Dow Jones Reprints: This copy is for your personal, non-commerical use only. To order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers, use the Order Reprints tool on any article or visit www.djreprints.com
THE SUMMER HEAT NOTWITHSTANDING, Wall Street is now thick with folks shivering over the collapse of Treasury-bond yields, reading it as an augur of a coming deflationary ice age.
The question, "What is the bond market telling us?" is being asked with growing urgency, mostly by folks who have settled on the answer that the bond market is conveying a message that economic- growth expectations are in peril and that the stock market—which even after last week's dip is in the upper end of its summer range—is ignoring it at grave risk.
The 10-year Treasury yield sliding to a 16-month low of 2.68% shouldn't be ignored or explained away. It's for good reason the stock market was dubbed "the bond market's idiot kid brother." Clearly, at minimum, the 10-year yield at these levels reflects the general reduction in U.S. growth assumptions, both about last quarter and the second half of the year. Yet there is probably more going on here than bonds reliably pricing in another economic contraction that would upend stocks. There's even a chance that neither stocks nor bonds have the outlook wrong. The argument between the two asset classes might instead be a subdued and agreeable discussion.
At the most basic level, both markets seem to have internalized the idea that the Federal Reserve's zero-rate policy is the law of the land for the investable future, and policy makers stand ready to throw money at the economy's problems, be they evident or hypothetical. With overnight lending rates at zero and the two-year note yield barely above half a percent in yield, the incentives for banks and other leveraged investors to simply coast along the yield curve remain strong, even at 2.68% on the 10-year.
There have also been hints that some of the buying pressure on 10-year Treasuries looks forced or mechanical, related to hedging by mortgage-bond investors. One thing is sure: The rally in longer-term Treasury paper hasn't been supported by the largest U.S. bond investor. Pacific Investment Management, which Bloomberg recently reported is taking in $1 billion a week from bond-craving investors, reduced U.S. government-related holdings in its flagship Total Return fund in July from 63% to a still-high 54%.
A more salient rejoinder to the admonition to heed the bond market is, "Which bond market, exactly?"
Because in contrast to the purported economic malaise and acute risk aversion being foretold by teensy Treasury yields, the corporate bond market hasn't flinched at all.
The iShares iBoxx Investment Grade Debt exchange-traded fund (ticker: LQD) traded at nearly a five-year high last week. The iShares iBoxx High Yield Corporate Bond ETF (HYG) has held steady in the last three months, as the 10-year Treasury yield sank more than 20%. If economic and corporate fortunes were due to erode quickly, corporate debt would presumably be sniffing this out as well.
For sure, corporate debt is supported by a couple of strong tailwinds. Very slow but positive economic growth is something near a nirvana state for credit, as strategists at Morgan Stanley noted. Companies can handily service their debt without necessarily growing rapidly, and a sluggish recovery forestalls inflationary fears that can poison returns.
And, of course, the public is bingeing on bonds, and has been for years. In the first half of 2010, investors sent $136 billion in net new money into bond mutual funds, taking the total net inflow since the start of 2009 above $500 billion.
Corporate America has been availing itself of the public's willingness to lend, as the widely noted International Business Machines (IBM) sale of three-year notes at a 1% rate attests. The percentage of new corporate-capital issuance in the form of equity is near a 20-year low. History suggests that what companies are most eager to sell isn't the best buy, and vice versa.
The risk isn't necessarily that there's a bond "bubble," as is commonly heard (especially from folks who sell stocks). A bubble requires that the public be whipped up into a state of enthusiasm over some grandiose "story" about a certain asset class. That isn't happening, unless one considers the sober demographic argument in favor of income instruments.
No, one take-away is that bond investors better be happy with the coupon, because not much absolute appreciation is likely from current levels. And most probably are.
Another is that if the environment remains OK for corporate credit, then it shouldn't be terribly hostile to equities. J.P. Morgan noted last week that the forward "earnings yield" of the Standard & Poor's 500 based on current forecasts is 8.1%, while high-yield bonds were at 8.3%—the narrowest spread in history (it has averaged 5.1% since 1987).
Telling a similar story in a different way, the dividend yield of the Dow Jones Industrial Average components, at 2.65%, is essentially equal to the 10-year Treasury yield. The folks at Morgan Stanley note that over the past 50 years the Dow's yield has exceeded that of the 10-year Treasury for only one period—the end of 2008 into early 2009, as the financial crisis climaxed.
E-mail: michael.santoli@barrons.com
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com
Yahoo! Buzz
MySpace
Digg
del.icio.us
NewsVine
StumbleUpon
Mixx
Three insiders have bought $3.6 million in the tech firm's stock.
Though quarterly results from Nordstrom, Kohl's and J.C. Penney were disappointing, we think one name is worth buying.
Ticonderoga says it sees general improvement in the sector.
Nvidia and Dynegy rose. Lilly and Nordstrom fell.
Wedbush upgraded the water-treatment firm to Outperform from Neutral.
Morgan Keegan keeps Outperform ratings on Baxter and Haemonetics.
Credit Suisse downgraded the foods firm to Neutral from Outperform.
Despite impressive gains, a latte upside remains for the coffee giant's stock. Perk Up Your Portfolio
Alan S. McKim sold 67,000 shares of the cleanup company.
UBS says valuations in the sector have more upside.
Sterne Agee downgraded the apparel retailer to Neutral from Buy.
In light of Thursday's earnings-induced selloff, the answer is yes, assuming you can endure what will likely be a bumpy ride.
Raymond James likes Starwood, Gaylord and three REITs.
Wedbush downgraded Gap to Neutral from Outperform and cut estimates.
The drug distributor should benefit from federal stimulus and the company's lesser-known health-care IT business.
The bet on the burger chain provides a good investing lesson. (At SmartMoney.com.)
A torrent of bad news, coupled with a caution and feeble action by the Fed, jolt investors and clouds the market outlook. GDP estimates take a wicked hit.
Coinstar's DVD rental group has risen from nowhere to become a major film player. And the story isn't over.
Japan's Toto, purveyor of luxe toilets, is changing the privy habits of people around the world. With more innovations in store, its stock could sparkle like the finest of porcelain.
A Barron's screen turns up 13 big companies with inexpensive stocks, healthy dividends and the ability to keep paying shareholders, in industries ranging from health care to tech.
Read Full Article »