Politicians and special interest groups in California have started going after an unlikely group of people: fantasy sports players. Shutting down fantasy contests in California has suddenly become a real possibility. These groups are intent upon disrupting fantasy sports everywhere. The effort has support from both parties, and some conservatives in Texas have introduced new legislation that would ban all fantasy sports contests in the Lone Star State.
I helped write the federal Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIEGA) twenty years ago. Back then, offshore sites were taking illegal bets from Americans over the internet, and our answer was to choke off the payments that kept those sites alive. There’s still plenty of work left on offshore and other illegal sites, which continue to take money from Americans. But we recognized then that illegal sports betting and fantasy sports betting are very different, so we carved fantasy contests out of the federal definition of a bet and wager.
The fantasy sports language was in the works for years before it passed. The baseball players’ union even testified on its behalf in 1998. They knew fantasy players were among the sport’s most loyal fans. Every major league backed it. When the bipartisan bill finally passed in 2006, the House vote was 409 to 2, and the Senate passed it by unanimous consent. My colleague, Democrat Congressman Xavier Becerra, now the Governor-Elect of California, voted for it. Try getting numbers like that today.
We were careful with the definition, too. A fantasy contest only qualifies for protection as fantasy sports under the law if it clears three tests.
The first is that skill and knowledge decide the winners, based mainly on individual athletes’ accumulated stats over several real games. One game can come down to a fluke. Spread that across a full slate and a whole roster, though, and the luck mostly washes out. The person who did the homework tends to win.
The second: nobody can win on a team’s score, the point spread, a combination of teams, or just one athlete’s performance in a single game. Those are the bets sportsbooks take. Leaving those out is what keeps a fantasy contest from turning into a regular sports bet. What matters is how well you put together an entire lineup, not whether one team got lucky.
Third, prizes have to be fixed and announced before the contest begins. Their value can’t rise or fall with how many people sign up or how much they put in. You’re playing for a known prize, like a golfer playing for a tournament purse. That’s different from a betting pool, where the pot swells with every dollar wagered, and that kind of setup has been linked to problem gambling.
If a contest fails any of those tests, the UIGEA doesn’t protect it. Good. I have zero sympathy for operators running sports betting under the guise of fantasy sports. They should be shut down. But a contest that meets the criteria is exactly what Congress set out to protect.
That line held for almost 20 years. Yet now a group of activist politicians and special interest groups want to outlaw fantasy sports. As far as I can tell, their argument is that because money changes hands and sports results are involved, it has to be considered a bet. They are wrong about that. A bettor puts money up against the house on a point spread or the next play, then waits. A fantasy player drafts a roster, studies matchups, figures out how to leverage the scoring rules, and competes against other people in contests for prizes. Knowledge and judgment decide who wins.
Governor Newsom quickly sided with fantasy sports players and rightly called for state legislation to better protect fantasy sports players.
The people who play fantasy sports aren’t the same crowd you’d find at a casino. I know of office leagues that have been running for fifteen years. Or the high school friends now living in four different states, kids grown, still trash-talking every Sunday. Or the service members running a league from a deployment. For many Americans, this is how they stay in touch, and these leagues almost always cross state lines. That’s why we built the federal framework on Congress’s power over interstate commerce.
Congress settled this question in 2006, and California activists are trying to reopen it. Until Congress reinforces what it meant, or California’s legislature settles the matter, your fantasy football league really could be one court case away from trouble. Sports fans deserve better.