With Europe's ESG 2.0, Compliance Is Not An Option
AP
X
Story Stream
recent articles

Even as many American businesses are quietly quitting the environmental, social and governance (ESG) movement due to political pushback from Republicans, Europe is now moving full speed ahead with the next phase of its controlled sustainable finance experiment by making ESG mandatory for most European companies and financial institutions.

To help pay for the European Green Deal, with its priority goal of transitioning away from hydrocarbons, the European Union (EU) has passed a wave of sustainability rules and directives to conscript the private sector into the government-led drive to make Europe the first “carbon neutral” continent by the year 2050. Using financial disclosure to help force a change in corporate behavior, European firms must now report regularly on how their business and investment activities align with the EU’s ESG prescriptions, including how much capital is being steered toward companies and projects deemed “sustainable” by the bureaucrats in Brussels.

Given their categorical, prescriptive, and impact-oriented nature, the EU’s sustainability regulations supersede all the various disparate ESG-related ratings and scoring systems that have sprung up in recent years. They also render moot any lingering debate about whether ESG factors drive corporate or investment outperformance since European business compliance is no longer optional.

So far, the EU’s financial shaming system seems to be working. Between 2015 and 2025, Europe’s total fossil fuel investment declined by 27% in real terms, while its capital spending on “clean” energy sources (mainly wind and solar power) doubled to $500 billion, more than five times the amount spent on hydrocarbon development. Such a dramatic shift was not justified by industry fundamentals or risk-return market relationships during the period and should have been contradicted by recent regional geopolitical developments. The logical response to the outbreak of the Russia-Ukraine war in 2022 should have been a resurgence in European capital spending on indigenous hydrocarbon projects, not a continued decline.

As we argue in our recent article, Europe’s current attempt to reengineer its financial system on socially responsible grounds and allocate capital based on ESG criteria instead of investor preferences will lead to a misallocation of scarce resources and a reduction in overall economic welfare.

Ignoring the socialist and communist lessons of the last century, Europe is once again engaging in a form of central planning with its sustainable finance and ESG edicts—an incredible conceit considering the complexity of modern finance. Nonetheless, EU government officials, working in tandem with like-minded or opportunist CEOs and asset managers, are now seeking to replace the decentralized information processing of the financial system with their own limited knowledge base. The end goal is to override the market’s independent pricing mechanism by using ESG mandates (e.g., reducing carbon emissions) to determine which firms get capital and at what cost.

Mass adoption of ESG will fundamentally alter the financial sector’s critical role in the European economy of balancing supply and demand for available capital while filtering out the investable universe based on opportunity costs, trade-offs, and net externalities. A default to the preferences of government planners will reduce market price informativeness and distort the efficient allocation of funds needed to meet  the most urgent needs of society and citizens.

The unintended negative consequences of Europe’s ESG financial exercise can already be seen at the macroeconomic level. Thanks to its anti-fossil fuel policies, Europe now boasts some of the highest electricity prices in the world—roughly two-to-four times the U.S. average, depending on the country—despite spending 62% more on per capita energy investment now versus ten years ago.

Higher energy costs coupled with drastic regulation, in turn, have weakened the competitive position of Europe’s energy-intensive manufacturing base, especially in Germany, where industrial production peaked in 2017 and the national economy stopped expanding four years ago. By almost every measure—including real GDP growth, world export share, gross fixed capital formation, corporate R&D spending, labor productivity, and per capita personal income—Europe’s continental economy has grown more anemic and sclerotic in recent years.

Even though the European Green Deal was promised as a “new growth strategy” that would transform the EU into a “competitive economy,” a 2024 report to the European Commission prepared by former European Central Bank President Mario Draghi highlighted how higher energy prices and a heavy regulatory burden were leading to a loss of European business competitiveness. Since the release of the Draghi report, there has been no discernible change in the EU’s decarbonization and net-zero emissions goals or the legal momentum behind its sustainable finance mandates, away from some public hand-wringing and marginal tinkering with rule details and deadlines.

While often couched as much-needed reform for the global financial system, sustainable investing is antagonistic and antithetical to a well-functioning free market. By meddling with the entrepreneurial function and the market process, EU mandates will likely result in negative outcomes, both economically and (ironically) environmentally. Over the coming years, Europe’s ESG experiment will therefore prove instructive for the rest of the world since it will illustrate the consequences of “green” central planning—both economic and financial—based on the a priori political determination of which business activities are sustainable and which are not.

The fatal flaw that Europe’s government central planners failed to consider when drawing up their comprehensive sustainability plans is the fact that companies and investors are not bound by Europe’s physical borders. Both are flexible and mobile due to the integrated nature of the world’s financial markets and the global economy.

By removing the agency of business executives and professional investors while layering on significant compliance costs and legal liability, the EU’s onerous ESG framework will only serve to drive corporate issuers and investment capital away from Europe. Since the European financial markets are not a closed loop, it is only a matter of time before the EU regulators lose complete control of their controlled sustainable finance experiment.

Mr. Gomes is a full professor of finance at Université Jean Moulin Lyon 3 in France. Mr. Tice is an adjunct professor of finance at New York University’s Stern School of Business and a senior fellow at the National Center for Energy Analytics. Both are co-authors of the article, “Socially Responsible Investing: A Resource Misallocation Disaster in the Making,” published in The Independent Review.



Comment
Show comments Hide Comments