X
Story Stream
recent articles

This month, Americans voters handed Democrats control of Congress in a midterm election that was driven largely by cost of living. When asked about life for the next generation, 57 percent of voters say they expect America’s next generation to be worse off than today. 

While policies related to affordability certainly matter, the most important question has to do with the American Dream. Does hard work still lead somewhere?

Answering this question drove the Social Mobility Around the World index, which I co-authored with Carlos Martinez and released this month for the nonpartisan Archbridge Institute. Rather than looking backward, the index measures the environment that shapes opportunity and mobility today. It ranks 132 countries and tracks direct policy- and outcome-related variables that have been shown to matter for mobility. 

The good news is that the United States ranks fourth in the world, behind only Switzerland, Denmark, and Norway. American strength continues to be its economic dynamism. The U.S. ranks third globally on entrepreneurship and growth, first on labor market freedom, and second on legal system quality and property rights. 

The bad news is where the climb stalls. In certain cases, policies that promote mobility have slid in recent years. America ranks 17th overall on education and civil society—our weakest pillar and the only one where our northern neighbor Canada outperforms us. While the U.S. ranks fifth in human capital (a measure of the amount of education and returns on that education), we are just 58th in terms of education equality. Recent school choice movements at the state level have helped, but a child’s ZIP code still decides too much about the quality of the education received. 

Overall, social mobility does not come from one level. It takes economic dynamism, well-functioning legal systems, as well as education and civil society. This gives the newly elected officials at the federal and state level a possible reform agenda that goes beyond relief checks, price controls, and socialism. 

First, stop crowding out private credit. The U.S. ranks 80th on credit market regulation, which in part penalizes credit absorbed by government borrowing. This is where our ever-growing national debt harms citizens today and future generations. A Yale Budget Lab study estimates that higher interest rates as a result of federal government debt adds roughly $2,500 per year on the average mortgage for Americans who never agreed to continuous debt.

Second, make it cheaper to build. Faster permitting for roads, ports, and energy production would close the gap in infrastructure with much of the modern world, where the U.S. ranks just 16th globally. Many affordability problems are at their core problems of restricted supply. Congress is currently debating a bill that would ease delays due to permitting. 

There is also a harder truth behind the fourth-place finish. Archbridge’s index uses 2024 data, and some of our strengths have eroded since. The U.S. ranked ninth in the world on free-trade measures like tariffs, but raising tariff rates has become a pillar of the Trump administration. The Tax Foundation estimates that tariffs have increased costs on U.S. households by about $1,000 per household. Simply returning to pre-2016 tariff rates would ease affordability and opportunity concerns for everyday Americans. 

Similarly, the U.S. previously ranked second in the world on keeping the state out of economic activity. Since last January, the federal government has signed 40 deals to take stakes in private companies. Crony capitalism is a setback: Government ownership tilts the field toward the politically connected, harming the very idea of competitive capitalism that has defined America’s economic dynamism. The private sector is dependent on individual entrepreneurship and small business health, not dealmaking in the Beltway.

The 2026 candidates that Americans elected will face pressure to deliver quick fixes. Addressing affordability and expanding opportunity can go hand in hand.

However, lasting affordability comes from a country where people can earn more, start something of their own, and trust that the rules are fair. As recent research shows, America still has the foundation, but the new Congress must start removing the barriers to success now—before the idea that the next generation cannot get ahead becomes a reality. 

Justin T. Callais, PhD is chief economist at the Archbridge Institute.


Comment
Show comments Hide Comments