${Html.ActionLink("My MarketWatch", "index", new { controller = "composite", area = "section", page = "my" })} | !{Html.ActionLink("Sign out", "LogOff", new { area = "User", controller = "Account" }, new { id = "signOutLink" })}
Welcome, ${UserDisplayName}
Log in
Become a MarketWatch member today
Mark Hulbert Archives | Email alerts
Jan. 31, 2012, 12:01 a.m. EST
Want to see how this story relates to your portfolio?
Just add items to create a portfolio now:
Create Portfolio or Cancel Already have a portfolio? Log In
By Mark Hulbert, MarketWatch
CHAPEL HILL, N.C. (MarketWatch) "” Can the Super Bowl help you make more money this year?
Yes.
But that profit won't come from basing your investments on who wins this coming Sunday's game "” even if, per the veritable Super Bowl Predictor, the Giants win on Sunday and the market rises, or the Patriots win and the market falls.
On the contrary, Sunday's game can help us become better investors only if we use it to understand how almost any data set is vulnerable to being tortured into saying something meaningless.
/quotes/zigman/627449 DJIA 12,653.72, -6.74, -0.05%
The Super Bowl Predictor, for those of you who haven't heard of it, holds that stocks will rise over the coming year if the winning team can trace its roots back to the original National Football League "” and fall if that team's roots are in the old American Football League. Followers claim that the Indicator has an impressive 79% success rate.
There's less here than meets the eye, however "” even if we overlook the Predictor's spectacular failure the last time the Giants won the Super Bowl, in 2008. Far from rising, as it the indicator predicted, stocks turned in their worst year since the 1930s.
The problem with the Predictor's 79% success rate: It is artificially inflated by the indicator's especially good record in the late 1960s and early 1970s, which came before even the most diehard football fan ever dreamed of correlating the Super bowl winner with the stock market. The earliest mention in a mainstream publication of such a correlation, as far as I can determine, came in 1978 by the late Leonard Koppett, a sports writer for the New York Times.
Reuters New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning.To properly judge the indicator's success, we should be focusing only on its record since then. Otherwise, we would be guilty of what statisticians refer to as hindsight bias. To put that in football terms, it's akin to Monday-morning quarterbacking.
Unfortunately for the indicator, its real-time success since 1978 has been less impressive "” 68%, in fact. While that might still seem much better than a coin flip, it isn't. A simple bet that the market would rise each year would have been right 76% of the time since 1978.
Another essential reality check that can help immunize us from being seduced by spurious correlations: Estimate how many others were tested during the process of "discovering" the one that now appears to be so impressive. We should never forget that, even at the 95% confidence level that statisticians use to conclude that a pattern is genuine, there will be five "false positives" out of every 100 apparent correlations.
This is a crucial point, given the millions of investors who constantly analyze the market's every squiggle and are correlating those squiggles with everything from sunspots to tea leaves.
To give one example: Consider another sports-related predictor, which also was popular in the 1970s. According to it, if the American League won the World Series in a presidential election year, then the Republican candidate would win the presidency, while the Democrat would win if the National League team won. Based on its "uncanny" success rate from 1952 through 1976, many began singing this indicator's praises.
It failed in 1980, however, and its record since then has been statistically indistinguishable from 50:50. Now hardly anyone but the old-timers have even heard of it.
Click to Play $(function () { $("#video_44843C4D-5BD2-4DD2-BF30-B3E07BB3253A").click(function (e) { e.preventDefault(); MarketWatch.Video.loadAndStartVideo('44843C4D-5BD2-4DD2-BF30-B3E07BB3253A', 'video_44843C4D-5BD2-4DD2-BF30-B3E07BB3253A', '287', '162'); }); }); Why market likes the GiantsFor 36 of the 45 Super Bowls, the stock market has gone up after a win by an "original" National Football League team, and gone down when they lose. Does that mean everyone should root for the Giants? (Photo: Getty Images)
To be sure, hope springs eternal, and some believers in the Super Bowl Predictor will undoubtedly continue to believe in it "” my calm, reasoned prose notwithstanding. They will find apparently strong support for this belief in an article that appeared in the Spring 2010 issue of the Journal of Investing, written by George Kester, a finance professor at Washington & Lee University.
Kester measured the returns of a portfolio that switched between the market and cash according to the Super Bowl Predictor, and found that even in real time since the indicator was first publicized, this portfolio has beaten a buy-and-hold. So even if it's not statistically significant, it's economically significant.
Note carefully, however: Kester does not endorse the indicator. In an interview Monday afternoon, he told me that he thinks it's ridiculous for anyone to do so. On the contrary, one of his goals in conducting the study was to show how difficult it is to beat a buy-and-hold.
Is Kester nevertheless hoping that the Giants will win on Sunday, I asked him? Laughing, he said "yes," acknowledging that maybe even he was unconsciously believing that a win by an old NFL team would be better for the stock market than a win by an old AFL team.
Click here to learn more about the Hulbert Financial Digest.
//$(document).ready(function() { var storywidth = $('#mainstory').width(); var maxwidth = storywidth; $('#maincontent pre').each(function (index, value) { var thiswidth = $(value).width(); if (thiswidth > maxwidth) maxwidth = thiswidth; }); var offset = maxwidth - storywidth; if (offset > 0) { var margin = 13; var blanketwidth = $('#blanket').width(); var contentwidth = $('#maincontent').width(); $('#blanket').width(blanketwidth + offset + margin); $('#maincontent').width(contentwidth + offset + margin); $('#mainstory').width(storywidth + offset + margin); } //});Mark Hulbert is the founder of Hulbert Financial Digest in Annandale, Va. He has been tracking the advice of more than 160 financial newsletters since 1980.
var OB_permalink= 'http://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-wall-street-is-rooting-for-the-giants-2012-01-31'; var OB_Template="marketwatch"; var OB_widgetId= 'AR_1'; var OB_langJS ='http://widgets.outbrain.com/lang_en.js'; if ( typeof(OB_Script)!='undefined' ) OutbrainStart(); else { var OB_Script = true; var str = ""; document.write(str); } Comment on this story 1 Comment Most Popular Therese Poletti's Tech TalesFacebook IPO is the talk of Silicon Valley
1. Paul B. FarrellShort China: Its commodities bubble is set to pop
2. Asia MarketsMost Asia markets rise; Taipei, Hong Kong gain
3. David Weidner's Writing on the WallDavos is just an ego trip for the 1%
4. Earnings OutlookKindle may set Fire to Amazon's results
5. Join the Conversation 1 Comments 1,000 characters My comments... Community guidelines » Add Comment Breaking Insight David Weidner's Writing on the WallDavos is just an ego trip for the 1%
Therese Poletti's Tech TalesFacebook IPO is the talk of Silicon Valley
Irwin KellnerIt's the fiscal policy, stupid
Paul B. FarrellShort China: Its commodities bubble is set to pop
Find a Broker Partner Center » VideoAsia Week Ahead: Electronics Giants Post Earnings
U.S. Week Ahead: Exxon, Amazon, jobs
Investors, Skip the 'January Indicator' for Stocks
Tax-Time Confusion over Reporting Capital Gains
About Mark Hulbert RSS News feedMark Hulbert is editor of the Hulbert Financial Digest, which since 1980 has been tracking the performance of hundreds of investment advisors. The HFD... Expand
Mark Hulbert is editor of the Hulbert Financial Digest, which since 1980 has been tracking the performance of hundreds of investment advisors. The HFD became a service of MarketWatch in April 2002. In addition to being a Senior Columnist for MarketWatch, Hulbert writes a monthly column for Barron's.com and a column on investment strategies for the Journal of the American Association of Individual Investors. A frequent guest on television and radio shows, you may have seen Hulbert on CNBC, Wall Street Week, or ABC's World News This Morning. Most recently, Dow Jones and MarketWatch launched a new weekly newsletter based on Hulbert's research, entitled Hulbert on Markets: What's Working Now. Collapse
More from Mark Hulbert As goes January, so goes the year? How to catch a falling knife A leading indicator of a higher market? Market as undervalued today as in 1990 Exploiting munis' abnormally high yields Featured Commentary » Next: Irwin KellnerThe Economist's Corner
It's the fiscal policy, stupid
Next: David Weidner's Writing on the WallWriting on the Wall
Davos is just an ego trip for the 1%
Next: Jeanette Pavini's Buyer BewareBuyer Beware
Jobless grads fight loan fees
Next: Paul B. FarrellBehavioral Economics
China's commodities bubble is set to pop
Next: Therese Poletti's Tech TalesTech Tales
Facebook IPO is the talk of Silicon Valley
Next: Mark HulbertOn the Markets
Why Wall Street is rooting for the Giants
Next: Lawrence G. McMillan
Overbought market still has bullish potential
Next: Chuck JaffeMutual Funds
Stable-value funds are shaky 401(k) options
Next: Amy Hoak's Home EconomicsHome Economics
It may be a good time to buy, but not to sell
Next: Craig Stephen's This Week in ChinaThis Week in China
Apple wrestles with its "?China problem'
Next: Peter BrimelowWall Street Irregulars
Gold bull methodically takes profits
WSJ WSJ MarketWatch MarketWatch Facebook Twitter Barron's Barron's SmartMoney SmartMoney AllThingsDigital AllThingsDigital FINS FINS More BigCharts Virtual Stock Exchange Financial News WSJ Asia WSJ India WSJ China chinese edition WSJ Japan japanese edition WSJ Europe WSJ Deutschland WSJ Americas en Español em Português WSJ Radio WSJ Wine SEARCH 5:19 AM EST January 31, 2012 /marketstate/country/us New York Closed /marketstate/country/uk London Open /marketstate/country/jp Tokyo Closed /marketstate/country/us /marketstate/country/uk /marketstate/country/jp View All Latest News /news/latest 4:54aEuropean markets edge higher on EU pact
4:22aBanks might double ECB emergency loans: report
3:34aMost Asia markets rise; Taipei, Hong Kong gain
3:16aEurope stocks open higher, led by banks, ARM
3:14aSantander profit falls short; takes â?¬3.18B charge
3:03aARM Holdings up 4.6% after results
3:03aGerman DAX 30 index up 0.7% to 6,487.30
3:02aBanco Santander up 1.5% after results
3:01aFrench CAC 40 index up 1% to 3,298.57
3:01aFTSE 100 index up 0.7% to 5,712.95
3:01aStoxx Europe 600 index up 0.6% to 253.95
2:42aBanco Santander 4Q net interest income EUR7.97B
2:41aBanco Santander 4Q net profit EUR47 million
2:38aEuro gains on Greek hopes; yen extends climb
2:31aARM posts profit of 33 million as sales rise 21%
2:14aMorgan Stanley buys Fairfax Media stake: report
2:12aARM: FY dollar revenues seen at just over $860M
2:11aARM: Global uncertainy could hit industry sales
2:09aARM Holdings 4Q sales 137.8 million pounds
2:08aARM Holdings Q4 net profit 33 million pounds
Loading more headlines... dow /quotes/zigman/627449 12,653.72 -6.74 -0.05% nasdaq /quotes/zigman/123127 2,811.94 +6.66 +0.24% s&p 500 /quotes/zigman/3870025 1,313.01 -3.32 -0.25% Kiosk 1326845100000 1326931800000The Trading Deck
Michael A. Gayed Fed paranoia is bullish...for now The possibility for anything inflation-sensitive to do well now exists because the conditions favor a return to higher inflation. /conga/kiosk/trading-deck-2.html 189875 1309370400000 1309428000000SportsWatch
Super Bowl ads go social Facebook app will let members exchange and discuss ads during NFL championship broadcast. "¢ MarketWatch's sports coverage/conga/kiosk/wildcard4.html 189748 1325088600000 1325142000000
Asian Currencies
Can gold save the rupee? India's currency suffered a heavy drop last year and some say gold is to blame. "¢ International yuan | Irrepressible yen "¢ Aussie may fall before it rises /conga/kiosk/wildcard2.html 189750 1310436000000 1310436000000Games
Pick ... trade ... win! Join MarketWatch's quarterly earnings-focused stock competition. Beat thepros and MarketWatch experts to win prizes. "¢ Week 3 results: Winning with Netflix /conga/kiosk/games.html 189870 1309191300000 13092480000002012 Tax Guide
How you can file for free You can go with the IRS's Free File Alliance or directly to top tax-prep sites, many of which offer free basic services. "¢ Top tax sites online: How to choose /conga/kiosk/wildcard3.html 189703 1326382200000 1326413400000The Trading Deck
MEENA KRISHNAMSETTY Six stocks to buy now Goldman Sachs names six stocks to consider buying now, alongside two stocks that look like good sell candidates. Get the details here. /conga/kiosk/trading-deck-1.html 189878 MarketWatch.com Site Index Topics Help Feedback Newsroom Roster Media Archive Premium Products Mobile Company Info Code of Conduct Corrections Advertising Media Kit Advertise Locally License our Content Broker Center Your Ad Choices MarketWatch on Facebook MarketWatch on Twitter RSS Podcasts WSJ.com Barron's Online BigCharts Virtual Stock Exchange All Things Digital MarketWatch Community Financial News Online WSJ.com Small Business FINS: Finance, IT jobs, Sales jobs Read Full Article »