Imagined Internal Dialogues by Market Players

Dow Jones Reprints: This copy is for your personal, non-commerical use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers, use the Order Reprints tool on any article or visit www.djreprints.com

The wild market action of the past couple of weeks has plenty of folks talking to themselves. Here are a few imagined internal dialogues by different market participants, composites of dozens of conversations with professional investors and commentaries by investment strategists last week.

President Obama: "Now I know how Bill Clinton felt in the early '90s when he said, 'You mean to tell me that the success of my program and my re-election hinges on the Federal Reserve and a bunch of *%&@# bond traders?' Except today, it's the Fed and bond raters, rather than traders."

But, of course, the downgrade of the government debt by Standard & Poor's was not, in itself, the trigger for last week's upheaval or the main reason that traders were muttering to themselves. "Lookit," they're saying. "In each of the six trading sessions through Thursday, the S&P 500 had an intraday range between 5% and 6%. At last week's lows, we were down 18% in less than three weeks. This was either a slow-motion crash or an incredibly rapid correction. Nothing like this ever truly makes sense. Walt Disney (ticker: DIS) wasn't suddenly 9% less great a company at 4 p.m. Wednesday versus 4 p.m. Tuesday.

"Yet it felt unnervingly like 2008, even if the broader conditions don't neatly match up. The layering of too many unanalyzable issues, from European central bankers' fortitude to American politicians' cravenness spurred risk-reduction across the Street. For a time there, it was like we restarted the game of 'Who's trapped, and where.'

"The contrarian instinct is now flaring buy impulses. Assets in Treasury exchange-traded funds have surged relative to stock ETFs. Retail investors yanked $11 billion from traditional stock mutual funds last week. It has rarely paid to get aggressively negative on stocks with the S&P 500 Volatility Index above 40, where it spent at least part of the day Monday through Thursday, though when it has paid to sell a market with the VIX above 40, it has been in times of credit stress or systemic crisis. The high-yield market has weakened a lot, though much of that is about Treasury yields falling faster than junk yields.

"Plenty of folks who have gotten things mostly right in this cycle are tactically nervous. The Leuthold Group has said the cyclical bull market might have seen its peak. The Ned Davis Research 'cycle composite,' blending historical one-, four- and 10-year patterns, has turned negative. Michael Darda of MKM Partners, an economic optimist until earlier this year, fears that sluggish European monetary policy making is dooming the Continent to recession and contagion. Bridgewater Associates, the huge hedge-fund firm, stated in a starkly concise commentary Thursday that 'there is an uncomfortably high probability that there will be an unmanaged banking and sovereign-debt crisis in Europe.' "

The long-term strategic investor tries to talk herself off the ledge thus:

"The ferocious intraday rebound on Tuesday came just as the dividend yield on the S&P 500 ticked above that of 10-year Treasuries, as it did in the depths of the last bear market. The Fed is promising no higher rates for two years, meaning dividend stocks should retain a bid, and dividend payout ratios have lots of room to rise. It's far from clear the U.S. economy is teetering on recession; last week's jobless claims and retail sales numbers were OK. Stock valuations aren't to a level that would inure them to steep corporate profit declines, but barring that, they look pretty attractive."

FINALLY, THIS COLUMN'S ANONYMOUSLY famous mystery broker, who has had no trouble forecasting recessions and bear markets over the past 20 years, offered this on Wednesday: "I am absolutely stunned by the decline over the last week. Some of my unsophisticated clients actually sold near the top of the market last month because they thought the U.S. government would default on its debt. This is the first time they have made the right call, but I can guarantee they will wait and get back in at higher prices.…My opinion is that the stock-market collapse is much more similar to 1998 and 2010 than 2008. It is based on pure unadulterated fear."

He figures the indexes will possibly need to revisit the recent lows but sees them appreciably higher by year end. If only it were as easy for all of us to talk ourselves into his level of clarity and conviction. 

E-mail: michael.santoli@barrons.com

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com

Twitter

Yahoo! Buzz

facebook

MySpace

Digg

LinkedIn

del.icio.us

NewsVine

StumbleUpon

Mixx

Wealth-management firm Hilliard Lyons says the stock can hit $475, thanks to strong sales of smartphones and tablets.

Distributors are seen with the least exposure to reimbursement.

The bakery-cafe operator is seen as a defensive pick in restaurants.

While July was a good month for many retailers, Nordstrom in particular should ring up gains for investors.

Lower commodity prices would hurt EOG, Whiting and Pioneer Natural.

The chip maker will see lowered earnings per share in 2012 and 2013.

Cisco's first-quarter purchase commitments were kept roughly flat.

The integrated-silicon firm is set for a trimmer 2012-2013 EPS.

Shares of specialty HMOs Amerigroup and WellCare can rise as Medicaid rolls increase.

After dropping more than 15% since last month, the energy giant's stock looks too cheap to ignore.

Companies that want to grow their sales in this economy had better be able to steal customers from rivals. (At SmartMoney.com.)

They've taken a beating lately, but quality stocks, helped by historically low interest rates, are appealing.

What became of summer doldrums? This season, there are multiple reasons they didn't arrive: the market's wild gyrations, the S&P downgrade of U.S. debt, worries about Europe and, of course, the outlook for our economy and growth.

BlackRock CEO Larry Fink talks about the markets, the failure of government and why he prefers dividend stocks to Treasuries.

TIAA-CREF Mid-Cap Value Fund's Tom Kolefas sees some possible benefits for discounters and supermarkets in the recent stock volatility.

Last week's auction of 30-year U.S. Treasuries fell flat.

Keith Trauner and Larry Pitkowsky, founders of the GoodHaven Fund, are finding stocks to buy as the market gyrates. Big on tech, including HP and Microsoft.

Investors are starting to warm to the beaten-down networking giant. Here's what the company must do to retain its edge.

Shares of CBOE Holdings will benefit from market volatility. Also: a simple options strategy that will make money now.

Working with two Yale researchers, a new Barron's study suggests a coming upgrade in circuit breakers requires some more study by the SEC and Wall Street.

Barron's Roundtable members are buying up stocks after a wild week of trading. But the markets will fall further, they say, unless policy makers in the U.S. and Europe take decisive action to curb sovereign debt.

The Blue Chip consensus trims expectations for GDP gains, but still doubts a recession looms.

With the Fed holding short-term rates near zero, investors need to extend their search for income. Here's where to find it.

The iPad maker momentarily nudged ExxonMobil aside in last week's market turmoil to become the largest stock in the world before ceding the crown again to the oil giant.

Shares of the giant bank are down 46% this year, thanks to the housing mess and worries about a global slowdown. At their current level, that's all priced in and more.

Read Full Article »




Related Articles

Market Overview
Search Stock Quotes