A Market Crash Early Warning System

Brandon Keim Wired March 21, 2011

Complexity researchers who study the behavior of stock markets may have identified a signal that precedes crashes.

They say the telltale sign is a measure of co-movement, or the likelihood of stocks to move in the same direction. When a market is healthy, co-movement is low. But in the months and years before a crash, co-movement seems to grow.

Regardless of whether stock prices go up or down or stay the same, they do so in tandem. People are copying each other, and a small nudge can send everyone in the same direction. The system appears primed for collapse.

“One of the most important things happening now is that economists are trying to understand, what is systemic risk? When is the entire system vulnerable to disaster? Our results show that we have a direct, unambiguous measure of that vulnerability,” said Yaneer Bar-Yam, president of the New England Complex Systems Institute.

Bar-Yam’s findings, released Feb. 13 on arXiv, are part of an emerging research field known as econophysics. It applies to economics insights from the physical world, especially from systems in which networks of interacting units produce radical collective behaviors.

Heated water turning to gas is one such behavior, known technically as a phase transition. Another is snow gathering into an avalanche. Seen through an econophysicist’s eyes, a stock market panic is an avalanche, too.

Using a phase-transition model, Bar-Yam’s group analyzed patterns of movement in the stock market. At the beginning of the 2000s, co-movement was low. On any given day, about half the stocks were moving up or down. By 2008, shortly before the crash, co-movement was absolute. People were no longer making independent decisions, but copying others.

“There’s a break point where the system is flat — equally likely to have any number of stocks moving together on a particular day,” said Bar-Yam. “And if you see these collective behaviors building up, then you know you’re in trouble.”

At top, a metric of stock co-movement during the 2000s. As it gets closer to zero, individual stocks are more likely to move up or down in the same direction. At bottom is the Russell 3000 Index.

After expanding the analysis back to 1985, they found periods of increasing co-movement within four years before each major crash, though never so starkly as before 2008. The researchers also propose that increasing co-movement fuels large, single-day market drops.

Jeffrey Fuhrer, researcher director at the Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, called the results intriguing but preliminary, requiring more rigorous statistical examination.

“As an initial pass, it’s an interesting idea,” he said, but doesn’t yet distinguish when investors respond rationally and independently to the same information, such as a rise in fuel prices, or move reflexively as a herd.

However, the line between those trends may be blurry. According to Bar-Yam’s group, external stresses — fuel prices, war, the perception of market bubbles — may increase the market sensitivity, making it more vulnerable to panic. So might changes in the very structure of markets, from their increasingly interlocking nature to instant-communication tools.

Fuhrer’s cautions were echoed by econophysicist Tobias Preis of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology. “One should be very careful about generalization to predict future crises,” he said. “The most important point is to quantify this risk. That would be a huge step forward.”

If co-movement does prove to be a reliable early warning signal, it’s an open question how to make use of it. “That is one of the $64,000 questions,” said Fuhrer.

Whereas bailing out a company is relatively simple, intervening in the dynamics of a system is not. But the first step is understanding that markets follow rules we’re just beginning to understand.

“The financial crisis has shown that mainstream economic theories have limitations that need to be overcome,” said Dirk Helbing of the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, who specializes in modeling crowd behavior. “Economic systems have become much more complex, and complex systems have certain features — cascading effects, systemic shifts. This calls for new theoretical approaches.”

See Also:

Citation: “Predicting economic market crises using measures of collective.” By Dion Harmon, Marcus A. M. de Aguiar, David D. Chinellato, Dan Braha, Irving R. Epstein, Yaneer Bar-Yam. arXiv, Feb. 13, 2011.

Tags: Complexity, economics, econophysics, networks Post Comment | Permalink (function() { var s = document.createElement('SCRIPT'), s1 = document.getElementsByTagName('SCRIPT')[0]; s.type = 'text/javascript'; s.async = true; s.src = 'http://widgets.digg.com/buttons.js'; s1.parentNode.insertBefore(s, s1); })(); tweetmeme_style = 'compact'; Digg wired:http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2011/03/market-panic-signs/ Stumble Upon Delicious Reddit if(typeof CN!=='undefined' && CN.dart){ CN.dart.call("blogsBody",{sz: "300x250", kws : ["bottom"]}); } Anonymous

There will always be market crashes, especially since we have a monetary system that is “money as debt” based. Please watch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVkFb26u9g8, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_doYllBk5No http://www.digitalcoin.info/The_Essence_of_Money.html Once one understands the unsustainable system of usury then micro and macro economics becomes easier to comprehend then confusion and obfuscation are replaced by clarity.

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_VW7P3VRAVGQ4K5OST6ZNAWLMNY Rob

Making this “co-movement” information widely available will change how the system behaves–observing alters the thing being observed.

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_X332JSUGUDXNCIWI6HLN3HAECQ Mario Marmaris

Witamy na Dobry-start.com! Strona startowa, to przewa?nie graficzna wersja ulubionych zakÅ?adek, tak wiÄ?c zamiast ka?dorazowo wpisywaÄ? adres www, bÄ?dziesz mógÅ? klikaÄ? i wchodziÄ? na ulubione strony. Przygotowalismy dla Was dziaÅ?y takie jak rozrywka, informacje, radio i telewizja, bramka sms oraz linki do banków, czy te? poczty. Je?eli nie podoba Ci siÄ? uklad strony, kolorystyka, mo?esz Å?atwo to zmieniÄ? za pomoca motywów, dostepnych w menu. Je?eli chcesz, aby na stronie pojawily siÄ? twoje ulubione strony, napisz do Nas. Teraz Twoja ulubiona strona startowa dostÄ?pna bÄ?dzie z ka?dego komputera. Wystarczy zapamietaÄ? http://www.Dobry-start.com.

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_X332JSUGUDXNCIWI6HLN3HAECQ Mario Marmaris

http://naturetm.com/ NatureTM

So, some bad information is released and everybody thinks together, “oh shit! SELL!” I feel like this just is showing that, when everyone agrees the entire market is at risk, they all do the same thing. Duh?

Anonymous

Yes, the self-knowledge-feedback makes this fundamentally chaotic, in ways that (for example) the weather is not. Thunderstorms aren’t sentient, attempting to maximize their net/wet worth.

http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1432958068 Teja Pasupuleti

I see a silver Apple! RUN!!

http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1432958068 Teja Pasupuleti

I see a silver Apple! RUN!!

Anonymous

Does anyone on Main Street America really care whaty happens on Wall Street? I know I sure dont.

http://www.anon-tools.es.tc

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EUAWAEMJ7WNCRJP54AJM246AQQ Stanley Smyla

EFT’s!!!! DUH!!!!

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EUAWAEMJ7WNCRJP54AJM246AQQ Stanley Smyla

EFT’s!!!! DUH!!!!

Anonymous

An interesting, and consonant, follow-on to Didier Sornette’s work on the subject.

http://www.facebook.com/people/Joe-Orton/100002165514574 Joe Orton

I agree with rob. And now Im going to buy my lottery ticket. http://www.euro-millions.net

blog comments powered by Disqus /* */ /* */ /* */ function loadCurArticleComments() { loadComments(escape('http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2011/03/market-panic-signs/'), 0, 10, false); } loadCurArticleComments(); if(typeof CN!=='undefined' && CN.dart){ CN.dart.call("xrailTop",{sz: "300x250", kws : ["top"]}); } Wired Science Blogs #sidebar-blogs{border-top:solid 10px #000; padding-top:10px; margin-bottom:20px; } #sidebar-col1{width: 140px; float:left; margin-right:20px; clear:both; padding-bottom:10px; height:180px; } #sidebar-col2{width: 140px; float:right; padding-bottom:10px; height:180px; } .sidebar-title { width:140px; height: 35px; margin-bottom:10px; } .sidebar-title img {float:left;margin-right:10px;} .sidebar-title .blurb { display:block; font-size:11px; border-bottom:5px solid #b1e724; float:left; width:95px; height:30px;} .sidebar-title a{color:#000;} .sidebar-title a:hover {background-color:#FFF !important;} #sidebar-blogs #twitter{padding-left:20px; height:20px; background:url('/wiredscience/wp-content/gallery/scienceblogs/icons.gif')no-repeat -4px -62px;} A new network of all-star science bloggers. Clastic Detritus Brian Romans Dot Physics Rhett Allain Frontal Cortex Jonah Lehrer Genetic Future Daniel MacArthur Laelaps Brian Switek Neuron Culture David Dobbs Superbug Maryn McKenna Read the latest Wired Science Blogs articles Follow us on Twitter Subscribe to Wired Magazine

Subscribe to WIRED

Renew

Give a gift

Customer Service

CNP.ecom.request({pid:'blogs_rightRail_A', tgt:'/atg/registry/RepositoryTargeters/WIR/WIR_blogs_rightRail_A'}); runMobileCompatibilityScript('myExperience', 'anId'); Editorial Team Editor: Betsy Mason | E-mail | Twitter Contributor: Brandon Keim | E-mail | Twitter Contributor: Dave Mosher | E-mail | Twitter Contributor: Lisa Grossman Contributor: Danielle Venton Community Manager: Arikia Millikan | E-mail | Twitter

Send us a tip

Search for: FB.init("d53bb4300a345fefeeccdfadf717335c"); Advertisement if(typeof CN!=='undefined' && CN.dart){ CN.dart.call("xrailBottom",{sz: "300x250", kws : ["spotc"]}); } Services Subscription: Subscribe | Give a Gift | Renew | International | Questions | Change Address CNP.ecom.request({pid:'blogs_rightRail_subServices', tgt:'/atg/registry/RepositoryTargeters/WIR/WIR_blogs_rightRail_subServices'}); Quick Links: Contact Us | Sign In/Register Sign Out | Newsletter | RSS Feeds | Tech Jobs | Wired Mobile | FAQ | Site Map whosamungus original WAU_classic('r5so28brwya8') whosamungus var wau_p = wau_p || []; wau_p.push(["g16s", "552180f7", false]); (function() { var s=document.createElement("script"); s.type="text/javascript"; s.async=true; s.src="http://widgets.amung.us/a_pro.js"; document.getElementsByTagName("head")[0].appendChild(s); })(); google anayltics var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); try { var pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-2527556-6"); pageTracker._trackPageview(); } catch(err) {} Twitter graphic scrubStatsBlogPermalinkPageName(); ord=Math.random()*10000000000000000; document.write(''); var textPref = getCookie("style"); var title = textPref ? textPref : getPreferredStyleSheet(); setActiveStyleSheet(title); Corrections | Sitemap | FAQ | Contact Us | Wired Staff | Advertising | Press Center | Subscription Services | Newsletter | RSS Feeds Condé Nast Web Sites: Webmonkey | Reddit | ArsTechnica | Details | Golf Digest | GQ | New Yorker Subscribe to a magazine: View All Titles Allure Architectural Digest Bon Appétit Brides Condé Nast Portfolio Condé Nast Traveler Details Elegant Bride Glamour Golf Digest Golf World GQ Lucky Modern Bride Self Teen Vogue The New Yorker Vanity Fair Vogue W Wired Condé Nast web sites: Allure Architectural Digest ArsTechnica Bon Appétit Brides.com Condé Nast Traveler Condé Nast Portfolio Concierge Details Elegant Bride Epicurious Glamour Golf Digest Golf World GQ Hotel Chatter Jaunted Lucky Modern Bride Nutrition Data Reddit Self Style.com Teen Vogue The New Yorker The Sartorialist Vanity Fair Vogue Webmonkey W

Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (Revised 4/1/2009) and Privacy Policy (Revised 4/1/2009).

The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast Digital.

_uacct = "UA-2624369-1"; _udn="wired.com"; urchinTracker(); var _sf_async_config={uid:15455,domain:"wired.com",sections:"Wired Science",authors:"Brandon Keim"}; (function(){ function loadChartbeat() { window._sf_endpt=(new Date()).getTime(); var e = document.createElement('script'); e.setAttribute('language', 'javascript'); e.setAttribute('type', 'text/javascript'); e.setAttribute('src', (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://s3.amazonaws.com/" : "http://") + "static.chartbeat.com/js/chartbeat.js"); document.body.appendChild(e); } var oldonload = window.onload; window.onload = (typeof window.onload != 'function') ? loadChartbeat : function() { oldonload(); loadChartbeat(); }; })();

Making this “co-movement” information widely available will change how the system behaves–observing alters the thing being observed.

Yes, the self-knowledge-feedback makes this fundamentally chaotic, in ways that (for example) the weather is not. Thunderstorms aren’t sentient, attempting to maximize their net/wet worth.

I see a silver Apple! RUN!!

Does anyone on Main Street America really care whaty happens on Wall Street? I know I sure dont.

http://www.anon-tools.es.tc

EFT’s!!!! DUH!!!!

An interesting, and consonant, follow-on to Didier Sornette’s work on the subject.

I agree with rob. And now Im going to buy my lottery ticket. http://www.euro-millions.net

Subscribe to WIRED

Renew

Give a gift

Customer Service

Send us a tip

Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (Revised 4/1/2009) and Privacy Policy (Revised 4/1/2009).

The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast Digital.

Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (Revised 4/1/2009) and Privacy Policy (Revised 4/1/2009).

The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast Digital.

Read Full Article »

Comment

Show comments

A Market Crash Early Warning System

Related Articles