Why the Market Deserves Benefit of the Doubt

Dow Jones Reprints: This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers, use the Order Reprints tool on any article or visit www.djreprints.com

Bypassing the preliminary small talk, let's eavesdrop on some of today's loudest market arguments, with the Dow nearly recovered from its April dip, even though investors haven't fully recouped their nerve.

Is this year walking the path trod by 2010 and 2011, when nice rallies in risk assets into the spring gave way to fearsome macro scares and swift double-digit market tumbles?

For sure, the resemblances are there, with the European sovereign-debt monster poking out from under the bed, improved domestic economic numbers giving way to softer ones and a return of napkin-shredding questions about whether central banks can and will do something to help.

The more-articulate worriers say that this rerun comes with the market and corporate-profit cycle a year older, with slower earnings growth, and greater political uncertainty the world over. Yet the Eurostress is more localized than in the past two years. Meanwhile, upbeat strategist Binky Chadha at Deutsche Bank explains why the "risk-off" trade unleashed last spring and summer seems to have less juice in it now: The 10-year Treasury yield is below 2% already, versus above 3% a year ago. Corporate-bond spreads are wider (showing less complacency), and equity valuations a bit lower.

This suggests that more negative noise would be less jarring to the markets. The past two years, it took an overbought stock market, giddy investor sentiment, a soft patch in economic numbers, and outsize shocks ("flash crash," earthquake, oil spike, drawn-out Greek default, U.S. credit downgrade) to invite a bear scare. This time, we had the overbought market and a garden-variety cooling of macro data. So far, no big shock, no big deal.

How likely is it that markets would serve up the same pattern for a third straight year, just as everyone has been talking loudly about the similarities with the past two?

A related query: Is it likely that the impending "fiscal cliff" -- the coming fiscal drag from expiring government stimulus -- will be this year's market bugaboo, given that it has already become Wall Street's pervasive preoccupation? A Factiva news search shows that the term "fiscal cliff" quintupled in usage this month versus the prior two. True, sometimes the snake you're watching still bites you, but not as often as the one that's hidden.

Given Treasury yields' stubborn refusal to rise, even as Fed officials downplay additional bond-buying efforts, is the strong equity market resilient or in denial?

This is certainly an intermarket relationship to watch closely, and stock bulls should probably hope for government yields to work higher, to ratify the decent economic results. The bond market is less distractible in discounting economic forces, even if the Treasury yield has sat near 2% all year as equities have risen at a 40% annualized rate.

Could that little 4.3%, two-week drop in the S&P 500, starting April 2, have been the long-awaited correction?

Quite possibly. If so, it's because the drop rapidly reset short-term market psychology toward skepticism, and because, beneath the indexes, cyclical and high-expectation stocks were punished far more severely. The main weekly survey of retail investors now shows more bears than bulls, and options traders have been leaning toward protective bets. The froth has been skimmed off some glamour names. The PowerShares S&P High Beta ETF (ticker: SPHB) lost nearly 10% in three weeks into this month's low. As long as the market refuses to buckle, given plenty of passable motivations to do so, it deserves the benefit of the doubt. This Friday's employment data could provide a timely test of stocks' sturdiness.

Can stocks hold up without stronger trading volume?

Yes, because that's what they've been doing for most of the past three years. In a market featuring so many electronic middlemen with algorithms built to trade noise in sub-penny increments and intervals of microseconds, volume follows volatility. Wishing for more volume is tantamount to wishing for fear-driven, jumpy markets. Rallies have come on lighter volume than selloffs during virtually the entire doubling of the U.S. market the past three years.

Main Street's ongoing boycott of equity funds also withholds buying power from traditional money managers. The Investment Company Institute estimates that stock funds shed $8.6 billion in the first quarter, despite a straight-up market. And don't expect the public to suddenly fall into lust with the market, given the daily diet of worrisome headlines we'll be served over the balance of this election year of diminished expectations and no easy fixes. 

Comments? E-mail: michael.santoli@barrons.com

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com

The coffee giant turned in a solid first-quarter but shares sank as investors hoped for more. Buy the dip.

by Richard C. Morais

Penta's ongoing investigation into where the nation's top chefs eat on their downtime serves up a big "value" surprise.

The S&P 500 index can gain in second quarter, thanks to an improving economy and "less downside surprise to manage," the bank writes.

The stock is up strongly Friday on a Street-beating earnings report. But Nomura thinks it can gain an additional 25%.

Wells Fargo handicaps upcoming quarterly results for a slew of companies in the sector.

In assigning Texas Capital Bancshares a Buy rating, Sterne Agee writes that the shares can climb about 18%.

Illumina has compared itself to the world's most valuable company. But the gene decoder seems overvalued given the growing competition.

First-quarter earnings were hardly impressive but a 21% dividend hike bodes well for investors.

Yahoo and Microsoft's Bing continue to lose share against the search leader, writes Nomura.

The Internet-technology stock is upgraded on improved traffic and pricing environment.

Choosing when -- and how much -- to buy may be as important as what to buy.

Bernanke-friendly GDP report. Sizing up the Wal-Mart scandal. A growth business gone sour.

The company dominates the online-payment business with PayPal and has become an all-around leader in e-tailing. Why Wall Street looks ready to bid up eBay at last.

The "Teflon" market continues to rise, as investors ignore bad news in favor of good. Nine stocks that could pay special dividends, including Limited Brands, Carnival and HCA.

Thermo Fisher Scientific looks ready to surprise the skeptics. The big supplier of lab gear is boosting margins, expanding overseas and carrying out acquisitions with aplomb.

In both the U.S. and Europe, those who hold the monetary purse strings are reluctant to loosen them, even as economic numbers disappoint.

Oracle's move into cloud-based software will enhance current offerings and drive new sales. The shares could rise 10% —and possibly much more—in a year.

The troubled economies on the periphery of Europe are getting into deeper trouble. Growth has slowed, unemployment has risen, indebtedness has gone up, and borrowing costs have climbed sharply.

Niall Ferguson, economic and financial historian, sees parallels between the U.S. now and the mid-20th-century U.K.

What you should know about the increasingly popular array of low-volatility funds.

Former SEC chief Richard Breeden's fund looks for opportunities at companies in need of change. Among them: Steris, H&R Block and Zale.

Amazon.com stock surges, as gross margins jump.

Its share of GDP declined in the latest report, which saw overall growth in output of 2.2%, against consensus expectations of 2.6%.

Subscriber Content Read Preview

Subscriber Content Read Preview

Subscriber Content Read Preview

Subscriber Content Read Preview

Subscriber Content Read Preview

Read Full Article »




Related Articles

Market Overview
Search Stock Quotes