Obama Seeks Another Wealth Transfer

Michael Tanner National Review September 21, 2011

Get FREE NRO Newsletters

October 3 Issue

Subscribe to NR

Renew

October 3 Issue | Subscribe | Renew

Page Tools

TEXT RESIZE

RSS Feed

Print Version

NRO Links

Set Sail with NR

Join Mark Steyn, Fred Thompson, John Bolton, VDH, Jonah, Jay, Rich, Ramesh, Mona, S.E., KLO, Andy, and dozens of more conservative all stars on the National Review 2011 Caribbean Cruise, November 12-19.

Subscribe to NR

Subscribe to National Review magazine today and save 70 percent off the newsstand price!

Conservative Grads

Learn more about the NR Collegiate Giving Clubs, a special service designed for readers who donate to universities and want to maximize the impact of their giving.

Get NRO Newsletters

MOST-READ CONTENT

Michael Tanner

Archive | Latest | Log In

September 21, 2011 4:00 A.M.

The president’s plan barely makes a pretense of reducing spending. The Obama administration claims that its proposal would reduce future budget deficits by roughly $4.4 trillion. But that includes $1.1 trillion in savings from troop draw-downs in Afghanistan and Iraq that were already going to occur. This is an old trick by which the president gets to “save” money that was never going to be spent. The president also reaches back to include $1.2 trillion in savings from the debt-ceiling deal that was signed into law last month. And, he includes $430 billion in savings from lower interest payments as a result of the reduced debt.

The president’s actual cuts total less than $580 billion over the next ten years. That amounts to less than 1.3 percent of expected total federal spending over that period. It barely offsets the cost of the new stimulus bill he announced last week.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Entitlement reform, once the supposed basis for a grand compromise, is now off the table. Social Security is running a deficit and facing more than $20 trillion in unfunded liabilities, but the president makes no changes to the program. Medicaid would be cut by roughly $72 billion over ten years, barely more than $7 billion per year in a program that today costs $276 billion annually. The president would trim Medicare by $248 billion over ten years. Depending on which accounting measure you use, that program is facing unfunded liabilities of $30–90 trillion, meaning that under the best-case scenario, the president is proposing a reduction of less than 1 percent. And none of the president’s proposed Medicare savings amounts to structural change in the program, which is what is needed. Instead, the president falls back on the usual grab-bag of cuts in provider reimbursements. Those cuts are likely to drive providers out of the program, making it harder for seniors to see a doctor, while doing nothing to change the program’s path towards insolvency.

The American welfare state is alive and well.

On the other hand, the president throws his weight fully behind tax hikes. His plan would increase taxes by $1.5 trillion over the next ten years. That’s on top of $450 billion in tax hikes that the president proposed last week to pay for the stimulus package. In total, the president is seeking nearly $2 trillion in higher taxes, compared to $580 billion in spending cuts. That amounts to nearly $4 in taxes for every $1 in cuts.

And, let’s look at those taxes. The president continues to focus his rhetoric on millionaires and billionaires, but his proposal includes the expiration of the Bush tax cuts for people earning as little as $200,000 per year. That tax hike would also fall heavily on small businesses and almost certainly would slow job creation.

The president’s other big tax initiative is, of course, the new “Buffet rule,” a new alternative-minimum tax designed to ensure that “millionaires and billionaires” pay the same effective tax rate as middle-income workers. While that populist pitch may well prove politically popular, numerous studies have shown that it is highly misleading. Few millionaires and billionaires actually pay taxes at such low effective tax rates. Those that do are receiving the majority of their income from capital gains, income that has already been taxed multiple times before it is subject to the capital-gains tax.

Besides, we should never forget that investment is both risky and necessary for job creation. It is exactly the sort of thing we should be encouraging.

But in the end, economic growth and job creation is secondary to the president. So is deficit reduction. This proposal is about the president’s idea of “fairness,” as he has said over and over. The president sees the wealthy as achieving their success not through hard work and initiative but by exploiting the less well-off or through pure luck. They are the winners of life’s lottery, in his view. It is his job, therefore, to remedy this injustice. That means taking money from some and giving it to others.

It’s about “spreading the wealth around.”

— Michael Tanner is a senior fellow at the Cato Institute and author of Leviathan on the Right: How Big-Government Conservatism Brought Down the Republican Revolution.

COMMENTS 0

EXPAND

$.getJSON('http://nr-media-01.nationalreview.com/outloudopinion/articles/277805/still-spreading-wealth-michael-tanner?jsoncallback=?', function(data){ if (data.audio) { $("#outloudopinion").html('

Listen to the Audio Version

').show(); AudioPlayer.embed("outloudaudio", { soundFile: data.audio, titles: "Still Spreading the Wealth" }); } }); Next Last

Add a Comment

Already Registered? Log In Here.

Your Name * Your E-mail * The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. Your Comment *

* Designates a required field.

NRO Articles | Article RSS | Author Directory

//'); //]]> //'); //]]> var google_adnum = 0; function google_ad_request_done(google_ads) { var ad_unit = ''; if (google_ads.length == 0) { return; } if (google_ads[0].type == "flash") { ad_unit += 'Ads by Google' + ' ' + '' + '' + ''; } else if (google_ads[0].type == "image") { ad_unit += 'Ads by Google '; } else if (google_ads[0].type == "html") { ad_unit += google_ads[0].snippet; } else { if (google_ads.length == 1) { ad_unit += 'Ads by Google' + google_ads[0].line1 + '' + google_ads[0].line2 + '' + google_ads[0].line3 + ' ' + google_ads[0].visible_url + ''; } else if (google_ads.length > 1) { ad_unit += 'Ads by Google'; for(i = 0; i < google_ads.length; ++i) { ad_unit += '' + google_ads[i].line1 + '' + google_ads[i].line2 + ' ' + google_ads[i].line3 + '' + google_ads[i].visible_url + ''; } ad_unit += ''; } } document.getElementById("ad_unit").innerHTML += ad_unit; google_adnum += google_ads.length; return; } google_ad_client = "ca-pub-7596656896688386"; google_ad_output = 'js'; google_max_num_ads = '6'; google_feedback = "on"; google_ad_type = "text"; google_adtest = "off"; google_image_size = '300x250'; google_skip = '6'; google_ad_region = 'test'; className = 'blog_text'; max_width = 400; if (document.getElementsByClassName) { classes = document.getElementsByClassName(className); } else { classes = Array(); divs = document.getElementsByTagName('div'); for(i = 0; i < divs.length; i++) { if (divs[i].className == className) { classes.push(divs[i]); } } } if (classes.length) { for (k = 0; k < classes.length; k++) { div = classes[k]; var imgs = div.getElementsByTagName("img"); for (var i in imgs) { img = imgs[i]; if (img.width < max_width || !img.src) { continue; } ratio = (img.height/img.width); img.width = max_width; img.height = Math.round((max_width * ratio)); } var objects = div.getElementsByTagName("object"); for (var i in objects) { object = objects[i]; if (object.width < max_width) { continue; } ratio = (object.height/object.width); object.width = max_width; object.height = Math.round((max_width * ratio)); } var embeds = div.getElementsByTagName("embed"); for (var i in embeds) { embed = embeds[i]; if (embed.width < max_width || !embed.src) { continue; } ratio = (embed.height/embed.width); embed.width = max_width; embed.height = Math.round((max_width * ratio)); } } } flowplayer("div.player", { src: "http://global.nationalreview.com/swf/flowplayer.commercial-3.2.2.swf", wmode: "transparent" }, { key: '#$7d41c22f17c720e72d8', canvas: { backgroundColor: '#000000', backgroundGradient: 'none' }, clip: { onStart: function() { pageTracker._trackPageview(this.getClip().url); pageTracker._trackEvent("Blog Videos", "Play", this.getClip().url); }, onResume: function() { pageTracker._trackEvent("Blog Videos", "Resume", this.getClip().url, parseInt(this.getTime())); }, onPause: function() { pageTracker._trackEvent("Blog Videos", "Pause", this.getClip().url, parseInt(this.getTime())); }, onStop: function() { pageTracker._trackEvent("Blog Videos", "Stop", this.getClip().url, parseInt(this.getTime())); }, onFinish: function() { pageTracker._trackEvent("Blog Videos", "Finish", this.getClip().url); }, scaling: 'fit' }, plugins: { audio: { url: 'flowplayer.audio-3.2.0.swf' }, controls: { url: "flowplayer.controls-air-3.2.1.swf", timeColor: "#ffffff", borderRadius: "0px", bufferGradient: "none", slowForward: true, backgroundColor: "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.6)", volumeSliderGradient: "none", slowBackward: false, progressGradient: "medium", time: true, height: 22, volumeColor: "rgba(120, 120, 120, 1)", tooltips: { marginBottom: 5, volume: true, scrubber: true, buttons: false }, opacity: 1, fastBackward: false, volumeSliderColor: "rgba(217, 210, 217, 1)", border: "0px", bufferColor: "rgba(150, 150, 150, 1)", buttonColor: "rgba(87, 87, 87, 50)", mute: true, autoHide: { enabled: true, hideDelay: 1500, hideStyle: "fade", mouseOutDelay: 1500, hideDuration: 500, fullscreenOnly: false }, backgroundGradient: [0.5,0.2,0], width: "100pct", display: "block", buttonOverColor: "rgba(148, 148, 148, 0)", fullscreen: true, timeBgColor: "rgba(0, 0, 0, 0)", scrubberBarHeightRatio: 0.2, bottom: 0, stop: false, zIndex: 1, sliderColor: "#000000", scrubberHeightRatio: 0.4, tooltipTextColor: "rgba(255, 255, 255, 0.55)", sliderGradient: "none", timeBgHeightRatio: 0.7, volumeSliderHeightRatio: 0.4, name: "controls", volumeBarHeightRatio: 0.2, left: "50pct", tooltipColor: "rgba(156, 156, 156, 0.25)", playlist: false, durationColor: "rgba(166, 166, 166, 1)", play: true, fastForward: true, progressColor: "#ffffff", timeBorder: "1px solid rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.3)", scrubber: true, volume: true, builtIn: false } } }); © National Review Online 2011. All Rights Reserved. Home | Search | NR / Digital | Donate | Media Kit | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Log In _qoptions={ qacct:"p-cdKqrewDOys1A" }; var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://ssl." : "http://www."); document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost + "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E")); pageTracker = _gat._getTracker("UA-1167326-1"); pageTracker._setDomainName(".nationalreview.com"); pageTracker._initData(); pageTracker._trackPageview('/articles/277805/still-spreading-wealth-michael-tanner'); function trackClick(elm, clickCategory, clickEvent, clickLabel, clickValue) { pageTracker._trackEvent(clickCategory, clickEvent, clickLabel); setTimeout('document.location = "' + elm.href + '"', 100); } var _sf_async_config={uid:22270,domain:"nationalreview.com"}; (function(){ function loadChartbeat() { window._sf_endpt=(new Date()).getTime(); var e = document.createElement('script'); e.setAttribute('language', 'javascript'); e.setAttribute('type', 'text/javascript'); e.setAttribute('src', (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ? "https://a248.e.akamai.net/chartbeat.download.akamai.com/102508/" : "http://static.chartbeat.com/") + "js/chartbeat.js"); document.body.appendChild(e); } var oldonload = window.onload; window.onload = (typeof window.onload != 'function') ? loadChartbeat : function() { oldonload(); loadChartbeat(); }; })(); var dc_AdLinkColor = '#216221' ; var dc_PublisherID = 186678 ;