anyone was ever for that, its BHO.

Posted By: Brownknows(2070) on 6/17/2010 | 7:46 PM ET

Sadly BHO believes capitalism is evil, that wealth must be redistributed back to the rightful owners (poor/limosine liberals/rulers) through any means legal or extra-legal; see Chrysler takeover, BP shake down, pay czars, EPA regulations, and mandated purchase of a product. Pure ideologue with a smooth tounge, until his first speech from the oval office. Eyes are opening, and Americans don't like what they see. If only BHO had an ounce of Sowell's intelligence & integrity. Live free or die.

To participate in Community areas, please Sign In or Register

Register

Don't be afraid to take some profit when your stock has run up a reasonable amount.

Get QuoteSearch Site

Read Full Article »


Comment
Show comments Hide Comments


Related Articles

Market Overview
Search Stock Quotes