Were the Bush Tax Cuts Good for Growth?

Liz Peek at FoxNews.com congratulates me for writing about the importance of economic growth. So in the spirit of maximizing growth, I want to pose a question: Why should we believe that extending the Bush tax cuts will provide a big lift to growth?

Those tax cuts passed in 2001 amid big promises about what they would do for the economy. What followed? The decade with the slowest average annual growth since World War II. Amazingly, that statement is true even if you forget about the Great Recession and simply look at 2001-7.

The competition for slowest growth is not even close, either. Growth from 2001 to 2007 averaged 2.39 percent a year (and growth from 2001 through the third quarter of 2010 averaged 1.66 percent). The decade with the second-worst showing for growth was 1971 to 1980 — the dreaded 1970s — but it still had 3.21 percent average growth.

The picture does not change if you instead look at five-year periods. Here’s a chart ranking five-year periods over the past 50 years, in descending order of average annual growth:

I mean this as a serious question, not a rhetorical one: Given this history, why should we believe that the Bush tax cuts were pro-growth?

Is there good evidence the tax cuts persuaded more people to join the work force (because they would be able to keep more of their income)? Not really. The labor-force participation rate fell in the years after 2001 and has never again approached its record in the year 2000.

Is there evidence that the tax cuts led to a lot of entrepreneurship and innovation? Again, no. The rate at which start-up businesses created jobs fell during the past decade.

The theory for why tax cuts should create growth and jobs is a strong one. When people are allowed to keep more of each dollar they earn, they are likely to work longer and harder. The uncertainty is the magnitude of this effect. With everything else that’s happening in a $15 trillion economy, how large of an effect on growth do tax cuts have?

Every available piece of evidence seems to suggest that the Bush tax cuts did little to lift growth. I have yet to hear a good argument to the contrary, but I’d be fascinated to see another blogger or an economist take a crack at it.

Update: A reader asks for statistics on real economic growth (that is, adjusted for inflation). The above chart is already adjusted for inflation.

Every available piece of evidence seems to suggest that the Bush tax cuts did little to lift growth.

To reduce the federal deficit, Americans should recognize that taxes are too low and health care costs are out of control, an economist writes.

Start fixing the budget deficit by overhauling the overly complex and out-of-date tax system, an economist writes.

A budget reflects a nation’s priorities and should be determined by the people and their legislators, while economists can best be used to help decide which options best serve those priorities, an economist writes.

Is economic growth a means, or an end? That question surfaces again and again in the United Nations Development Project’s latest Human Development Report.

Cartoons, graphic art and “graphic recordings” are enlivening presentations of economics in many forums, an economist writes.

An explanation of the interactive deficit puzzle on The Times’s Web site and the article in Sunday’s Week in Review.

Much has been written about anti-incumbent fervor in the midterm election. But aside from a few high-profile races, incumbents actually fared very well.

While the Medicare fee structure is dictated by the government, not the market, it is a legacy of Republican administrations, an economist writes.

Blue-ribbon panel after blue-ribbon panel has advocated some variation of the same set of fiscal policy reform ideas. If there is so much wonkish agreement, why hasn’t anything changed?

Catherine Rampell is the economics editor at nytimes.com.

David Leonhardt writes the Economic Scene column, which appears in The Times on Wednesdays.

Motoko Rich is an economics reporter for The New York Times.

Michael Powell is an economics reporter for The New York Times.

Steven Greenhouse writes about labor and workplace issues for The New York Times.

Liz Alderman writes about European economics, finance and business from Paris.

Sewell Chan writes about economic issues from Washington D.C.

Jack Ewing writes about European economics and business from Frankfurt.

Economists offer readers insights about the dismal science.

Economics doesn’t have to be complicated. It is the study of our lives "” our jobs, our homes, our families and the little decisions we face every day. Here at Economix, David Leonhardt, Catherine Rampell and other contributors will analyze the news and use economics as a framework for thinking about the world. We welcome feedback, at economix@nytimes.com.

In order to view this feature, you must download the latest version of flash player here. var so = new SWFObject('http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash/business/20081008-credit-charts-graphic/credit3.1.swf','nytSWF',337,385,9,'#FFFFFF'); so.addParam('allowScriptAccess','always'); so.addParam('allowFullScreen','true'); so.addParam('BASE','http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash/business/20081008-credit-charts-graphic/'); so.addVariable('allowCaching',true); so.write('embed70'); #embed70{visibility:visible !important;}h2.multiHeadline {font-size:156% !important;padding:0px 0px 7px !important;margin:6px 6px 11px 3px !important;border-bottom:1px solid #CCCCCC !important;}

Introducing

Apture allows readers to dig deeper into a subject without ever leaving the blog post. When you click on any link marked by the icons , , or , you will be able to view video, reference materials, images and other related media. Please e-mail your feedback and thoughts on this feature to apture@nyt.com.

Multimedia Breaking Down the Bailout

An accounting of the government’s rescue package.

How the Government Dealt With Past Recessions

Three economists explain what worked and what didn't.

Geography of a Recession

A map of unemployment rates across the United States, now through January.

Related Article In order to view this feature, you must download the latest version of flash player here. var so = new SWFObject('http://www.nytimes.com/packages/flash/multimedia/swfs/AS3Multiloader.swf','nytSWF',165,104,9,'#FFFFFF'); so.addParam('allowScriptAccess','always'); so.addParam('allowFullScreen','true'); so.addParam('wmode','opaque'); so.addParam('BASE','http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash/us/20090300-economy-user-photos/promos/'); so.addVariable('contentPath','http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/flash/us/20090300-economy-user-photos/promos/163quilty.swf'); so.addVariable('allowCaching',true); so.write('embed443'); #embed443{visibility:visible !important;}

Faces, numbers and stories from behind the downturn.

Special Features The Debt Trap

A series about the surge in consumer debt and the lenders who made it possible.

The Reckoning

A series exploring the origins of the financial crisis, from Washington to Wall Street.

Blogroll Blogroll Barking Up the Wrong Tree Brad DeLong Cafe Hayek Calculated Risk Capital Gains and Games Dani Rodrik's Weblog DataPoints: The Dismal Scientist Blog Econbrowser EconLog Economist's View Greg Mankiw Marginal Revolution Nouriel Roubini's Global EconoMonitor Nudge Raghu Rajan Robert Reich Tax.com TaxProf TaxVox The Baseline Scenario The Becker-Posner Blog The Big Picture Will Wilkinson: The Fly Bottle Blogs From Newspapers and Magazines Andrew Sullivan Ezra Klein Felix Salmon Floyd Norris Freakonomics Free exchange (The Economist) James Surowiecki Megan McArdle Money-Supply (Financial Times) Paul Krugman Real Time Economics (WSJ) Wolf Forum (Financial Times) Economic Resources Employment Statistics GeoFRED: Geographic Federal Reserve Data Historical Data on Job Growth and Wages Historical Unemployment Data Inflation Calculator Interactive Housing Calculator International G.D.P. Rankings Latest Job Market Data Local Gas Prices Statistics on Income, Poverty and Health Insurance Coverage in the U.S. U.S. G.D.P. Statistics Tag List DAILY ECONOMIST 498 TAXES 247 UNEMPLOYMENT 241 HEALTH CARE 216 EMPLOYMENT 128 UWE E. REINHARDT 119 EDWARD L. GLAESER 118 HOUSING 118 STIMULUS 116 HEALTH INSURANCE 110 CASEY B. MULLIGAN 102 JOBS 101 JOBS REPORT 100 SIMON JOHNSON 94 WOMEN IN THE WORKFORCE 91 NANCY FOLBRE 86 RECESSION 86 CHINA 78 BUDGET DEFICIT 78 FEDERAL RESERVE 78 U.S. HEALTH CARE COSTS 78 FINANCIAL CRISIS 70 EDUCATION 70 BANKS 67 BAILOUT 66 HIGHER EDUCATION 66 INTERNATIONAL ECONOMICS 65 GREAT RECESSION 65 STOCKS 61 MAP 61 Archive Select Month November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 Follow The New York Times »FacebookTwitterYouTubeRSS Home World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos Back to Top Copyright 2010 The New York Times Company Privacy Terms of Service Search Corrections RSS First Look Help Contact Us Work for Us Advertise Site Map function apture_onload() { apture.addCallback(apture.WINDOW_OPEN, function() { dcsMultiTrack('DCS.dcssip','www.nytimes.com','DCS.dcsuri','/blogs/Apture.html','WT.ti','Apture','WT.z_dcsm','1'); }); } if (typeof NYTD.Blogs.user != 'undefined') { if(NYTD.Blogs.user.isLoggedIn()) { var dcsvid=NYTD.Blogs.user.getId(); var regstatus="registered"; } else { var dcsvid=""; var regstatus="non-registered"; } } var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-4406282-67"); pageTracker._initData(); pageTracker._trackPageview(); if((document.referrer).indexOf(document.location.hostname) == -1) { var referrer = document.referrer; } else { var referrer = ''; } document.write('');

Apture allows readers to dig deeper into a subject without ever leaving the blog post. When you click on any link marked by the icons , , or , you will be able to view video, reference materials, images and other related media. Please e-mail your feedback and thoughts on this feature to apture@nyt.com.

An accounting of the government’s rescue package.

Three economists explain what worked and what didn't.

A map of unemployment rates across the United States, now through January.

Faces, numbers and stories from behind the downturn.

A series about the surge in consumer debt and the lenders who made it possible.

A series exploring the origins of the financial crisis, from Washington to Wall Street.

Read Full Article »