There's no shortage of chatter about the challenges facing the municipal bond market. Headlines about deeply indebted states and cities – combined with the Federal Government's own soaring debt – have provided ample ammunition to muni bond bears.
Meredith Whitney, an analyst who made her name forecasting trouble for banks ahead of the financial crisis, began arguing last September that big defaults are ahead in the $3 trillion muni bond market. Her comments rocked the market, led to outflows from muni bond funds and sent various muni bond ETFs reeling.
Video: Are Muni-Bond Fears Overblown?
With many cities and states facing dire financial situations, WSJ's Dave Kansas talks with SmartMoney's Janet Paskin about the risk of investing in muni-bonds and the likelihood that some municipalities could default on those bonds.
Should investors be concerned about all the heavy breathing? Mostly, the answer is no. Muni bonds remain a relatively safe way to invest and earn money in a tax protected fashion. It's not sexy, but sometimes slow-and-steady wins the race.
There are, of course, caveats and investors should always pay attention -- the financial crisis has taught us that the seemingly sacrosanct can surprise. Even seemingly super safe money funds got caught in that inferno.
Much of the muni bonds "safety" reputation stems from investment-grade ratings. If a big state, say California or Illinois, gets downgraded below investment-grade, that will certainly be a red flag for that locality. But shrewd muni bond investors always remember that, like real estate, munis are a highly localized market and a broad downdraft in the wake of such a move (which remains speculative) would present opportunities elsewhere.
Here are three additional things to bear in mind when thinking about all things muni.
• History . The stories of past defaults aren't always explained. The term default has many meanings.
• Variety . There are many flavors of muni bonds, and some are safer than others.
• Interest rates . The rate environment is shifting, which may overtake all the talk about defaults.
First, history. As you've no doubt read elsewhere, the history of muni bond defaults is incredibly small. According to Moody's Investors Service the average default rate for investment-grade muni bonds is 0.03% -- sharply lower than for similarly rated corporate bonds. In the four decades before 2010, Moody's said 54 rated bonds defaulted.
Default, of course, means many things. At first glance, one would think a default would mean the investor got hosed. But usually, that's not the case.
In one of the highest profile defaults, the Orange County, Calif., 1994 bankruptcy, muni bondholders were ultimately made whole. More recently, Harrisburg, Penn., "defaulted" in Sept. 2010 when it missed a bond payment. Days later, the state stepped in and the bond holders were made whole.
One of the more famous bond defaults is the Arkansas default in 1933 during the Great Depression. After much haggling between bondholders and the state, eventually the bondholders were paid off after Arkansas raised taxes to fund the bonds. (Joe Mysak, the maestro of all things muni, chronicled this moment in history .)
Now, of course, the default rate isn't zero. In the 1970s, the Washington Public Power Supply System defaulted on $2.25 billion in bonds when its plan to build five nuclear power plants went a cropper. Investors recovered between a dime and 40 cents on the dollar.
But the WPPSS bonds were tied to a specific plan – the building of power plants. And therein lies the next lesson.
There are many types of muni bonds, and those tied to a specific, prospective thing, such as building nuclear plants, tend to be among the riskiest. Here are the main types of munis:
General Obligation (or "GO") bonds . These bonds are backed by the issuing government's full faith and credit. In other words, they are promising to pay back the bonds no matter what. Governments have a lot of tools to make this happen. The biggest, of course, is raising taxes, which is what Arkansas did back in the 1930s. Given the power to raise taxes, governments are in a strong position to honor their GO bond obligations. These are considered the safest of the historically safe muni bond environment.
Trackback URL for this story: http://www.smartmoney.com/tb/Jd.2Br.2F9c.3D
What is a Trackback?It is a way to tell us that you have published something that references this story.
How do I send a Trackback? If you blog or mention this story on your website, you can use this Trackback URL to notify us about it. Some blogging software programs can help in sending a Trackback to us.
Click here to read more about Trackbacks.
Report Spam/Abuse
Unlike a simple calculator or worksheet, lifeplan provides step-by-step actions to help you put - and keep - your financial house in order.
This award winning column addresses estate planning, individual retirement accounts, long-term-care insurance and strategies for selecting variable annuities.
Read Full Article »