Can a city be planned in the same way that an architect designs a house? American economist Sanford Ikeda, a professor at the State University of New York, believes this is a mistake. In his book “A City Cannot Be a Work of Art” (Palgrave Macmillan), he draws on the ideas of American urban critic Jane Jacobs. Jacobs studied how cities actually function and developed her criticism of government urban planning on that basis. Her approach was not deductive, but pragmatic: She observed life in cities and drew conclusions from what she saw. However, she never systematically developed a coherent economic and sociological theory underlying her insights. This is what Ikeda attempts to do.
Ikeda criticizes architects who treat existing cities as blank canvases on which they can realize their grand designs, disregarding the complex structures that have developed over time.
To explain how order emerges, Ikeda draws on a comparison made by economist Richard E. Wagner: a military parade and an Italian piazza. At a military parade, everything is prescribed down to the smallest detail. Every soldier has his assigned place, every step is predetermined. One person gives orders, the others obey. Everything follows a central plan. Individual initiative is not wanted.
An Italian piazza is entirely different. People come and go, talk to one another, drink coffee, shop, or watch other people. Children play, waiters serve their customers, and passersby move around one another. Nobody has drawn up a plan determining who should be where and when. Nobody gives orders. Yet the interaction between people works. Order emerges even though nobody has planned it.
At a military parade, order is imposed from above, through command and obedience. On the piazza, it emerges from below, through people's voluntary decisions. The parade works only if everyone follows the plan. The piazza works precisely because everyone can pursue their own plans and coordinate with others.
There is a parallel here with the economy. Unlike socialism, capitalism is not a system invented by intellectuals sitting at their desks and imposed from above. It developed through an evolutionary process, much as animals and plants evolved in nature without the need for a central planner.
Friedrich August von Hayek explained this connection particularly clearly. He argued that functioning institutions did not originate through deliberate invention or planning, but emerged through an evolutionary process in which successful institutions survived. People imitated institutions and customs that had proved successful.
The greatest mistake socialists make is believing that a few particularly intelligent people can design an economic system that works better than the outcome of decisions made by millions of entrepreneurs, investors, and consumers. Hayek called this way of thinking constructivism. However, this mistake is not confined to socialists. There are even libertarians who believe they can design the perfect society at their desks.
What applies to the economy also applies to the city. A city is not a military parade. It is the result of millions of decisions. People move into certain neighborhoods, while others move away. Entrepreneurs open businesses, while others close them. New restaurants appear, old ones disappear. Buildings are renovated, apartments are enlarged or divided.
Yet many urban planners believe they must make decisions for people, planning cities according to their own aesthetic, political, or other preferences.
In Chapter 8 of his book, Ikeda provides numerous examples of how governments control the development of cities and restrict the decisions of property owners, entrepreneurs, and residents. His examples relate primarily to the United States, although similar regulations exist in many other countries.
· Functional Zoning: The government determines where people may live, work, or shop. Residential areas, business districts, and industrial zones are separated. The result is often business districts deserted in the evenings and residential neighborhoods with little activity during the day. This prevents precisely the lively mixture of activities that Jane Jacobs valued. The New York Times once reported that zoning regulations were so restrictive that 40 percent of Manhattan's buildings could no longer be built today.
· Mandatory Inclusionary Zoning: To obtain building permits, developers must construct a certain percentage of apartments with regulated rents, for example 30 percent. The idea is to create more affordable housing. However, the market-rate apartments must cross-subsidize the cheaper ones, making them more expensive. If a project becomes financially unviable, it may never be built. In that case, neither the planned price-controlled apartments nor the market-rate apartments are constructed.
· Voluntary Inclusionary Zoning: Developers may be allowed to construct taller buildings if they agree to provide apartments at regulated rents in return. This sounds voluntary. In reality, the government first prohibits a particular type of development and then “generously” permits it if the developer complies with additional requirements. Freedom is first restricted, and then part of it is returned as a reward.
Not all government regulations are unnecessary or harmful, but there are certainly far more unnecessary than sensible regulations in this area.
These interventions are based on a similar assumption: that government authorities can make better decisions than property owners, entrepreneurs, and residents about what a city should look like. The consequences are often fewer apartments, higher construction costs, and fewer opportunities for cities to adapt to changing needs.
Many measures are justified as attempts to create affordable housing. Yet governments simultaneously impose minimum requirements for housing quality, parking spaces, building setbacks, and floor-area ratios that make construction more expensive. One set of regulations drives up costs, while another attempts to mitigate the consequences.
Ikeda also points to an important contradiction: Almost every other market offers inexpensive products for low-income consumers, including cars and smartphones. Why should housing be different? Cheap, simple apartments serve an important need, particularly for people with low incomes. Yet regulations frequently prevent precisely this kind of housing from being built.
Jane Jacobs recognized that lively cities do not emerge because a few planners determine everything down to the smallest detail. Cities develop through countless decisions made by the people who live and work there. Sanford Ikeda demonstrates the economic logic behind this insight. A city is not a military parade. And anyone who tries to design it like a work of art according to a central plan risks destroying precisely what makes a city vibrant.