Can Housing Handle Another Blow?

Charles Hugh Smith Daily Finance March 23, 2011

New regulations limiting mortgage brokers' compensation go into effect on April 1, and they might prove to be appropriate for an April Fools' Day. Though aimed at unscrupulous mortgage brokers, it seems the regulations will instead hit the nation's struggling housing market. The Federal Reserve Board says that its regulatory goal is to "protect mortgage borrowers from unfair, abusive, or deceptive lending practices that can arise from loan originator compensation practices." The basic idea is to prevent loan officers from steering borrowers into riskier types of loans or a higher-than-average interest rate to make a higher commission. Officially titled "Loan Originator Compensation amendment to Regulation Z," The new rules apply to mortgage brokers and the companies that employ them, as well as mortgage loan officers employed by banks and other lenders. Closing the Barn Door.... #mini_module_blank { width: 269px; height:200px; border: none; float:right; margin:10px; font-size:12px;} #mini_module_blank img {border:none; width: 265px; height:131px; border: none; margin:0px; } #mini_module_blank #mini_main { margin: 0px; padding:0px; width:269px; height:206px; background: transparent url(http://www.aolcdn.com/travel/zing-background-no-photo)} #mini_module_blank #mini_item_header {padding:8px 0px; margin: 0px 20px; font-size:14px;} #mini_module_blank #mini_item {padding:4px 0px; margin: 0px 20px; border-bottom:1px dotted #CCCCCC;} #mini_module_blank a { color: #49A3CA; text-decoration:none; } #mini_module_blank a:hover { color: #F98419; text-decoration:underline;} Search Millions of Home Listings View photos of homes for sale and apartments for rent on AOL Real Estate See homes for sale See rental listings Check out the latest real estate news Since most of us only deal with mortgage loan origination fees when we buy a home or refinance a mortgage, the average citizen will have a tough time sorting out the often-arcane issues at stake. But the bottom line is straightforward: the already-limited mortgage market is about to become more limited, as small mortgage brokers are essentially being shoved out of business. Call it "unintended consequences" or a cloaked plan to channel more of the mortgage business to the "too big to fail" big banks -- but regardless of the motivations, the rules may end up limiting consumer choice and make it harder for home buyers to get a loan. While the stated goal of the new rules is laudable, those in the mortgage industry say it's a case of closing the barn door after the horse has bolted: the risky, subprime-type mortgages that were the root cause of the problem have already vanished from the mortgage market. Since the rules largely apply to small lenders and brokers who must sell the mortgages they originate to larger banks -- most banks and other direct lenders, including big mortgage companies that function like banks, are exempt from the new regulations -- then the limits will weigh entirely on smaller independent players. Setting Ground Rules Critics, including U.S. Senators David Vitter and John Tester, observe these rules will further concentrate a market already dominated by mega-large banks. According to the senators, two banks already originate 43% of the nation's mortgages. It's difficult to see how home buyers will benefit from the effective exclusion of small independent brokers and lenders. What the regulations do is set some ground rules. For example, consumers must be offered the lowest possible interest rate and fees for which they qualify. They also limit loan officer and broker compensation in several key ways.

Sponsored Linksadsonar_placementId=1505951;adsonar_pid=1990767;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=242;adsonar_zh=252;adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com';

adsonar_placementId=1505951;adsonar_pid=1990767;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=242;adsonar_zh=252;adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com';According to the Federal Reserve Board, a loan originator "may not receive compensation that is based on the interest rate or other loan terms." In other words, a lender can no longer pay a loan broker a yield-spread premium, which is tied to the rate or terms of the mortgage. Currently, the brokerage firm and the loan officer typically split this rebate, which is typically stated in "points," where each point equals 1% of the loan amount. Thus a loan origination might earn an $8,000 fee, $4,000 of which goes to the loan officer and $4,000 to the mortgage broker. Under the new rules, the mortgage broker cannot pass on part of the commission to the loan officer, who must now be paid an hourly wage or salary. The idea is to remove the incentive of the loan officer to push the consumer into a more lucrative loan -- but the result is to remove the incentive to remain in the independent mortgage business. The Insider's View Mark Helling, a licensed loan officer based in Ohio, summed up the view from inside the industry. "After April 1st," he says, "a loan officer will have to be paid the same rate whether it is an easy loan that takes two weeks to close or a foreclosed property in need of rehabbing for marginal borrowers that takes three months of work to close. Just when the country needs the most experienced and knowledgeable mortgage professionals to help liquidate the flood of foreclosed homes, the Fed is making it unprofitable for loan officers to accept these deals." From the point of view of those in the mortgage industry trenches, what the rules do is increase the regulatory expenses of being in sales but eliminate the commissions that are the lifeblood of any sales enterprise. The Fed Board also says the final rule "prohibits a loan originator that receives compensation directly from the consumer from also receiving compensation from the lender or another party." In other words, a loan originator cannot collect payments from both the consumer and the lender in a single transaction. If a broker is paid a commission by the lender based on the loan amount, then the broker is barred from charge the borrower "points" or fees for the loan processing. This prohibits loan officers from paying borrowers' fees or issuing them a credit from their own commission. This has been a common practice within the industry -- and from the inside perspective, it has offered a flexible way to lower borrower's costs. A Case of Overkill? These major regulatory changes are being made in the service of fair lending practices. But to those seeing their livelihoods threatened, it looks like a sledgehammer is being used where a flyswatter would have sufficed. "As far as trying to protect consumers from those seeking to charge a higher interest rate, with all of the competition out there for mortgage loans," Helling observes, "all a consumer has to do is check one or two other banks and they can quickly find out if they are getting a fair deal or not." The rules will also interact in potentially harmful ways with the massive Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, the most sweeping financial regulation since the Great Depression. At issue is section 1413 of the Dodd-Frank Act, which states that any violation of the loan originator compensation rules will offer the borrower a "defense to foreclosure" for the life of the loan. In other words, if a delinquent borrower can go back and find some violation of the compensation rules in his/her mortgage origination, the lender is effectively barred from foreclosing on the borrower's loan. Drying Up Competition Given the risks this presents to banks, many observers -- including the two senators -- expect the large banks that typically buy mortgages from independent brokers and small lenders to shun these mortgages. Why buy a mortgage that could go sour via a future default -- that could preclude foreclosure as a remedy? The net result of these rules could hurt the housing market in several ways. If mortgage brokers can no longer make enough in commissions to stay in business, then the mortgage options for home buyers will shrink. The most productive loan officers will find reduced incentives to their remaining independent, so there will be less competition offered to the big banks which already dominate the industry. Perhaps most devastating, the financial institutions which have bought mortgages originated by brokers and smaller lenders will have a powerful incentive to avoid the risks that are being placed on these mortgages by the Dodd-Frank Act. The housing market may well sag further, as mortgage sources and competition dry up. The need for thoughtful financial regulation has been made painfully apparent by the excesses of the credit and housing bubbles, but squashing legitimate independent loan originators and further concentrating the mortgage industry into the hands of the "too big to fail" banks seems counterproductive.

adsonar_placementId=1491054; adsonar_pid=1990767; adsonar_ps=-1; adsonar_zw=627; adsonar_zh=110; adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com'; Tagged: commissions, Dodd-Frank Act, Federal Reserve Board, housing, loan officers, mortgage brokers, mortgages, real estate $(document).ready(function() { try{ if(document.getElementById("articleCmntHdr")){ var cmstr=$("#articleCmntHdr").html(); var comnum=cmstr.match(/\d+/); //$("#cmtCount").html('Comments: '+comnum+''); $("#cmtCount").html('Comments: '); } }catch(e){} }); checkTextPref(); //below code configures url for facebook like feature document.onload(setLink(window.location)); // document.onload(); function setLink(link){ try{ document.getElementById('fbLike').href= link }catch(err){//module is not configured on the page } } //above code configures url for facebook like feature Print Email This .topText { display:block; } (function(d){ var w = d.getElementById("aol-related-videos").offsetWidth; d.write(''); })(document); Robyn Beck, AFP/Getty Images EXPENDABLE ME: Could a Robot Do Your Job? - MSNBC ADDING UP: Cost Cuts That Can Save You $50,000 - CNN Money WHAT'S IN A NAME? Do Star Endorsements Pay Off? - SmartMoney TAX QUIZ: Can You Deduct Your Breast Implants? - CNN Money SIN STOCKS: Your Portfolio's Dirty Secrets - InvestorPlace EASY MONEY: The Dow's Top Dividend-Paying Stocks - InvestorPlace READ THE FINE PRINT: What Homeowner's Insurance Doesn't Cover - FOX Business ROOKIE MISTAKES: College Money Moves to Avoid - CBS MoneyWatch Related Posts

From DailyFinanceWhy Is the Fed Letting Banks Boost Dividends?

2 days ago

Why the Foreclosure Mess Settlement Proposal Can’t Fix the Damage

4 days ago

Bank of America Document Leaks Allege Insurance Scams

9 days ago

From Our NetworkWarren Buffett, Suze Orman Disagree on Whether to Own

6 days ago

Higher Down Payment Requirements May Be Discriminatory

7 days ago

New Down Payment Rules May Be Discriminatory

7 days ago

See More Related Articles and Blog Posts

Add Your Comment

Recent QuotesWatchlistMy Portfolios My PortfoliosCreate a New Portfolio var watchlist; var AOL_QuotesWatchList; var elemStks; var addText = "Enter symbol(s) seperated by commas"; var goodSymbol = 1; var userAdding = 0; var watchlistMAX = 100; var maxReached = 0;var elemNum = -1; var previousElemNum = -1; var portURL = 'http://portal.pf.aol.com/jsonmfus/ws?service=symslist,markets&exchange=USA&symbols='; var recentqURL = 'http://portal.pf.aol.com/jsonmfus/ws?service=symslist&exchange=USA&symbols='; var newsMAX = 5; var strRecentQuotes = ""; rqSyms = buildString(""); if(rqSyms.length > 0)allSyms += rqSyms + ','; var defSymErr = "";var symbolErr="One or more symbols you entered is not available. ";errFlag=0;portfoliosCount = 5;document.getElementById("mnc_recentquotes").style.display = "none"; if(getCookieBase64("AOL_QuotesWatchList"))AOL_QuotesWatchList = sortString(getCookieBase64("AOL_QuotesWatchList")); else AOL_QuotesWatchList = ""; var initWatchlist=0; var wlSyms=buildString(AOL_QuotesWatchList); if(wlSyms.length > 0)allSyms += wlSyms + ',';document.getElementById("mnc_watchlist").style.display = "none";if(AOL_QuotesWatchList.length>0 && 1 != 1)initWatchlist=1; var portSyms =''; function SubmitLTModule() { var cbo = document.getElementById("LT_LOAN_TYPE"); var index = cbo.selectedIndex; var link; switch (cbo.options[index].value) { case "1" : { link = "http://www.lendingtree.com/alliance/from.asp?whereto=mort"; //link += "&EST_VALUE=" + document.getElementById("LT_EST_VALUE").value; //link += "&FIRST_MORT_BALANCE=" + document.getElementById("LT_CURRENT_MORTGAGE_BALANCE").value; link += "&PROP_STATE_CONST=" + document.getElementById("PROP_STATE_CONST").value; break; } case "2" : { link = "http://www.lendingtree.com/alliance/from.asp?whereto=refi"; //link += "&EST_VALUE=" + document.getElementById("LT_EST_VALUE").value; //link += "&FIRST_MORT_BALANCE=" + document.getElementById("LT_CURRENT_MORTGAGE_BALANCE").value; link += "&PROP_STATE_CONST=" + document.getElementById("PROP_STATE_CONST").value; break; } case "3" : { link = "http://www.lendingtree.com/alliance/from.asp?whereto=homeeq"; //link += "&EST_VALUE=" + document.getElementById("LT_EST_VALUE").value; //link += "&FIRST_MORT_BALANCE=" + document.getElementById("LT_CURRENT_MORTGAGE_BALANCE").value; link += "&PROP_STATE_CONST=" + document.getElementById("PROP_STATE_CONST").value; break; } } window.open( "http://pr.atwola.com/promoclk/100002732x1215196033x1200999976/aol?redir=" + escape(link + "&ESOURCEID=648550&BP=")); } Featured Sponsor Consolidate Your DebtLower Your Payments! Loan Type: Refinance Mortgage Purchase Mortgage Home Equity Loan/Line Property State Select State Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming DailyFinance Wire New Mortgage Regulations Could Hurt Housing How to Pay Down the Federal Deficit: Sell America's Icons, Assets and Gold? Japanese Shares Jittery as More Earthquakes Rumble Inside Wall Street: Turbo-Charged Investment Managing LinkedIn Membership Reaches 100 Million Worldwide Is the Rally Over, or Is It Just Taking a Breather? Where Does the AT&T and T-Mobile Deal Leave Sprint Nextel? More DailyFinance Stories Newswire AP BloggingStocks CNN 24/7WallSt. Stocks mixed after BofA's dividend request denied Bernanke says bank overhaul will help small banks Europe debt market tensions worsen ahead of summit Portugal braces for govt collapse over debt vote Watchdog: FAA improves for-hire aircraft oversight Goldman Sachs CEO testifies at NYC hedge trial New-home sales plunged in February to record low Fed rejects Bank of America's dividend hike plan Latest Financial News Loading... Loading... Loading... .followHead {background-color:#F0F4F5; border-top:3px solid #000000; color:#707678; font-size:18px;padding:4px 0 4px 10px; zoom:1;} .follow .spot {padding-left:31px;} Follow Us Facebook Twitter RSS To Go adsonar_placementId=1491063;adsonar_pid=1990767;adsonar_ps=-1;adsonar_zw=314;adsonar_zh=300;adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com'; Headlines From DailyFinance Partners SHOULD VERIZON BUY SPRINT? Stocks: Investors play waiting game Homebuilders may never fully recover - The Buzz More CNNMoney.com Snack sales boost General Mills profits MBIA loss estimates $10bn short, say banks Goldman chief called to testify in Galleon case More Financial Times Stocks Turn Mixed; Materials Up, Banks Slip Big Hopes For Big Lots? Schork Oil Outlook: NatGas Bears Running Out of... More from CNBC.com How to Figure Out What You'll Need to Retire Divorce Over 50: 3 Mistakes to Avoid Stocks for the Jobs Comeback More at SmartMoney Does Charlie Sheen Have a Case Against... Should Children Fight Back Against... Ret. General: We Need to Destroy... More Fox Business Pica-Pic brings retro handheld games back to... Linux Foundation announces MeeGo Smart TV... BMW launches DriveNow, the 'premium' car sharing... More from Engadget Goldman Sachs CEO Lloyd Blankfein:... Sprint Plans To Take Concerns Over AT&a... How Pepsi Fell Behind Coke More from Huffington Post Chase Takes the Ax to Debit Rewards... New Passport Application Asks for... Five Legitimate Reasons Celebrities... More WalletPop Don't Ever Give Up Going Green, Companies Eliminate 4... SCORE Launches e-Business Now to Help... More from AOL Small Business BMW to Show 6 Series Coupe in Shanghai Glenlivet Decades from Gordon &... Omega Seamaster Aqua Terra 44 Chronograph Watch... More at Luxist.com Freddie Mac Goes Viral With... Tiger Woods' Ex Buys Palm Beach Estate... Rental Market Still Belongs to Renters More from AOL Real Estate Bruce Pearl Fired After NCAA... US Teacher Killed in Japan Earthquake... Film Icon Elizabeth Taylor Dies at 79... More from AOL News DailyFinance An AOL Money & Finance Site var fdt = document.getElementById('ftr_date'); fdt.innerHTML = dayArray[day] + ', ' + monthArray[month] + ' ' + date + ', ' + year; Send Feedback Business NewsWhat's HotInvesting and Real EstatePersonal Finance at WalletPopOur Partners Main Stock Market News Investing Portfolios BloggingStocks About Us Economy DailyFinance RSS Feeds Press Releases Small Business Start a Business Business Marketing Business Financing Oil Prices Cell Phone Brain Retirement Age J.C. Penney Logo Bank of America Fee Xoom vs. Apple iPad Millionaire Dropouts Best States for Small Business Electric Car Tax Credit Making Work Pay Credit Earnings Media Tech News Hotel Deals Celebrity Real Estate Condo Auctions Stocks to Buy Stocks to Sell Real Estate Apartments Housing Trends Debt Fraud Insurance Loans 2010 Income Taxes Taxes Tax Advice Tax Basics Tax Forms Tax Credit Online Tax Filing College Finance Recalls Retirement Personal Finance 24/7 Wall St. Secret Millionaires Club Luxury News ParentDish Tech News Download Squad TUAW Sports Autoblog Politics News Latino News Radio

Surphace.copyRightSiteTitle = 'DailyFinance'; // Bottom script default - DailyFinance header //call anchor cookie to see if page shloud ancor on comments checkForAnchorCookie(); var newdiv = document.createElement('div'); var divIdName = 'gcpAuthLeft'; newdiv.setAttribute('id',divIdName); newdiv.style.display = "none"; newdiv.innerHTML = ''; document.body.appendChild(newdiv); // Bottom script default - DailyFinance header var sitedomain = 'www.dailyfinance.com'; if( user_screen_name ==undefined){var user_screen_name='';} var isAolClient=0; if(navigator.userAgent.indexOf("AOL")!=-1){isAolClient=1;} $(document).ready(function() { $('#GH_').globalHeader({ activeTab : -1, moreLinks : [['BloggingStocks','http://www.bloggingstocks.com/'], ['WalletPop','http://www.walletpop.com/'], ['Small Business','http://smallbusiness.aol.com/'], ['Luxist','http://www.luxist.com/'], ['Real Estate','http://realestate.aol.com/'], ['Politics Daily','http://www.politicsdaily.com/'], ['Jobs','http://jobs.aol.com/'], ['AOL News','http://www.aolnews.com/'], ['Sports','http://aol.sportingnews.com/'], ['MMA','http://www.mmafighting.com/'], ['Fleaflicker','http://www.fleaflicker.com/'], ['Engadget','http://www.engadget.com']] }); }); function gh_fin(x){ user_screen_name=x; var url="siteState=" + encodeURIComponent("OrigUrl="+encodeURIComponent(window.location)); var signedoutstr='Sign Out'; if(isAolClient==1){signedoutstr='';} $('#GH_').globalHeader({ auth : { doAuth : true, authenticated: (user_screen_name!='' ) ? true : false, authState : 'Hi, '+user_screen_name+''+signedoutstr+'', unauthState : 'Sign In / Register' } }); if(user_screen_name.length adsonar_placementId=1491054; adsonar_pid=1990767; adsonar_ps=-1; adsonar_zw=627; adsonar_zh=110; adsonar_jv='ads.tw.adsonar.com'; Tagged: commissions, Dodd-Frank Act, Federal Reserve Board, housing, loan officers, mortgage brokers, mortgages, real estate $(document).ready(function() { try{ if(document.getElementById("articleCmntHdr")){ var cmstr=$("#articleCmntHdr").html(); var comnum=cmstr.match(/\d+/); //$("#cmtCount").html('Comments: '+comnum+''); $("#cmtCount").html('Comments: '); } }catch(e){} }); checkTextPref(); //below code configures url for facebook like feature document.onload(setLink(window.location)); // document.onload(); function setLink(link){ try{ document.getElementById('fbLike').href= link }catch(err){//module is not configured on the page } } //above code configures url for facebook like feature Print Email This .topText { display:block; } (function(d){ var w = d.getElementById("aol-related-videos").offsetWidth; d.write(''); })(document); Robyn Beck, AFP/Getty Images EXPENDABLE ME: Could a Robot Do Your Job? - MSNBC ADDING UP: Cost Cuts That Can Save You $50,000 - CNN Money WHAT'S IN A NAME? Do Star Endorsements Pay Off? - SmartMoney TAX QUIZ: Can You Deduct Your Breast Implants? - CNN Money SIN STOCKS: Your Portfolio's Dirty Secrets - InvestorPlace EASY MONEY: The Dow's Top Dividend-Paying Stocks - InvestorPlace READ THE FINE PRINT: What Homeowner's Insurance Doesn't Cover - FOX Business ROOKIE MISTAKES: College Money Moves to Avoid - CBS MoneyWatch Related Posts

From DailyFinanceWhy Is the Fed Letting Banks Boost Dividends?

2 days ago

Why the Foreclosure Mess Settlement Proposal Can’t Fix the Damage

4 days ago

Bank of America Document Leaks Allege Insurance Scams

9 days ago

From Our NetworkWarren Buffett, Suze Orman Disagree on Whether to Own

6 days ago

Higher Down Payment Requirements May Be Discriminatory

7 days ago

New Down Payment Rules May Be Discriminatory

7 days ago

See More Related Articles and Blog Posts

Add Your Comment

Comment

Show comments