Related articles, background features and opinions about this topic.
An Analysis by Sven Böll and Maria Marquart
True Finns party boss Timo Soini: Sunday's election in Finland wasn't a great day for Europe.
Across the 17-member euro zone, government heads had a hunch April 17 might not be a very good day for the future of Europe. The strong ballot box performance of the euroskeptic True Finns means it is very likely the party will be part of the next government. It appears that a country long seen as an EU anchor may soon become a source of irritation for Brussels and in capitals across the bloc.
During the election campaign, True Finn party head Timo Soini lashed out repeatedly against the European Union and bailout plans for debt-ridden euro-zone members. Bolstered by an election that saw the party more than quadruple its standing, with 19 percent of the vote, an emboldened Soini remained vocal on Monday, saying it was unacceptable that Finland "must pay for the mistakes of others." And that "the content of politics must change. We have been too soft on Europe."
Does the party represent a threat to the common European project? Do Finland's right-wing populists truly have the power to bring the euro to its knees? Or does it merely have the capacity to create a threat to the euro's stability and thus protract the current currency crisis?
If the party becomes part of Finland's next government, that answer could come within a matter of weeks. A coalition between the conservatives, who drew the most votes, the opposition Social Democrats and the True Finns is one viable option currently being discussed.
Will Remainder of Euro Zone Be Left to Foot the Bill?
Under current euro-zone rules, all 17 members must approve bailout packages for countries in need -- and next month, an €80 billion package for Portugal is up for approval. During the campaign, Finland's major parties said they wouldn't form a governing coalition with the True Finns if doing so would create a threat to the future of Europe's common currency. As such, it seems likely that, should the True Finns join the government, the party's euro-critical positions will be watered down. It remains possible, however, that a future Helsinki coalition could refrain from vetoing a bailout package for Portugal, but would then refuse to provide funding.
Were Finland to back out of any future rescue packages, it would have a significant impact on the common currency. The timing is bad, too, given that Europeans are currently faced with three euro-related problems that need to be solved at the same time:
The temporary euro rescue fund (EFSF), valid until 2013, needs to be expanded. The permanent crisis mechanism (ESM), intended to replace EFSF starting in 2013, needs to be formally agreed to. Financial aid to Portugal needs to be released.
Within the framework of the temporary rescue fund, all 17 euro-zone member states are providing credit guarantees valued at a total of €400 billion ($579 billion). In order to preserve the highest possible credit rating for the fund, however, a maximum of €250 billion from the fund can be lent to troubled euro-zone countries. Euro-zone leaders are now discussing nearly doubling the sum of money that is actually lendable as quickly as possible so that €440 billion can be disbursed in emergencies. That will be crucial if, following Ireland and Portugal, larger EU countries like Spain require bailouts in the future.
Looking ahead to elections in Finland, EU leaders in March delayed a final decision on the expansion of the existing bailout fund until June, well after Finns would go to the polls.
Finnish Pullout Would Be 'Politically Uncomfortable'
It is now possible that if the right-wing populists with the Real Finns party join the government, that a deal will be blocked by Finland or that the Finns place additional hurdles before passage. Helsinki is currently responsible for providing credits valuing €7.9 billion, representing a share of about 1.8 percent of the EFSF. Under the current deal, Finland would also have to increase its credit guarantees in proportion to its shares in the EFSF. By comparison, Germany is covering around 28 percent of the total sum. At €119.4 billion, that figure is almost 15 times greater than Finland's.
If the Finns decide not to take part in the expansion of EFSF, then other countries would have to plug the gap. Daniel Gros of the Brussels-based Center for European Policy Studies, however, says this wouldn't be a major problem. Still, he says "it would then be politically uncomfortable" because if one country decided to stop supporting the rescue program, others might soon follow suit.
Nevertheless, throughout its history, individual countries have demanded exceptions on a number of issues and the European Union has still managed to get by. Slovakia and the other new EU member states, for example, have been given a sort of discount on the amount they are required to put up for the permanent ESM rescue fund. The countries had complained because they felt they were being overly burdened by the bailout.
A Finnish 'No' Could Get Expensive for Germany
But the effect of a Finnish withdrawal would be greater on Germany than it would be on most other euro-zone member states. Germany and Finland, together with France, the Netherlands and Austria, are the only countries in the euro zone that possess the best possible rating, Triple A, from the ratings agencies. If one of these countries with the best credit ratings ceases to participate, the additional burden would likely fall on the other countries with Triple A ratings and not on countries with lesser ratings such as Estonia or Malta.
It could also create problems for the permanent European Stability Mechanism (ESM), which is expected to replace the temporary rescue package in 2013. ESM is intended to be able to loan a maximum of €500 billion. In order to be able to loan that much, the euro-zone states would have to put €700 billion into the fund. And in order to obtain the highest rating from ratings agencies, ESM would have to include credit guarantees totalling €620 billion. As security collateral, it would also have to include €80 billion in cash.
That would mean the first infusion of actual cash from taxpayers into a rescue fund since the start of the euro crisis. All of the bailout measures undertaken so far have been covered with credit guarantees, with the exposure to taxpayers existing only on paper -- at least until a country fails to repay its loans. But whereas Germany will have a share of 27.1 percent of the ESM, meaning €168 billion and €22 billion in cash reserves, Finland's share is also relatively small. The government would have to provide €11.1 billion in guarantees and €1.4 billion in cash. If the True Finns party becomes part of the coalition, it is conceivable that the Finnish government would either not participate in EFSF or ESM or that it will want to reduce its participation.
Threats from Finnland Create Uncertainty on Markets
Close attention is being paid by the financial markets to the political tug o' war. "So far, there has already been a tendency towards palpable skepticism about further aid in the donor nations," analysts at Germany's Commerzbank have written. With the election victory of the euro critics, the bank's analysts write, the risk has increased "that a donor country will pull out of the rescue mechanism." They add: "A pullout by the Finns would mean more than a termination of solidarity because the agreement of all 17 euro-zone members is required to approve aid."
The analysts are referring to an important means of pressure the Finns have at their disposal. In order for the ESM to go into effect, the Treaty of Lisbon, which governs the workings of the EU, must be modified. The change would not require countries to cede sovereignty on any additional issues to the EU, but it would nevertheless require ratification by the national parliaments of member states, including the Eduskunta in Helsinki.
So the future Finnish government actually does have the ability to block the increased funding of the EFSF and the creation of the ESM. But that remains speculative at this stage. Ognian Hishow, an expert on EU integration at the German Institute for International and Security Affairs (SWP), doesn't believe that Finland would withdraw from the currency union or the EU. "Finnish companies wouldn't tolerate that," he said, adding that the financial risks would be too great. "Finland has so far done well with the euro," Hishow said. "Reason will prevail in the end."
'Overall Political Picture in Europe Has Worsened'
Nonetheless, the Finns could stir up trouble in terms of disbursing financial aid for Portugal. A unanimous decision is required by all euro-zone finance ministers in order to disburse loans under the current EFSF agreement. This is expected to take place in May. In the worst-case scenario, this would provide the Finnish finance minister with an opportunity to strike. He could demand that Finland would only agree to the bailout if Helsinki didn't have to participate financially.
Given the relatively small, single-digit billion volume of Finland's share of the bailout, this quasi veto power probably wouldn't threaten Portugal's bailout. But economist Gros at Center for European Policy Studies argues that the political symbolism of a pullout would be important, especially if other countries followed suit -- particularly countries that have been leaders in a united Europe until now. Gros says it could create huge problems if sentiment like that crossed over into Germany.
"The overall political picture in Europe has worsened," Gros said.
Article... Print E-Mail Feedback For reasons of data protection and privacy, your IP address will only be stored if you are a registered user of Facebook and you are currently logged in to the service. For more detailed information, please click on the "i" symbol.Post to other social networks:
Forum Discuss this issue with other readers! 1 total post Visit Forums... Most recent posts on the issue: 04/20/2011 from BTraven:There is a interview with a charming Finnish woman on DreiSat – unfortunately only in German. Quite interesting. At least we know that the name of the party which has caused so much fuss has not been expressed correctly – it's [...] more...
What do you think? Discuss this issue with others. Visit Forums... Keep track of the newsStay informed with our free news services:
All news from SPIEGEL International Twitter | RSS All news from Europe section RSS© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2011 All Rights Reserved Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH
ReprintsFind out how you can reprint this SPIEGEL ONLINE article.
Related Topics Euro Crisis European Union DER SPIEGELGraphic: Europe's Right Turn
SPIEGEL ONLINEGraphic: Defenses Against Default
DER SPIEGELGraphic: A Common Currency
DER SPIEGELGraphic: Scope of the EU rescue packages
DER SPIEGELGraphic: Yields on selected euro-zone debt
Related SPIEGEL ONLINE links Election Success for the True Finns: Finland's Right Turn Spells Trouble for Europe (04/18/2011) Back to the Roots: Why Elections in Finland Could Doom Portugal's Bailout (04/15/2011) The Never-Ending Crisis: Greek Debt Restructuring Looks Inevitable (04/11/2011) 'A Grave Moment for Our Country': Portugal Forced to Request EU Bailout (04/07/2011) European Partners PresseuropNo work, no home (De Volkskrant, Amsterdam)
Outraged, but still sat at home (El País, Madrid)
PolitikenDSB lets another director go
Nokia to lay off 950 in Denmark
Corriere della SeraBerlusconi – Referendum would have Blocked Atomic Energy
Italy Agrees to Targeted Attacks on Libya
Global Partners New York TimesPanetta and Petraeus in Line for Top Security Posts
The Caucus: Obama Releases His Long Form Birth Certificate
ABC NewsBREAKING: First Images of Gabrielle Giffords Since Shooting
'I've Got Better Stuff to Do'
Newsletter Sign up for Spiegel Online's daily newsletter and get the best of Der Spiegel's and Spiegel Online's international coverage in your In-Box everyday. Facebook FB.init("8e0192d8770be48129dc946121d0092e"); new TWTR.Widget({ version: 2, type: 'search', search: '@SPIEGEL_English', interval: 6000, title: 'Live Postings @SPIEGEL_English', subject: 'SPIEGEL on Twitter', width: 302, height: 250, theme: { shell: { background: '#ffffff', color: '#666' }, tweets: { background: '#ffffff', color: '#444444', links: '#990000' } }, features: { scrollbar: false, loop: false, live: true, hashtags: true, timestamp: true, avatars: true, behavior: 'all' } }).render().start();Follow SPIEGEL_English on Twitter now:
MORE FROM SPIEGEL INTERNATIONAL German Politics Merkel's New Govermnent: Forging Germany's Future World War II Truth and Reconciliation: Why the War Still Haunts Europe Economy Green Shoots: Europe Climbs Out of Crisis Climate Change Global Warming: Curbing Carbon before It's Too Late Fall of the Wall 20 Years Later: Legacy of the Iron Curtain Overview International TOP Home Politik Wirtschaft Panorama Sport Kultur Netzwelt Wissenschaft UniSPIEGEL SchulSPIEGEL Reise Auto Wetter DIENSTE Schlagzeilen RSS Newsletter Mobil VIDEO Nachrichten Videos SPIEGEL TV Magazin SPIEGEL TV Programm SPIEGEL Geschichte MEDIA SPIEGEL QC ReprintsFind out how you can reprint this SPIEGEL ONLINE article.
Related Topics Euro Crisis European Union DER SPIEGELGraphic: Europe's Right Turn
SPIEGEL ONLINEGraphic: Defenses Against Default
DER SPIEGELGraphic: A Common Currency
DER SPIEGELGraphic: Scope of the EU rescue packages
DER SPIEGELGraphic: Yields on selected euro-zone debt
Related SPIEGEL ONLINE links Election Success for the True Finns: Finland's Right Turn Spells Trouble for Europe (04/18/2011) Back to the Roots: Why Elections in Finland Could Doom Portugal's Bailout (04/15/2011) The Never-Ending Crisis: Greek Debt Restructuring Looks Inevitable (04/11/2011) 'A Grave Moment for Our Country': Portugal Forced to Request EU Bailout (04/07/2011) European Partners PresseuropNo work, no home (De Volkskrant, Amsterdam)
Outraged, but still sat at home (El País, Madrid)
PolitikenDSB lets another director go
Nokia to lay off 950 in Denmark
Corriere della SeraBerlusconi – Referendum would have Blocked Atomic Energy
Italy Agrees to Targeted Attacks on Libya
Global Partners New York TimesPanetta and Petraeus in Line for Top Security Posts
The Caucus: Obama Releases His Long Form Birth Certificate
ABC NewsBREAKING: First Images of Gabrielle Giffords Since Shooting
'I've Got Better Stuff to Do'
Newsletter Sign up for Spiegel Online's daily newsletter and get the best of Der Spiegel's and Spiegel Online's international coverage in your In-Box everyday. Facebook FB.init("8e0192d8770be48129dc946121d0092e"); new TWTR.Widget({ version: 2, type: 'search', search: '@SPIEGEL_English', interval: 6000, title: 'Live Postings @SPIEGEL_English', subject: 'SPIEGEL on Twitter', width: 302, height: 250, theme: { shell: { background: '#ffffff', color: '#666' }, tweets: { background: '#ffffff', color: '#444444', links: '#990000' } }, features: { scrollbar: false, loop: false, live: true, hashtags: true, timestamp: true, avatars: true, behavior: 'all' } }).render().start();Follow SPIEGEL_English on Twitter now:
MORE FROM SPIEGEL INTERNATIONAL German Politics Merkel's New Govermnent: Forging Germany's Future World War II Truth and Reconciliation: Why the War Still Haunts Europe Economy Green Shoots: Europe Climbs Out of Crisis Climate Change Global Warming: Curbing Carbon before It's Too Late Fall of the Wall 20 Years Later: Legacy of the Iron Curtain Overview International TOP Home Politik Wirtschaft Panorama Sport Kultur Netzwelt Wissenschaft UniSPIEGEL SchulSPIEGEL Reise Auto Wetter DIENSTE Schlagzeilen RSS Newsletter Mobil VIDEO Nachrichten Videos SPIEGEL TV Magazin SPIEGEL TV Programm SPIEGEL Geschichte MEDIA SPIEGEL QC Mediadaten Selbstbuchungstool weitere Zeitschriften MAGAZINE DER SPIEGEL Dein SPIEGEL SPIEGEL GESCHICHTE SPIEGEL WISSEN KulturSPIEGEL UniSPIEGEL SPIEGEL GRUPPE Abo Shop SPIEGEL TV manager magazin Harvard Business Man. buchreport buch aktuell SPIEGEL-Gruppe WEITERE Hilfe Kontakt Nachdrucke Datenschutz Impressum TOPGiven the relatively small, single-digit billion volume of Finland's share of the bailout, this quasi veto power probably wouldn't threaten Portugal's bailout. But economist Gros at Center for European Policy Studies argues that the political symbolism of a pullout would be important, especially if other countries followed suit -- particularly countries that have been leaders in a united Europe until now. Gros says it could create huge problems if sentiment like that crossed over into Germany.
"The overall political picture in Europe has worsened," Gros said.
Post to other social networks:
There is a interview with a charming Finnish woman on DreiSat – unfortunately only in German. Quite interesting. At least we know that the name of the party which has caused so much fuss has not been expressed correctly – it's [...] more...
Stay informed with our free news services:
© SPIEGEL ONLINE 2011 All Rights Reserved Reproduction only allowed with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH
Find out how you can reprint this SPIEGEL ONLINE article.
Graphic: Europe's Right Turn
Graphic: Defenses Against Default
Graphic: A Common Currency
Graphic: Scope of the EU rescue packages
Graphic: Yields on selected euro-zone debt
No work, no home (De Volkskrant, Amsterdam)
Outraged, but still sat at home (El País, Madrid)
DSB lets another director go
Nokia to lay off 950 in Denmark
Berlusconi – Referendum would have Blocked Atomic Energy
Italy Agrees to Targeted Attacks on Libya
Panetta and Petraeus in Line for Top Security Posts
The Caucus: Obama Releases His Long Form Birth Certificate
BREAKING: First Images of Gabrielle Giffords Since Shooting
'I've Got Better Stuff to Do'
Follow SPIEGEL_English on Twitter now:
Read Full Article »